Three ideas for Lloyds Bank's new boss

The Black Horse needs whipping into shape. A change at the top provides a great opportunity, says Matthew Lynn.

António Horta-Osório did a decent enough job as chief executive of Lloyds Bank. But whether shareholders will be all that sorry to see him leave office is open to question. The bank is back on a stable footing, but it has hardly been making a fortune for investors. Over the last five years the shares have plunged from 80p to 30p and while much of that was lost during the Covid-19 crisis, the price was still at 60p before any of us had heard of Wuhan. With the dividend now scrapped for this year in response to the epidemic, it has hardly been a great asset to own. After all that, shareholders might well feel it is time for a change. 

Safe and dull is not good enough

Whoever takes on the job will inherit a leading position in the UK’s retail finance market. Including the Halifax and Bank of Scotland brands, Lloyds has 22 million current accounts, making it the largest in the UK, and it is also the biggest mortgage lender, with a quarter of the market for home loans. There is a problem, however. All Horta-Osório has really managed to do in his decade in charge is get the group back to where it was before the crash – a safe, steady but dull retail bank. That isn’t going to be good enough for the 2020s. Retail banking needs radical reinvention. Here are three ideas for his successor. 

First, Lloyds needs to keep closing branches. Ignore the campaigners who try to keep them open and brush aside the lobbyists who argue cash needs to be protected. It is not the job of a bank to save the high street, or to keep a system of payment alive after it has become technologically obsolete. After the Covid-19 crisis, local branches are going to be more irrelevant than ever. Apart from collecting cash from small businesses – and even the smallest of them are rapidly embracing contactless cards – a bank branch doesn’t have much to do anymore. And in a world where cash is dying out, cash machines are increasingly irrelevant. But the branch network is still a huge cost. The best companies don’t simply react to change, but get ahead of it. Lloyds can only do that by closing branches quickly. 

Next, work out how to respond to technology. Traditional retail banks are under assault from every direction. App-based start-ups are providing far simpler, better-designed current accounts. Fintech companies are chipping away at once-lucrative lines of business such as currency transfers and small-business lending (insurance will be next). The technology giants are increasingly moving into finance. Amazon has launched a current account, Apple and Google have payment systems and Facebook has even tried to launch its own currency. The start-ups have agility on their side and the tech giants have a mass of customer data, and deploy it brilliantly. A traditional retail bank has some residual strengths, such as a customer base, a payment system and lots of relationships. It has to figure out how best to use them. 

Time for a rebranding

Finally, it needs to reinvent its brand. All the high-street banks spend a fortune on marketing and Lloyds is no exception. Sure, it has a lot of name recognition, but there is not much in the way of affection, or respect, and customers are only loyal because it is usually a hassle to switch account. Decades of mis-selling products and sneaky charges have trashed the trust between banks and their customers and, apart from paying out billions in compensation, not much has been done to fix that. A brand needs to stand for something solid. It could be trust, or innovation, or value – or something else entirely. But the bank needs to work out what it is, and how to make it happen. 

Over the next few weeks there will be lots of speculation about who will replace Horta-Osório. The name doesn’t matter as much as whether he or she will be willing to push for a radical change of direction. If Lloyds makes an ambitious choice, it might be able to reinvent a tired business model – and set an example that the rest of the banking industry can follow. 

Recommended

The FTSE 100 is set for a makeover with an influx of new tech stocks
UK stockmarkets

The FTSE 100 is set for a makeover with an influx of new tech stocks

The FTSE 100 – the dullest index in the world – is about to reinvent itself as a host of new firms list on the market. The change is long overdue, say…
24 Jan 2021
Share tips of the week
Share tips

Share tips of the week

MoneyWeek’s comprehensive guide to the best of this week’s share tips from the rest of the UK's financial pages.
22 Jan 2021
Lockdown hammers commercial landlord Hammerson
Property

Lockdown hammers commercial landlord Hammerson

Three quarters of the tenants of shopping-centre operator Hammerson have been forced to close during the lockdown.
21 Jan 2021
Volatile Christmas trading leaves more of a mess at retailer M&S
UK stockmarkets

Volatile Christmas trading leaves more of a mess at retailer M&S

Last year was grim for retailers, while M&S, the clothing sector’s chronic underperformer, struggled at Christmas too. Matthew Partridge reports.
15 Jan 2021

Most Popular

The FTSE 100 is set for a makeover with an influx of new tech stocks
UK stockmarkets

The FTSE 100 is set for a makeover with an influx of new tech stocks

The FTSE 100 – the dullest index in the world – is about to reinvent itself as a host of new firms list on the market. The change is long overdue, say…
24 Jan 2021
Why we won’t see a house-price crash in 2021
House prices

Why we won’t see a house-price crash in 2021

Lockdown sent house prices berserk as cooped up home-workers fled for bigger properties in the country. And while they won’t rise quite as much this y…
18 Jan 2021
Think Tesla is a bubble? This might be the best way to bet on it bursting
Oil

Think Tesla is a bubble? This might be the best way to bet on it bursting

The huge rise in Tesla’s share price means that, by market value, it’s now the sixth-largest company in the US and and the world’s biggest car-maker. …
25 Jan 2021