Features

May’s ex-deal is nailed to the perch

All sides in the debate have declared the PM’s Brexit deal dead. What comes next? Stuart Watkins reports.

924-May-634

The hard work is still to come for May

All sides in the debate have declared the PM's Brexit deal dead. What comes next? Stuart Watkins reports.

It was a "funeral masquerading as a baptism", says Matthew d'Ancona in The Guardian. In Brussels this week, Theresa May's Brexit deal a 585-page agreement and a 26-page political annex that defines the UK's relationship with its EU trading partners over a two-year transition period was "welcomed into the world by the UK's soon-to-be-ex-partners and the priesthood' of the European Commission". But the agreement is a dodo. "This is an ex-deal. The only reason it is sitting on its perch is because it has been nailed there."

Barring a dramatic realignment of parliamentary opinion, the deal simply cannot survive the "meaningful vote" in the House of Commons, expected on 11 December, says d'Ancona. In the meantime the whips will be busy, but it's hard to see how they can possibly deliver a victory for May.

What happens after her defeat? No-one knows, but as Jeremy Hunt, the foreign secretary, has admitted, the wholesale collapse of the government cannot be ruled out. "The worst news May has ever had to confront is that the past two-and-a-half years were the easy bit."

PM may rise above the tantrums

I wouldn't be so sure, says Martin Sandbu in the Financial Times. All sides are hostile to the deal because they misunderstand what it is not a final, finished operational trade agreement of either the Norway or the Canada type. Such a deal is hardly possible until Britain decides what kind of deal it wants. Rather, it is a withdrawal agreement, designed to make the transition period as smooth a process as possible until a final trade deal is agreed. It should be judged on whether it achieves this. It does. It perpetuates most of the rights enjoyed by EU citizens in the UK and UK nationals in other EU countries.

It settles outstanding financial commitments fairly. It amicably settles the touchy issue of dispute resolution over its own content. And it ties up a myriad of other loose ends and secures a welcome degree of continuity. In every previous period of Brexit turmoil, May has emerged looking stronger than anyone previously thought once reality had had time to sink in. "This time will be no different."

The costs of the agreement

Meanwhile, the warnings about the expected costs of the deal were starting to roll in as MoneyWeek went to press. Two independent reports estimated that May's deal will reduce living standards by between £700 and £2,000 per person per year compared with remaining in the EU. In advance of the publication of the government and Treasury's own assessments, the chancellor, Philip Hammond, warned May's deal would make people worse off in economic terms.

There is no version of leaving the EU that increases prosperity, he told the BBC. But bear in mind that the Treasury's long-term forecasts have in the past been at the more pessimistic end of the spectrum, says Capital Economics. The consultancy expects strong GDP growth of 2% or so in 2019 if the deal is ratified, or a hit to GDP of between 1% and 3% in a no-deal scenario.

The costs of remaining should also be factored in, says Matt Kilcoyne for The Spectator's Coffee House blog. EU bigwigs have made it clear that a Britain that changed its mind and decided to remain stands to lose its £5.6bn rebate and its opt-outs, most controversially including its exemption from joining the single currency. And the costs of doing business in the EU, under the new burden of the GDPR data regulations, will continue to grow.

The PM should not just spell out the costs of the Brexits she doesn't like, but the costs of going cap in hand back to the EU too. Whatever the costs of Brexit, it's clear "the status quo is no longer an option".

Recommended

Greensill, Cameron and the return of Tory sleaze
UK Economy

Greensill, Cameron and the return of Tory sleaze

The collapse of Greensill Capital threw a spotlight on political lobbying when it emerged that former PM David Cameron had been fighting its corner. J…
17 Apr 2021
Recovery Loan Scheme: the latest government aid package for small businesses
Small business

Recovery Loan Scheme: the latest government aid package for small businesses

The Recovery Loan Scheme will help companies weather the pandemic
16 Apr 2021
UK mid-cap stocks look forward to life after lockdown
UK stockmarkets

UK mid-cap stocks look forward to life after lockdown

The FTSE 250 hit an all-time high at the end of last week, as investors look to a post-lockdown recovery.
16 Apr 2021
House prices: from boom to even bigger boom
House prices

House prices: from boom to even bigger boom

UK house prices have risen to new to record highs, says Nicole Garcia Merida. Demand continues to outpace supply, but continued low interest rates, th…
9 Apr 2021

Most Popular

The bitcoin bubble will burst: here’s how to play it
Bitcoin

The bitcoin bubble will burst: here’s how to play it

The cryptocurrency’s price has soared far beyond its fundamentals, says Matthew Partridge. Here, he looks at how to short bitcoin.
12 Apr 2021
What does the Coinbase listing mean for bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies?
Bitcoin

What does the Coinbase listing mean for bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies?

As the bitcoin price hit new highs, the world's biggest cryptocurrency exchange, Coinbase, listed on the stockmarket. John Stepek looks at what that m…
15 Apr 2021
Properties for sale for around £400,000
Houses for sale

Properties for sale for around £400,000

From a converted church in Banffshire with views towards the Cairngorms National Park, to a period property in the Georgian market town of Beverley, e…
2 Apr 2021