Investing in space: a fund for the final frontier

Early next month sees the launch of a new exchange-traded fund (ETF) that aims to boldly go where no other ETF has gone before: space. ETF specialists HANetf and Procure Innovation are about to launch the Procure Space UCITS ETF in London with the irresistible ticker of YODA. 

Inevitably, science-fiction geeks focus on the adventurous end of this well-established industry, notably missions to Mars and the moon. And much of the time SpaceX, Elon Musk’s rocket company, crops up in the discussion. 

In April, for instance Nasa announced that it had selected the company’s Starship vehicle as the lunar lander for its Artemis programme to return to the moon. Musk’s launch business was up against Jeff Bezos-backed Blue Origin and Dynetics.

A tiny market

For all the excitement, however, the space launch market is tiny. By some estimates it is only worth around $6bn. And prices have been dropping like a failed rocket as competition has intensified. 

Defence contractors involved in the sector, such as the United Launch Alliance of Boeing and Lockheed Martin, have felt the strain. 

According to a recent Economist report on the sector, this long-established alliance recently cut jobs and costs as the price for rockets was reduced from $225m a launch to just over $100m. SpaceX has been able to undercut its rivals, charging $62m for a fresh rocket or $50m for a used one.

For the time being, the key area to watch may be a more terrestrial market: broadband. Huge swathes of the UK are struggling to be connected to fibre-optic internet networks. BT and its Openreach business says its has plans to fill the gap but most rural customers are rightly suspicious. Enter space internet. Sending internet signals through satellite dishes is another way to supply areas that have struggled to get connected. SpaceX’s Starlink programme has recently been introduced in several rustic areas in the UK and although pricing isn’t exactly a bargain at £89 a month plus the cost of buying a dish, speeds are much more impressive. 

And Starlink isn’t the only service chasing this market. The government has backed OneWeb, a satellite business that went bust but has recently been relaunched. Like SpaceX, it is planning a low-orbit network of smaller satellites that will give fast, comprehensive coverage to rural areas. SpaceX is rumoured to be planning as many as 42,000 satellites in all. 

However, the business model at OneWeb seems to be slightly different. Its base stations are more expensive and likely to be aimed at existing broadband providers, who will then distribute traffic to local customers via local Wi-Fi networks.

Yet even within this huge broadband-connectivity market, challenges remain. Plenty of other businesses have attempted to tap this market and gone bust in the process. Iridium went under trying to offer similar services as has Intelsat and Speedcast, all using higher-orbit satellite networks. Unlike many tech-based business models, this is a high-risk investment proposition with massive upfront costs and increasing competition.

Cash is pouring into the space sector 

But it’s also clear that the space industry is attracting ever more investment, not all of it from tech billionaires such as Musk and Bezos. According to Seraphim Capital, a venture-capital group, the sector attracted $8.7bn of venture investment in the year to March 2021, up by 95% from the year before. 

SpaceX is the highest-profile private investment in this area. The Economist reports that in its latest funding round, completed in April, the business was valued at $74bn, up from $46bn in August 2020. UK-listed venture capital outfit Schiehallion (managed by Baillie Gifford and quoted on the specialist-funds segment of the London Stock Exchange) has about 5% of its fund invested in SpaceX.

These numbers suggest that a large number of savvy investors think that this new commercial space sector is about to grow rapidly, despite the many and obvious challenges. This is a classic disruptive sector that boasts what I would call the joker card – niches such as launch or rural broadband are likely to be tough, competitive markets but at some stage someone in the sector will come up with a set of products that sparks a huge commercial opportunity, kicking off a new space race of possibly epic proportions. Whether that entails supplying broadband to northern Scotland or African communities, or paying space tourists (or even mining asteroids) I don’t know, but there is the sense that something big is coming. Whether that justifies the valuations on many of these businesses I will leave to your judgement. 

A wide-ranging portfolio

But this ETF is a sensible way of accessing the niche via a portfolio of around 30 stocks. It includes the full range of industry players varying from long-established satellite network operators to businesses engaged in the early stages of space tourism. 

The index powering the fund has some rigorous rules to make it properly space-oriented as opposed to a fund claiming to invest in space but actually focusing merely on aerospace and defence. 

According to the index rules, to be included in the index, space-related revenue must either account for at least 20% of the total or exceed $500m annually. Crucially, 80% of the index is allocated to companies that generate 50% (but typically 100%) of their annual sales from space-related activities. 

The remaining fifth of the index is allocated to diversified companies that generate less than 50% of total revenues from space-related businesses: in terms of geographical mix, 70% of the value of the fund is US based and 30% international. 

Clearly this is one only for the truly adventurous amongst you willing to place a small bet on an exciting industry that is quite literally going places. I am not sure that the valuations ascribed to SpaceX make sense but it is worth recalling that plenty of people said that about Tesla and were wrong. My hope is that all the investment interest does finally result in products and business services that are useful for the rest of us, especially in rura