The art market endures after a jittery 2019

Wealthy Americans stepped up to help calm the art market's jitters in 2019. Chris Carter reports.

There were some big art sales in 2019, but much of the action came within a month. Claude Monet’s Meules (1890) sold for $110.7m in New York with Sotheby’s in May, raising the nominal price bar for an Impressionist painting. That price was far in excess of the estimated $55m – a valuation that was 22 times higher than its previous auction sale price in 1986, but one that was justified in the eyes of Sotheby’s Impressionist department head August Uribe. It was, he said, “the best one” of the 25 paintings in the Haystacks series, still in private hands.

So maybe it wasn’t all that surprising that it made nine figures. After all, pre-sale estimates tend to be conservative and another painting from the series had sold for $81.4m in 2016 with Christie’s. The problem is, it was the only art work to make nine figures in 2019. And it only made nine figures once the fees had been added (the “hammer price” was $97m). Nonetheless, May also saw Jeff Koons’s Rabbit (1986) fetch a record price for a work by a living artist – $91.1m at Christie’s, again in New York. Robert Rauschenberg’s Buffalo II (1964) sold for $88.8m and Andy Warhol’s Double Elvis [Ferus Type] (1963) fetched $53m. That same month, Sotheby’s in New York sold a Pablo Picasso (Femme au chien, 1962), a Francis Bacon (Study for a head, 1952) and a Mark Rothko (Untitled, 1960), each for over $50m. All in all, not bad. “Wealthy Americans showed their backbone,” as Melanie Gerlis put it in the Financial Times.

Thank goodness they did. Trade wars, the threat of recession and uncertainty over Brexit had looked at one point to have scared away the guarantors, as Abby Schultz noted in Barron’s Penta. These are the people who agree to stump up the money to buy a lot if it otherwise fails to sell at auction. Their presence injects confidence into the market. When they’re not there, the market gets rattled, but the auctioneers pulled through in the end. “Amid a challenging global environment, demand for art remains strong and is reflected in our 2019 results, especially for modern and contemporary art,” says Guillaume Cerutti, CEO at Christie’s. Yet at the start of 2020, those uncertainties haven’t gone away. Whether that demand remains strong will be the main question for this year.

Whisky breaks records

Rare whisky, on the other hand, went from strength to strength in 2019. Sotheby’s in London raised £7.6m from the sale of a single-owner collection in October, which also saw a new record set for a single bottle – another 1926 Macallan, this time costing £1.5m (different bottles of the 1926 have broken the record three times over the past two years). From 7-17 February, Whisky Auctioneer (whiskyauctioneer.com) is hosting a sale of 3,900 rare bottles of whisky. “Expect it to far exceed its lowball £7m-£8m estimate,” says whisky expert Fiona Shoop in The Daily Telegraph. It contains yet another 1926 Macallan.

The year art went bananas

Italian artist Maurizio Cattelan made headlines (most with puns) last month when he duct-taped a banana to a wall and then sold that “art installation” for $120,000. People queued up at the Perrotin gallery at Art Basel Miami Beach to take their picture with Comedian (as the banana was called). When it came to the turn of New York-based artist David Datuna, he peeled it off the wall and ate it. “Art performance by me. I love Maurizio Cattelan artwork and I really love this installation. It’s very delicious,” Datuna declared on Instagram. Luckily, Datuna “did not destroy the art work”, Lucien Terras, a director at the gallery, told the Miami Herald. “The banana is the idea.”

That’s right, says Jonathan Jones in The Guardian. In the tradition of Marcel Duchamp (the artist who put a urinal in a gallery and called it Fountain), Cattelan is mocking the art world. “Nowadays, art can’t get away from money,” says Jones. “That’s all anyone wants to know about it, and Dada gestures are part of the capitalist miracle.” Still, it’s no laughing matter for performance artist Rod Webber. After Perrotin removed the (restored) Comedian, Webber wrote on the blank wall in red lipstick: “Epstein didn’t kill himself”. He was arrested for vandalism. Artnet News reports he will appear in court next month. Webber has appealed to Datuna for help lest “a jury may be put in a position to legally decide what is and isn’t art”.

Auctions

Going…

Former Australian cricketer Shane Warne (on the left in our picture) put his beloved “baggy green cap” up for auction this week to raise money for those affected by the bushfires in Australia. The proceeds from the sale will be donated to the Red Cross’s disaster relief fund. Interest in the sale was so great that the Pickles auction website crashed soon after Warne announced the sale on Monday via Twitter, says Sky News. Bidders had until Thursday night to make their offer, with former England captain Michael Vaughan offering A$25,000 (£13,200). Warne wore the cap throughout his international test career from 1992 to 2007. The spin bowler hoped it would raise “some significant funds to help all those people that are in desperate need”.

Gone…

The Olympic Manifesto, the transcript of a speech made by Pierre de Coubertin in 1892, has become the most expensive item of sport memorabilia to be sold at auction. It fetched $8.8m at Sotheby’s in New York last month. In the handwritten transcript Coubertin spelled out his vision to see the Olympic Games of ancient Greece revived at the annual meeting of the Union des Sociétés Françaises de Sports Athlétiques. “Let us export rowers, runners and fencers; this is the free trade of the future, and the day that it is introduced into the everyday existence of old Europe, the cause of peace will receive new and powerful support,” he said. The first International Olympic Committee was set up 18 months later.

Recommended

Today's art markets are a paradise for bargain hunters
Alternative investments

Today's art markets are a paradise for bargain hunters

Now is an ideal time for collectors to go shopping at the art auctions. 
29 Nov 2019
Investing in art: where to find the best value in the art market today
Alternative investments

Investing in art: where to find the best value in the art market today

It’s been a record-breaking ten years for the art market – even Old Masters of questionable provenance are selling for hundreds of millions. But where…
15 Nov 2019
Lego: building profits from plastic bricks
Alternative investments

Lego: building profits from plastic bricks

The popularity of Lego boomed as bored workers twiddled their thumbs at home. Chris Carter reports
23 Sep 2020
Matchbox toys are on fire with collectors
Alternative investments

Matchbox toys are on fire with collectors

The children of the 1960s are fuelling a boom in collectable model cars, says Chris Carter.
4 Sep 2020

Most Popular

The rising dollar is proving bad news for most other assets – will it last?
Investment strategy

The rising dollar is proving bad news for most other assets – will it last?

Precious metals, stocks and pretty much every other asset has taken a tumble as the US dollar strengthens. Dominic Frisby looks at how long this trend…
23 Sep 2020
Oil producers are back at their Covid-19 lows – is it time to buy?
Oil

Oil producers are back at their Covid-19 lows – is it time to buy?

With demand for oil hammered by Covid-19 and talk of “peak oil demand”, there are lots of good reasons to be bearish on oil producers. So, asks John S…
22 Sep 2020
Why you should stuff your end-of-pandemic portfolio with Chinese stocks
China stockmarkets

Why you should stuff your end-of-pandemic portfolio with Chinese stocks

For an end-of-pandemic portfolio, you need assets that can cope with today’s volatility. And that, says Merryn Somerset Webb, means Chinese stocks.
14 Sep 2020