Profit from gold miners without investing in a mine

What do you think the price of gold will be in a year’s time?

I’ve no idea. Your guess will probably be at least as good as mine.

But it’s fair to say that the Western world is in a bit of a mess. Years of over-spending and borrowing too much have left many nations with crippling debts. Conditions are ripe for a nasty depression and years of falling prices.

While that would be painful, it’s probably what the economy actually needs. It would shut down a lot of bad businesses (including many banks), while falling prices would make us more cost competitive. It would also force the government to face facts – it is way too big and needs to slim down.

But this is unlikely to happen soon. The vested interests of politicians and the banking classes mean that the hard decisions will be avoided. A deflationary bust is their worst nightmare. Instead they will turn to the printing presses and destroy the value of our money.

This is why it makes sense to own some gold. But what’s the best way to do it?

A halfway house between mining shares and physical gold

We’ve been advising you to hold physical gold for a long time. This can be done by buying bullion yourself, or perhaps through a physically-backed gold exchange traded fund (ETF).

Another alternative is to buy the shares of gold mining companies. The theory here is that if the gold price rises, the profits of miners will rise even faster. This process is known as operational gearing. So you should make more money by owning gold miners than by owning plain old physical gold.

That’s the theory. Like many theories, it doesn’t always quite work out in practice. In recent years, gold miners have been underwhelming compared to gold itself. That’s mainly because the cost of getting the stuff out of the ground has soared.

We still like miners: as a sector, they look cheap, and when gold gets to the ‘bubble’ stage, they’ll rocket.

But if you’re looking for a halfway house between a miner and a gold bar, there is one type of share you could take a look at. I’m talking about gold royalty or streaming companies.

What are gold royalty stocks?

Building and developing a gold mine can be expensive. Mining companies often don’t want to borrow money from banks as the terms are often too restrictive. So they turn to investors, such as gold royalty companies, instead.

These companies give the miners the money they need to help build their business. In return, the royalty company gets a percentage of the output of the mine for a specified period of time. For example, a royalty may be 5% of sales. So at $1,700 per ounce of gold at an output of 50,000 ounces, the royalty company would receive an income stream of $4.25m.

Another alternative is for the company to get a gold stream. This usually means having to invest a lot more money in the mine than under a royalty agreement. Here, the company agrees to buy a proportion of the mine’s output for a fixed price for a fixed period of time.

Let’s say it agrees to buy the first 10,000 ounces at a fixed price of $400 per ounce. In this case, at $1,700 per ounce, the streaming company would receive an income of $13m. (($1,700-$400) x 10,000). As the company has very little overheads, most of this income gets converted into profit.

The beauty of gold royalty and streaming companies is that they are not exposed to the running costs of the mine. If the costs go through the roof, they will not lose out like the owners of gold mining shares. But if the gold price goes up, they make lots of money.

There are other benefits too. Because they usually have interests in lots of mining companies, you take on less risk. Gold royalty companies also often benefit from production increases, as their money has been invested in mines that are still being developed.

So if you believe that the gold price is going to go up a lot, then these companies could make serious amounts of money. And during the last four years, compared to a basket of gold mining stocks, the share prices of gold royalty companies have gone ballistic.

Are royalty stocks too expensive?

Stock Share price Market value Est p/e Est profit growth
Royal Gold $86.8 $5.6bn 46.3 45.09%
Franco Nevada $59.6 $8.7bn 48.8 37.56%
Sandstorm Gold $13.75 $1.2bn 47.4 68.92%

Prices as of 14/11/2012

That’s left the shares of gold royalty companies looking horribly expensive, as you can see from the table above. Normally, I wouldn’t dream of buying the shares of a company trading at nearly 50 times earnings. In fact, usually I’d say you’d have to be mad to do so.

But I’m not sure that you should ignore these companies. All of them expect to have a bigger share of mine production in the years ahead.

Sandstorm Gold should get its hands on around 34,000 ounces of gold this year but expects this to grow to 60,000 ounces by 2015. It can do so at a cash cost of just over $400 an ounce.

Royal Gold has interests in 202 gold developments, of which only 39 are currently in production. Its agreed cash costs to buy gold are even lower.

If you believe that the gold price is going to go up due to central bank money printing, then the cash flows of these companies could soar and today’s lofty share prices could end up looking very cheap. An added bonus is that they have invested in reasonably safe countries such as Canada, USA, Mexico, Brazil, Chile and Australia.

There’s still risk of course. Mine production might fall short of targets. The gold price could collapse. Cash-strapped governments might decide to tax the profits of gold mines more. But overall, if you are bullish on the gold price, it makes sense to have at least some of the money you’ve earmarked for precious metals in a gold royalty company or two.

Our recommended articles for today

How much debt does it take to sink a company?

Taking on debt can give companies several advantages, but too much debt can be disastrous. So what is the tipping point, and what should you as an investor watch out for? Tim Bennett explains.

How long can this farce continue?

Markets have finally come to terms with ultra-low interest rates. That makes investing all the more risky, says Bengt Saelensminde. Here, he explains why, and how you can still profit.

  • dlp6666

    Are there any well-managed funds/trusts that have good exposure to these royalty stocks (bit wary of buying them individually)?

  • Golden Bull

    I see Sandstorm has dropped nearly 9% today. Any reason for this? I’m sure Phil’s share picks don’t have that much of an affect on stock price!

  • Roger

    Sandstorm, PE 56.5, dividend 0, it requires a lot of currage to buy things like that. All the others, PE 40ish, good luck with lots of gold price increases.

  • Jaspal

    @dlp6666 – it appears Franco Nevada is one of the top 10 holdings in Blackrock Gold & General

  • Boris MacDonut

    Phil. You colleague Dom Frisby told us only last week that gold should hit $6,000 by the end of the Obama presidency and will go on to reach £10,000 ($16,000) thereafter. He confidently predicts $1,800 for the end of Nov 2012, so 5% in just the next two weeks…….according to the MW gold expert.But you say our guess is as good as yours. Do you think Dom is a bit too hopeful?

  • 4caster

    Boris, you’ve hit the nail on the head as usual.
    The XAU Index of gold mining shares has dropped some 8% in the last two days. The metal has also fallen, but not as much as that. This always happens when the gold bulls get excited and start predicting large rises. That is one thing I have learnt since I resumed investing in gold and its mines in 2003. Another thing I have learnt is that people like Dominic Frisby will go to ground until they think we have forgotten their gaffes. If he is right in the long term, it will be because the bottom has fallen out of the dollar, so sterling investors will not see anything like these gains. But personally I see the dollar remaining king, now that the US is going hell-for-leather to exploit its new-found shale oil and gas deposits. And to hell with us all when all that extra CO2 gets pumped into the atmosphere. Never mind the dollar price of gold; the sterling price will eventually reward us well.

  • goldsolutions

    Thanks for telling me what are gold royalty stocks