Great frauds in history: Jabez Spencer Balfour

Jabez Spencer Balfour built the largest building society in the land and swindled its depositors out of millions.

952_MW_P29_Profile-Bottom

PJ541D

Jabez Spencer Balfour was born in London in 1843 and went on to found the Liberator Building Society in 1868. Thanks largely to Balfour's connections, through his family, with the Nonconformist community, its assets quickly ballooned. Within a decade it was the largest building society in the land. Balfour also set up a variety of property and development companies, making the most of the fame he had garnered through their apparent success to launch a modest political career.

What was the scam?

The building society promised to invest its depositors' money in building affordable houses for working families. A large chunk was actually lent to speculative property schemes that Balfour was involved in, as well as to other parts of his empire. To sustain the illusion of profitability, Balfour overinflated the value of the assets his firms held. He also set up fictitious transactions between them so that he could claim they were growing at a fast rate and loot money from them for his own personal use.

What happened next?

The bad management and embezzlement meant that Balfour's companies had to resort to borrowing increasing sums, both from the building society and elsewhere, in order to pay dividends. Eventually, their debt grew so large that no one was willing to lend them any more money, even at interest rates of up to 20%. In 1892 a business run by his friend James Hobbs, who had borrowed £2m from another Balfour bank, imploded, bringing the bank down as well. The receivers quickly spotted that Balfour's empire was built on fraud, and he fled the country. He was extradited and convicted in 1895.

Lessons for investors

Overall, the Balfour Group owed £7m (£747m in today's money) to creditors, a sum secured against a small amount of mostly worthless assets. Those who put their money into the building society lost almost everything. The trial of Balfour and his accomplices revealed shocking levels of corporate governance. The auditors were friends of Balfour and signed off on things they didn't understand. Watch out for firms that have friends of the CEO on the board it's a warning sign.

Recommended

Why the classic 60/40 investment portfolio may no longer work
Investment strategy

Why the classic 60/40 investment portfolio may no longer work

The dramatic events in the bond market have thrown into question the classic investment strategy of the last 40 years. An investment portfolio made up…
1 Mar 2021
Expect more turbulence as the market calls central bankers’ bluff
Stockmarkets

Expect more turbulence as the market calls central bankers’ bluff

With bond yields climbing and stockmarkets sliding, markets are hoping central bankers will step in again to repress interest rates – but that won’t …
26 Feb 2021
The MoneyWeek Podcast: strategic metals, the commodities supercycle and the electrified future
Commodities

The MoneyWeek Podcast: strategic metals, the commodities supercycle and the electrified future

John Stepek talks to Dr Paul Jourdan, CEO of Amati Global Investors, about investing in the metals needed for the post-oil electrified world, the impo…
26 Feb 2021
Our trade of the decade came good – what’s next?
Investment strategy

Our trade of the decade came good – what’s next?

Back in 2010 we said you should invest in unloved and undervalued Japanese stocks. If you had done that, you’d have made a nice return. So what should…
25 Feb 2021

Most Popular

A beginner’s guide to bitcoin: what is bitcoin?
Bitcoin

A beginner’s guide to bitcoin: what is bitcoin?

As a completely novel concept for many people, bitcoin can take a little effort to get to grips with. In the first of a short series on the cryptocurr…
1 Mar 2021
What is “yield curve control” and why is it coming to a central bank near you?
Government bonds

What is “yield curve control” and why is it coming to a central bank near you?

Central banks around the world are determined not to let interest rates go up too quickly or by too much – a practice known as “yield curve control”. …
1 Mar 2021
What to watch out for in Budget 2021
Budget

What to watch out for in Budget 2021

In his 2021 Budget, Rishi Sunak will lay out his vision for post-Covid Britain – how to fix the public finances and repay all the pandemic stimulus wi…
2 Mar 2021