Features

The Green New Deal: a bold plan to save the planet

The Green New Deal proposed by a group of US politicians would be expensive and unworkable, says Matthew Partridge.

934_MW_P09_P&E

Ocasio-Cortez: the talk of the town

American political history is a long story of "waves of progressive enthusiasm breaking on the rocky shores of Washington DC, to no lasting effect", says David Roberts on Vox. A group of Democrats, including Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, aim to change that. They have launched a "radical environmental plan" that has become the "talk of the town". Their "Green New Deal" is "a massive programme of investments in clean-energy jobs and infrastructure", meant "to transform not just the energy sector, but the entire economy". It aims to make the US economy carbon- free by 2030 and to "make it fairer and more just".

Is it workable?

The "vast programme for economic egalitarianism" proposed which includes a universal basic income for those "unable or unwilling to work" makes the deal even more "unworkable". Adding the cost of the environmental and social programmes together suggests that government spending would have to rise by $6.6trn a year or by 34% of GDP.

Still, it would be a mistake to ignore the plan completely, says Robert Hockett in the Financial Times. True, the environmental aspects alone make for a larger undertaking than that of any American government since Franklin D Roosevelt's original New Deal and the US mobilisation for the World War II. But the problems the plan addresses "require solutions where bigger is better, imperative and, paradoxically, more affordable" than the alternatives. Economies of scale and the snowball effect (where rising temperatures increase carbon emissions) mean that, where climate is concerned, "acting faster will yield greater impact than acting sluggishly".

Shifting theOverton window

Nonsense, says Niall Ferguson in The Sunday Times. Floating wild schemes that have no chance of being implemented in order to shift the debate is "what you get when you recruit your legislators more or less directly from college". This isn't just some fringe plan it has been "endorsed by (thus far) five of the leading candidates for the Democratic nomination in 2020". The whole kerfuffle shows that the Democrats "are not one party, but two: a liberal and a socialist". The reality is that the former can beat Trump, "but not if it is associated with the latter".

EU makes a welcome stand for markets

The justification offered that Europe needs "a national champion in train and signalling manufacture to compete with the likes of China's CRRC" is "nonsense". CRRC does notyet provide any meaningful competition to Siemens and Alstom in non-Chinese markets. And in any case "there are better ways of competing against the cheating, stealing Chinese behemoths than creating a matching monopoly".

It may be a pyrrhic victory, says Ben Hall in the Financial Times. France has decided the EU merger rules are "obsolete"; Germany has demanded changes to "better take into account the demands of international competition". This is a mistake competition policy is there to serve customers, not just two countries with big corporate interests.

Still, if anyone is prepared to make the case for competition and markets it's Margrethe Vestager, the European Commissioner for Competition, says The Economist. During her time in the job, she "has taken on mighty corporate interests where others would have wavered", including Apple, Google, German carmakers, and even bond traders. Indeed, she has even been tipped as the next president of the European Commission. "Europe's liberals talk much about the need to rebuild confidence in the EU in populist times. In Vestagerthey have a chance to pick a head of the European Commission who actually believes in enforcing the rules."

Recommended

China owns a lot more gold than it’s letting on – and here’s why
Gold

China owns a lot more gold than it’s letting on – and here’s why

In a world awash with money-printing, a currency backed by gold would have great credibility. And China – with designs on the yuan becoming the world’…
21 Apr 2021
Three ways to make Biden's global tax rate work for Britain
Global Economy

Three ways to make Biden's global tax rate work for Britain

Joe Biden wants to set the corporation tax rate for the world. Britain should accept this, says Matthew Lynn – and game the system.
18 Apr 2021
The charts that matter: the dollar extends its fall
Global Economy

The charts that matter: the dollar extends its fall

The US dollar took quite the tumble this week. Here’s how the charts that matter most to the global economy reacted.
17 Apr 2021
Why you should expect another stockmarket crash
Stockmarkets

Why you should expect another stockmarket crash

Many fear inflation, but a deflationary debt collapse is a more likely scenario in the near term, says Tim Lee
16 Apr 2021

Most Popular

“Joke” cryptocurrency dogecoin goes to the moon. What’s going on?
Bitcoin

“Joke” cryptocurrency dogecoin goes to the moon. What’s going on?

Dogecoin – a cryptocurrency created as a joke – has risen by more than 9,000% this year alone. Saloni Sardana looks at how something that began as an …
19 Apr 2021
China owns a lot more gold than it’s letting on – and here’s why
Gold

China owns a lot more gold than it’s letting on – and here’s why

In a world awash with money-printing, a currency backed by gold would have great credibility. And China – with designs on the yuan becoming the world’…
21 Apr 2021
Why investment advice could be about to get a lot cheaper
Investment strategy

Why investment advice could be about to get a lot cheaper

Vanguard, the world’s second-biggest asset manager, is launching its own cut-price financial advice service. It’s something the industry badly needs, …
20 Apr 2021