A high-risk bet on the rise of mobile money

Mobile phone banking © Getty Images
Mobile money: set to be huge

If you’re a fairly small company, forming a partnership with a corporate giant can make a huge difference.

The classic example is Microsoft’s partnership with IBM in the 1980s. Once IBM started using Microsoft’s operating system in its early PCs, Microsoft was well on the way to global domination. Arm’s partnership with Apple in the early 1990s is another good example. Without that link-up, Arm would probably never have become the UK’s leading technology company.

So last week I was excited to see that IBM has announced a partnership deal with a UK technology company called Monitise.

Now, I’m not suggesting that Monitise will be the next Microsoft.

But the IBM deal does mean that the stock definitely warrants further investigation…

What does Monitise actually do?

Monitise (LSE: MONI) is a ‘mobile money’ company. Its software enables users to manage their finances on their mobiles. This means users can check their bank accounts on a mobile as well as make transfers and payments. The Monitise technology also enables different financial institutions to ‘talk’ to each other and facilitate financial transactions.

Monitise offers three main products. The first is ‘Bank Anywhere’, which enables users to check their bank accounts on their mobiles. The second is ‘Pay Anyone’ which gives users the freedom to pay bills from anyone to anywhere.

These two products have enabled Monitise to build working relationships with more than 350 financial institutions worldwide.  These include Royal Bank of Scotland, Visa, MasterCard and HSBC. Its relationship with Visa has been especially close – Visa Europe owns a 6% stake in Monitise, while Visa in the US has 5%.

Monitise is also working with some non-financial companies too – the best-known is Telefonica. There’s plenty of potential here for mobile phone networks to use the ‘Pay Anyone’ technology and muscle in on the banks’ traditional monopoly in payment services.

The third product is called ‘Buy Anything’. It’s a secure shopping platform for mobiles.

In July, Monitise announced a deal with IBM which was then strengthened last week. The partnership means that IBM will now market Monitise technology under the IBM brand to a wide range of businesses, including retailers and mobile phone networks.

Some of Monitise’s staff will move across to IBM, and Monitise products will now include some IBM technology. Monitise technology will now be hosted at IBM ‘big data’ centres.

There are no guarantees here, but I think this partnership with IBM could deliver a big boost to Monitise’s growth. It’s also worth noting that IBM has a partnership with Apple to market the iPhone as the best mobile offering for business – that may open up further opportunities for Monitise.


Sign up for a 4-week FREE trial of MoneyWeek magazine

MoneyWeek magazine signup

"The only financial publication I could not be without."
John Lang, Director, Tower Hill Associates Ltd.


I have tipped Monitise shares before

If you’re a keen reader of MoneyWeek magazine, you may remember that I tipped Monitise in an article called ‘Five small cap stocks worth a flutter’ back in February. The shares were trading at 68p at that point – they’ve fallen to 48p since then.

That amply illustrates some of the risks you take when you invest in small caps. So what was behind the fall?

The company had warned that revenue would be about 30% below expectations for the year ending June 2014. Monitise’s explanation for the fall was that it had adjusted its business model.

Previously, customers were expected to pay a large upfront free, and then pay much smaller recurring licensing fees. Monitise is now charging smaller or non-existent upfront fees in exchange for higher recurring payments later on.

I must say that this seems like a sensible move to me. The change should mean that more customers will sign up as they won’t have to pay so much money upfront. All being well, it should enable Monitise to make more money in the long term as the recurring payments continue to be made.

That said, even after this year’s fall in the share price, Monitise looks expensive at first glance. The company isn’t making any profit, and that isn’t likely to change until 2016. Full-year results are expected later this month, but it looks like revenue will come in around the £93m mark.

With a £961m market cap, that will put Monitise on a very hefty price/sales ratio of ten. The ratio is so high that I can’t help thinking back to the mad dotcom days of 1999/2000, when so many tech companies were overvalued.

What’s more, Monitise could get squeezed out by competitors. There’s lots of speculation that the likes of Google and Facebook will want to enter the mobile banking space. If that does indeed happen, there are no guarantees that these big tech companies will partner with Monitise.

And although I think there’s a strong chance that Monitise will become a major player in mobile banking, it may be tougher to become a major player in mobile commerce where there’s more competition. (That said, Monitise’s recent acquisition of the company behind the Myvouchercodes website, Markco Media, may help in this area.)

It’s also worth noting that Monitise is one of the most shorted shares on the London stock market. In other words, a lot of investors have placed a bet that the Monitise share price will fall.

But I’d still rate Monitise a high-risk buy

But, despite the high valuation and other potential risks, I think that Monitise is an attractive, high-risk growth play.

Yes, it could all go wrong. But I’m in no doubt that mobile banking and mobile commerce will grow rapidly from here, and the IBM deal makes me more confident that Monitise can be a major player in this area.

It’s also clear to me that mobile banking itself is going to become far more important within our day-to-day money management. My colleague David Thornton over at Red Hot Penny Shares has been focusing on this sector a great deal recently. You can read more about exactly what’s got David excited about it in his special report here.

• Red Hot Penny Shares is a regulated product issued by Fleet Street Publications Ltd. Your capital is at risk when you invest in shares; never risk more than you can afford to lose. Forecasts are not a reliable indicator of future results. Penny shares can be riskier than other investments – they can be relatively hard to trade and if you need to sell soon after you’ve bought you might get less back than you paid. Please seek independent financial advice if necessary. Customer Services: 0207 633 3601.

This article is taken from our FREE daily investment email Money Morning.
Receive our thought-provoking investment email every weekday morning plus occasional promotions & become a smarter investor.

Please enter a valid email address

To sign-up enter your email address.




• Stay up to date with MoneyWeek: Follow us on TwitterFacebook and Google+

Our recommended articles for today

Emerging markets: These three charts show we’re in a bull market

Early 2013 was a bad time for investors in emerging markets. But since then, they’ve been on a roll, says Lars Henriksson. And here’s the proof.

This technology could soon replace your bank account

New ‘mobile banking’ technology is threatening the lucrative business model of the traditional banks. It’s a change that can’t come too soon, says Bengt Saelensminde.

On this day in history

2 September 1666: The Great Fire of London starts

On this day in 1666, the Great Fire of London started on Pudding Lane. The fire raged for four days, laying waste to much of the city.

4 Responses

  1. 02/09/2014, mikeT wrote

    Am I the only one confused by this? I can already access my online accounts via a mobile with a high street bank and make payments etc. Why is this different?

  2. 03/09/2014, NeutronWarp9 wrote

    Because I can access your high street bank using your online account MikeT.

  3. 04/09/2014, mikeT wrote

    Thanks NeutronWarp9. Not very helpful but very pertinent. (Also -apologies – I think I reported your comment by clicking on the button by mistake. I didn’t mean it.)

  4. 04/09/2014, hairy wrote

    In your article you say that the share price when you originally tiped Monitise in Febuary was 68p and now its 48p but according to a chart I looked at, the share price in Febuary was £1.10 and currently its about 76pence
    Please explain.

    Also there is a similar article in Money Week dated 4th September .. is this article referring also to Montise?

Comment on this article