Turkey of the week: overheating copper stock

The price of copper soared to an all high time high recently. But Paul Hill thinks copper miners, including this one, could be about to get their fingers burnt.

Back in 2003, Alan Greenspan, the last chairman of the Federal Reserve, slashed interest rates to 1%. He was aiming to protect the American economy from recession. However, an unintended consequence of this policy was to fire up the US housing bubble, which eventually caused the 2008 crisis.

Now the Fed is doing it again. The official aim of its quantitative easing (QE) programme is to reduce bond yields and pump up asset prices. On the latter front, QE has proved a resounding success at least in the commodities market. Spot copper prices blasted through all-time highs of $10,000 a ton last week.

But QE's unintended side-effects are now seeping through. As commodity and food prices have soared, so governments in politically sensitive regions are toppling. There has been an uprising in Egypt, one of America's staunchest allies in the area close to the Middle East. And several other countries, including Jordan, look vulnerable.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE

Get 6 issues free

Sign up to Money Morning

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Sign up

This has to be a huge security worry for Washington. It could even trigger a reappraisal of its economic policy. So what's the biggest danger? Ending QE and watching US GDP drop by, say, 1% to 2%? Or commencing QE3, and perhaps allowing much of the Arab world, and maybe parts of Asia too, to fall into revolution? Sure, the arrival of democracy in dictatorships might sound great. But there's also the risk that anti-Western regimes ride into power.

As a result, I believe the odds of the Fed extending QE beyond June have decreased. Assuming I'm right, then without the abundant supply of free money, the juiced-up commodity markets are heading for a crash. That would be bad news for shareholders of Kazakhmys, whose share price has ballooned eightfold since November 2008.

Kazakhmys is Kazakhstan's top copper producer (60% of earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation, or EBITDA) and the tenth-largest worldwide. It has 16 mines across the country and sells around 40% of its output to China. It also produces significant quantities of other metals, including zinc, silver and gold. It spent $1.5bn in 2008 buying local power stations to secure its electricity supply. The group also owns a 26% stake in its compatriot, Eurasian Natural Resources whose shares have also shot up.

Kazakhmys (LSE: KAZ), rated OUTPERFORM by Macquarie


Kazakhmys is clearly heavily exposed to the metals bubble. But on top of this, there's the substantial geopolitical risk. Most of its assets are located in Kazakhstan, which was a former Soviet Republic and could even be affected by the current mess in north Africa. Worse still, as the local government owns a quarter of the group, there's the chance of a super-tax being introduced to fund social improvement schemes.

In terms of valuation, the stock is far too expensive for my liking. I would rate it on a through-cycle EBITDA multiple of five. After factoring in net debt of $585m, that gives an intrinsic worth of around £11 a share. A pre-close trading update is scheduled for 3 March, with the prelims out on the 29 March.

Recommendation: SELL at £16.00

Paul Hill also writes a weekly share-tipping newsletter, Precision Guided Investments

Paul gained a degree in electrical engineering and went on to qualify as a chartered management accountant. He has extensive corporate finance and investment experience and is a member of the Securities Institute.

Over the past 16 years Paul has held top-level financial management and M&A roles for blue-chip companies such as O2, GKN and Unilever. He is now director of his own capital investment and consultancy firm, PMH Capital Limited.

Paul is an expert at analysing companies in new, fast-growing markets, and is an extremely shrewd stock-picker.