Why value stocks struggle during technological revolutions

History shows that value stocks always struggle during technological shifts. But when’s the turnaround?

Apple CEO Steve Jobs © David Paul Morris/Getty Images

Apple: the face of the tech revolution

Apple CEO Steve Jobs © David Paul Morris/Getty Images

"Is value investing dead?" We've heard this plaintive cry many a time during the past decade, as growth stocks (flashy, expensive stocks) have trounced value stocks (dull, cheap ones). Several reasons have been proposed for this performance gap, from the idea that interest rates have hit a permanently lower plateau, to the theory that the nature of "book value" (see below) has changed as intangible assets such as "intellectual property" and "network effects" become more important than tangible assets such as factories. Now we have an interesting new take to add to the mix that it's all down to revolutions.

"Value is dead, long live value," a recently published paper by Chris Meredith of O'Shaughnessy Asset Management and Cornell University, uses a theoretical framework described by Carlota Perez in her 2002 book, Technological Revolutions and Financial Capital. Perez has studied what happens to markets and economies when a disruptive technology such as the car, or the internet takes off. The process of adapting to and embracing the new technology goes through various phases over a lengthy cycle (lasting several decades), and Meredith argues that it's in the middle of this process when innovation is peaking and the new technology is going mainstream that growth outperforms value.

Growth stocks those backing the exciting new technology take off, while value stocks darlings of the former cycle, now facing disruptive new rivals are left behind. So, for example, while manufacturers thrived during the boom era of the car and mass production, utilities languished. This helped to drive a period when growth outdid value for 15 years between 1926 and 1941. This time around, the leaders are tech stocks such as Apple, while the laggards are financials. However, this won't go on forever, not if history is any guide.

As the "innovations move to maturity", the wider economy starts to pick up the pace, and as a result cheap value starts to outperform expensive growth again. When will it happen? It's impossible to say, but as Meredith notes, "given that it's been 12 years, it certainly seems like this period is getting a bit long in the tooth". In short, value is not dead this has been a particularly rough period, but by no means a unique one.

As for what value investors should be eyeing now out-of-favour financials might be worth a look. Note that this has been one of the big drivers of the performance gap between the US and Europe: the US market is top-heavy in tech, whereas Europe's financials have struggled. One interesting investment trust investing in the sector is Polar Capital Global Financials Trust (LSE: PCFT), currently trading on a discount of 5%.

I wish I knew what book value was,but I'm too embarrassed to ask

A p/b of below one means that technically speaking you can buy the company for less than its assets are worth on paper. So if you could buy the whole company, you could sell all of its assets, and still profit. One problem, however, is that the book value may not reflect what you would actually get for those assets. For example, there may be a lot of "intangible assets", such as goodwill (often relating to the value of a brand).

The value of intangible assets unlike a factory or a piece of land can be hard to measure objectively. They may in fact not be worth very much at all particularly not in a fire sale. So an unusually low p/b could signal a company in trouble, rather than a potential bargain. By subtracting intangibles from book value you get a more conservative number, known as "tangible" book value, based on hard assets, such as land, stocks and cash. If you can buy a stock for a lot less than this figure, it may be a bargain.

Yet note that, as a paper last year from US money manager O'Shaughnessy Asset Management (OSAM) points out, intangible assets such as research and development spending are key parts of today's companies, and they can often be undervalued too. OSAM found that from 1993 to 2017 stocks that looked expensive on a p/b basis, but cheap on other measures, tended to beat the wider market. In other words, as with any other measure, don't rely on p/b alone, and understand its limitations.

See more definitions like this in MoneyWeek's financial glossary

Recommended

How not to get beaten by inflation
Inflation

How not to get beaten by inflation

With inflation at 9%, and the bank rate at 1% you’re not going to get a real return on cash. But there are steps you can take to beat inflation, says …
19 May 2022
Barry Norris: we’re already in the 1970s. Here’s how to invest
Investment strategy

Barry Norris: we’re already in the 1970s. Here’s how to invest

Merryn talks to Barry Norris of Argonaut capital about the parallels between now and the 1970s; the transition to “green” energy; and the one sector w…
19 May 2022
Delivering profits : should you buy Royal Mail shares?
Share tips

Delivering profits : should you buy Royal Mail shares?

The volume of parcels delivered by Royal Mail soared during the pandemic, and so did its profits. But it has been coming under pressure lately. So, as…
19 May 2022
Avoid easyJet shares – there are better airlines to invest in
Share tips

Avoid easyJet shares – there are better airlines to invest in

EasyJet used to be one of Europe’s most impressive airlines. But now it is facing challenges on all fronts and losing out to the competition. Rupert …
19 May 2022

Most Popular

Get set for another debt binge as real interest rates fall
UK Economy

Get set for another debt binge as real interest rates fall

Despite the fuss about rising interest rates, they’re falling in real terms. That will blow up a wild bubble, says Matthew Lynn.
15 May 2022
Is the oil market heading for a supply glut?
Oil

Is the oil market heading for a supply glut?

Many people assume that the high oil price is here to stay – and could well go higher. But we’ve been here before, says Max King. History suggests tha…
16 May 2022
Value is starting to emerge in the markets
Investment strategy

Value is starting to emerge in the markets

If you are looking for long-term value in the markets, some is beginning to emerge, says Merryn Somerset Webb. Indeed, you may soon be able to buy tra…
16 May 2022