An open-and-shut case: buy investment trusts

It's offical. Investments trusts are much better value than their higher fee-charging rivals such as unit trusts, says Adam Jourdan.

Here's some news that unit trust managers (and the financial advisers who sell their products) won't want you to hear. Over the last decade, investment trusts (also known as closed-end funds) have beaten their open-ended rivals (such as unit trusts and OEICs) in almost every area.

An updated report on the sector from financial advisory group Collins Stewart shows that over the ten years to 31 December 2011, "investment trusts have outperformed open-ended funds by a healthy margin in eight out of nine regional sectors, and relevant benchmarks in seven". The only sector where investment trusts failed to come out on top was in Japan. Over the same period, unit trusts underperformed their benchmarks on average in every sector. Five- and one-year results were similar.

In the financial world it's rare to see quite such an open-and-shut case: investment trusts have clearly been far better vehicles to invest in than their open-ended rivals. There are several reasons for this, but the most obvious one is that their management fees tend to be lower, sometimes by a full percentage point or more. It makes sense that if less money is taken by the managers, then there will be more left in the pot for you, the investor.

Yet, despite this clear outperformance, the investment trust sector seems to have passed ordinary investors by. While the total value of the OEIC and unit trust sector has grown by 142% from £236bn to £571bn over the past ten years, the investment trust sector has seen far more pedestrian growth, increasing by 33% from £68bn to £90.3bn. Why the gap?

MoneyWeek videos


Why we like investment trusts


Investing in funds: why we prefer investment trusts to unit trusts.

Watch all of Tim's videos here

It's simple: money. Open-ended funds pay commission. Investment trusts, by and large, don't. That's why they're generally cheaper than unit trusts. It's also why financial advisers have tended to ignore them. The good news is that with a ban on commission set to come in with the Retail Distribution Review at the end of this year, this could be a "golden opportunity" for investment trusts to get the exposure they deserve, says Collins Stewart. Given their better track records and lower total expense ratios, it shouldn't be difficult for fund managers to make the case for them.

Meanwhile, until commission is banned, do your own research into what's available. As Jeff Prestridge notes on Thisismoney.co.uk: "If you use an adviser and they say an equivalent unit trust is a better option, tell them it's your best interests they should be looking after, not theirs."

Recommended

Why the market is wrong about private equity
Investment trusts

Why the market is wrong about private equity

When it comes to listed private-equity trusts, investors are overly sceptical, with many funds trading at heavy discounts to their net asset values. B…
9 Aug 2022
A low-risk way to beat inflation
Share tips

A low-risk way to beat inflation

Demand for care-home places is strong and the sector should be able to raise prices ahead of costs, says Max King.
8 Aug 2022
Asia: long-term opportunities amid short-term noise
Advertisement Feature

Asia: long-term opportunities amid short-term noise

In a tough first half of the year for financial markets, Asia has struggled more than most. But that weakness may represent an opportunity for invest…
26 Jul 2022
Analysis: it’s been a terrible six months for investment trusts
Investment trusts

Analysis: it’s been a terrible six months for investment trusts

The first half of the year has not been kind to investment trusts because of their skew towards growth stocks and the global downturn, says Max King. …
25 Jul 2022

Most Popular

Are UK house prices finally heading for a crash?
House prices

Are UK house prices finally heading for a crash?

The latest house price figures show a fall of 0.1% in July. With interest rates rising, inflation hitting double figures and a recession on the cards,…
5 Aug 2022
A low-risk way to beat inflation
Share tips

A low-risk way to beat inflation

Demand for care-home places is strong and the sector should be able to raise prices ahead of costs, says Max King.
8 Aug 2022
Where to find inflation-resistant stocks
Investment strategy

Where to find inflation-resistant stocks

Terry Smith’s latest update contains some valuable pointers for investors looking to protect against inflation.
8 Aug 2022