Editor's letter

Why the government should stop messing about and just abolish stamp duty

If Boris Johnson is serious about getting more people on the housing ladder, he should stop messing about with complicated incentives that only reward housebuilders, and get rid of stamp duty.

UK house prices rose by 7.3% year-on-year last month, reports Halifax. That’s not enough for Boris Johnson. He’d like them to go higher. How do we know? Because this week he announced a new plan to raise demand for them – and barring a sudden explosion in supply, a sudden rise in demand will push up prices. The idea – to introduce a state-sponsored scheme of long-term, fixed-rate, low-deposit mortgages – isn’t all bad. There is no reason why we shouldn’t have long-term fixes in the UK. It isn’t how our system currently works. Our banks tend to borrow and hence lend out over much shorter cycles; and we have a dug-in system of using mortgage brokers to find products – they too prefer to flog us loans every five years rather than every 25. But it’s perfectly possible – and sensible too. 

The trickier bit is the idea of making these mortgages 95% loan-to-value (LTV), with the government guaranteeing the 5% deposit. The detail is not clear here (at all), but the idea that government should guarantee deposits is not new (the endless and awful Help to Buy scheme has set the precedent). However, it still misses two points.

The first is that deposits aren’t just there to protect lenders (a problem that can be easily solved by re-introducing some kind of mortgage insurance) – they protect buyers too. If house prices fall, 5% is not much of a margin between security and the sleepless nights of negative equity – that’s why lenders (already buried under mortgage holidays) are retreating from high LTV loans right now. Johnson says he wants everyone to feel the “joy and pride” of home ownership. Neither exists in a negative equity crisis. 

The second is that while it is clear that raising the cash needed to buy a house is hard, it isn’t just the deposit. It’s also the stamp duty. Buy a home in England or Northern Ireland for £400,000 (in normal times – houses under £500,000 are stamp duty exempt for now) and you’ll pay £20,000-£40,000 in deposit. That’s hard enough to save. But the stamp duty is another £10,000 – in cash and due on completion. You can’t add it to your mortgage. 

So here’s an idea for a libertarian government that wants to step out of more markets than it wants to step into – and that wants to prove it is less in thrall to the lobbying skills of housebuilders than its predecessor (no one wins from a house-buying subsidy more than a supplier of houses). How about skipping the “guarantee this and guarantee that” approach and just abolish stamp duty? 

This isn’t a time for losing tax revenue, but you could replace the losses either with a small capital gains tax on primary homes (at least then you are taxing the people in the deal who have the money already) or by switching the stamp duty payment to the sellers (again, the ones who already have the money). 

You can argue (I have – see here) that cutting stamp duty does not necessarily cut the overall cost of a house (the seller just puts the price up to the new level the buyer can afford). But it does (like Boris’s plan) at least reduce the cash-upfront problem and hence open the market to more cash-poor buyers. It’s a lot easier too – and based on recent events it seems that the very last thing this government needs is to attempt to create any new and even-a-little-bit-complicated schemes involving spreadsheets. Enough of that.

Recommended

Will energy prices go down in 2023?
Personal finance

Will energy prices go down in 2023?

The Energy Price Guarantee will now be extended, but how much will your gas and electricity cost you in 2023?
9 Dec 2022
Average monthly rent is up £117 from last year, says Zoopla
Personal finance

Average monthly rent is up £117 from last year, says Zoopla

Rental unaffordability for single renters is the highest in over a decade.
9 Dec 2022
UK house prices see their biggest fall since 2008
House prices

UK house prices see their biggest fall since 2008

Halifax’s latest house price index shows UK house prices fell by 2.3% in November
7 Dec 2022
Which house-price index is the best?
Property

Which house-price index is the best?

Britain is obsessed with house prices, and we have at least four house-price indices to choose from to measure the rate of increase in the value of ou…
7 Dec 2022

Most Popular

Is it cheaper to leave the heating on low all day?
Personal finance

Is it cheaper to leave the heating on low all day?

The weather is getting colder and energy bills are rising, but is it really cheaper to leave the heating on low all day or should you only turn it on …
1 Dec 2022
Radiator vs electric heater – which is cheaper?
Personal finance

Radiator vs electric heater – which is cheaper?

We compare the costs, pros and cons of radiators and electric heaters and see which one will help keep your energy bill as low as possible.
28 Nov 2022
The pros and cons of smart meters – should you switch?
Personal finance

The pros and cons of smart meters – should you switch?

A smart meter can help you keep tabs on your energy usage, but is it better than a regular meter? We take a look at smart meters vs regular meters.
2 Dec 2022