How Adam Smith predicted today’s wave of moral outrage

The rash of incivility, virtue signalling and outrage on social media is just the latest manifestation of a phenomenon Adam Smith knew only too well, says Merryn Somerset Webb.

Pro-EU and pro-Brexit protestors © Leon Neal/Getty Images

I tweeted a question this week about Greta Thunberg. I wondered if anyone knew how she was getting home from the US after her meetings there. I am interested. One way on a sailing boat was impressive (no cabins and no loos..). What next?

One of the first responses was pretty clear. "Fuck your cynicism", it said.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Become a smarter, better informed investor with MoneyWeek.

Interesting, isn't it? The young man in question (I'm going by his photo) was so convinced (for no obvious reason) that I disagree with him on something and that he is right on that thing that "Fuck your cynicism" seemed to him to be a perfectly reasonable thing to say to a middle-aged woman he doesn't know. I hope no one involved in parenting him follows him.

On the plus side for Adam Smith fans at least it is possible to see this little outburst of odd sweariness as just another example of the way in which Adam Smith forecast pretty much everything.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Consider this quote (my favourite at the moment): "Virtue is more to be feared than vice, because its excesses are not subject to the regulation of conscience." It's almost as though he invented Twitter and its epidemic of virtue signalling.

My Twitter correspondent need not refer to his conscience before being rude to me because he has, he believes, virtue on his side. You see this all over Twitter. But it isn't confined to the margins. The responses to Brexit are a classic of the virtue/vice genre.

Extreme Remainers feel free to spend years attempting to frustrate the 2016 referendum while referring to everyone who disagrees with them as a fascist because they believe that they have the moral high ground. If you know you are right absolutely 100% undoubtedly right it really doesn't matter how dirty you fight. It's ok to use every bit of arcane parliamentary procedure you can find to frustrate Brexit. Use some to try and push Brexit forward, however, and you are definitely an evil fascist dictator.

Extreme Brexiteers are often as guilty (different language, same dynamic).

It's the same in the US Bill Dudley can suggest, for example, that the Federal Reserve should get political and force the US into recession in order to get rid of Trump. Here's the relevant quote. "There's even an argument that the election itself falls within the Fed's purview. After all, Trump's reelection arguably presents a threat to the US and global economy, to the Fed's independence and its ability to achieve its employment and inflation objectives. If the goal of monetary policy is to achieve the best long-term economic outcome, then Fed officials should consider how their decisions will affect the political outcome in 2020."

There is no doubt that Dudley is about as anti-Trump as you can get, but there's a particular kind of madness in the suggestion that Trump is so awful and Dudley so very right that it is reasonable to forgo the political neutrality of the Fed to get rid of him. Nuts.

Advertisement - Article continues below

You can find examples of this kind of thing everywhere at the moment (it feels like more than usual but that might just be the Twitter effect). You could find that shocking; better, however, would be to use it as a reminder that human nature doesn't change and that Adam Smith was not just a great economist but one of the best observers of behaviour ever. If you haven't read Wealth of Nations and Moral Sentiments, now is as good a time as any.




How long can the good times roll?

Despite all the doom and gloom that has dominated our headlines for most of 2019, Britain and most of the rest of the developing world is currently en…
19 Dec 2019
Global Economy

The same changes are happening, just faster

From international relations to working from home, the coronavirus outbreak hasn't so much radically changed the world as sped up changes that were al…
2 Apr 2020
Global Economy

The MoneyWeek Podcast - Edward Chancellor: governments’ reaction to the virus will come back to haunt us

Merryn Somerset Webb talks to financial historian, investment strategist and author Edward Chancellor, and asks: are we doing the right thing, is it g…
31 Mar 2020
UK Economy

Debt jubilee: will our debts be written off?

The idea of a "debt jubilee" – general society-wide cancellation of debt – goes back to Biblical times. Could it happen again? And would it really do …
28 Mar 2020

Most Popular


Three things matter for the UK housing market now – and “location” isn’t one of them

The UK housing market is frozen. And when it does eventually thaw out, the traditional factors that drive prices will no longer apply. The day of reck…
1 Apr 2020

What does the coronavirus crisis mean for UK house prices?

With the whole country in lockdown, the UK property market is closed for business. John Stepek looks at what that means for UK house prices, housebuil…
27 Mar 2020

Has the stockmarket hit rock bottom yet?

The world's stockmarkets continue on their wild and disorientating rollercoaster ride. Investors are still gripped by fear. So, asks John Stepek, have…
2 Apr 2020
Small business

Furlough: what does it mean and how does it affect me?

Many companies have “furloughed” employees after they have shut down because of the coronavirus. But what does furlough mean and how does the scheme w…
30 Mar 2020