"Brazil, land of the lurid telenovela" is embroiled in a presidential election "full of political melodrama", says The Times. The favourite is right-wing populist Jair Bolsonaro, known for throwing vitriol at Brazil's black communities, gays and women, and who is nostalgic about the days of military rule.
He secured a victory with almost 47% of the vote in the first-round of the presidential election last Sunday. But he fell short of the 50% required to win, which means there will be a run-off at the end of the month. The second-placed candidate is Fernando Haddad of the leftist Workers' Party, heir to charismatic former leftist president Lula, who is now behind bars.
Brazil blows the budget
What might all this mean for the economy? "We see more room for a constructive liberal reform agenda if Bolsonaro wins, but it could be difficult to get [it] off the ground," says Daniel Sinigaglia at Standard Chartered. The main problem is that public debt has risen from 60% to 84% of GDP in just four years, says Buttonwood in the Economist. "This owes a lot to a collapse in revenues after 2013. A brutal recession did not help." For many years the budget benefited from windfalls from a mining boom and credit-fuelled consumer spending, but "those will not be repeated". Spending cuts are needed. But both front-runners are polarising figures and might therefore struggle to steer reforms through congress.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Whoever emerges as Brazil's leader has to tackle not only crime and corruption, but also rampant inequality issues. It is one of the most polarised places in the world, as it suffers from what has been described as "Robin Hood in reverse".
A large portion of its public spending goes to people in the upper middle class rather than the poor. State pensions are the most pressing example an issue that will only grow as the population ages. A third of Brazil's tax revenues are spent on retirement, 53% of which is for the wealthiest 20% while only 2.5% is for the poorest fifth.
"The crunch point might be next August," Arthur Carvalho Filho of Morgan Stanley told the Economist. A budget for 2020 must be submitted then, and if it doesn't contain pension reform, a squeeze will be needed elsewhere. Otherwise the country's long-term public spending cap, written into the constitution a few years ago, will have to be lifted.
That could deal a fatal blow to global investors' confidence in Brazil, triggering an exodus from Brazilian assets. However, it would be a mistake "to write off this vibrant country as a failing state" just yet, as The Times points out. If the worst doesn't happen, then the long-term outlook is positive. Brazil's private sector "remains dynamic and its commitment to the rule of law is a model for the continent".
Sign up for MoneyWeek's newsletters
Get the latest financial news, insights and expert analysis from our award-winning MoneyWeek team, to help you understand what really matters when it comes to your finances.
Marina Gerner is an award-winning journalist and columnist who has written for the Financial Times, the Times Literary Supplement, the Economist, The Guardian and Standpoint magazine in the UK; the New York Observer in the US; and die Bild and Frankfurter Rundschau in Germany.
Marina is also an adjunct professor at the NYU Stern School of Business at their London campus, and has a PhD from the London School of Economics.
Her first book, The Vagina Business, deals with the potential of “femtech” to transform women’s lives, and will be published by Icon Books in September 2024.
Review: Trisara, Phuket – a feast for the senses in Thailand
Expecting an inheritance? Don’t – only a fifth of Boomers plan to part with their cash
