Say no to smart meters

The government’s money-saving, energy-tracking revolution has turned into another costly damp squib, says Ruth Jackson.


The government's money-saving, energy-tracking revolution has turned into another costly damp squib.

They were hailed as a technological advance that would save us all money, eliminate billing errors and revolutionise the way we use energy in our homes. But so far, smart meters are proving to be anything but a smart decision.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Become a smarter, better informed investor with MoneyWeek.

More than 1.5 million smart meters installed in homes are not working properly, says Victoria Bischoff in the Daily Mail. The main problem is that many smart meters go dumb when you switch supplier, meaning they stop automatically sending meter readings. If this happens, you have to go back to supplying readings manually, as with a traditional meter.

Around 940,000 smart meters are believed to have gone dumb, according to government figures. A further 640,000 have been installed in unoccupied new-build homes, or where the customer has switched to a small supplier who hasn't supplied data to the government.

Advertisement - Article continues below

This problem is meant to have stopped with the introduction of second-generation smart meters, but these versions only work if the meter is compatible with local communications networks. As a result, only 300 of the 20,000 meters that have been installed are in the north of England and Scotland, where there are problems with connectivity.

Even if you are lucky enough to have a smart meter that still works, you may not be saving as much money as you'd hoped. Earlier this year the government admitted that its pledge that a smart meter would save the average household £26 a year had been a massive overestimate. In fact, they are saving households less than half that, at just £11 a year. Given the fact that energy bills have risen to cover the £11bn cost of roll out, it's hard to see how a smart meter is saving any member of the public money.

Believers argue that smart meters are needed because they are "an essential foundation for much of the UK's energy future", says Adam Vaughan in the Guardian. The government is on a mission to get 50 million smart meters installed by 2020. But until the current problems are ironed out, the smart meter revolution is "at risk of being short-circuited".

Given that, it's worth being aware that smart meters aren't mandatory, even though many energy firms are pushing them hard. All providers will be required to offer them eventually, but you don't have to accept. You can also say no at first, and then change your mind at a later date.

Act now to avoid rising CGT rates

Today's historically low rates of capital-gains tax (CGT) look ripe for review as the government seeks extra sources of funding, says Harry Brennan in the Daily Telegraph. As a result, some financial advisers are telling clients to consider crystallising gains now, while rates remain low, or risk a bigger tax hit later if CGT rates are raised in line with income-tax rates.

Higher-rate taxpayers currently pay 28% CGT on residential property and 20% on other gains, while basic-rate taxpayers pay 18% or 10% respectively. You have to pay CGT on your overall capital gains above your annual tax-free allowance, which is known as your annual exempt amount. This is currently £11,700.

Advertisement - Article continues below

However, you may be able to reduce your CGT liability by sharing assets with a spouse or civil partner. Combining both your CGT allowances allows you to make gains of up to £23,400 a year tax-free. If your partner has a lower tax rate than you, it may be worth transferring more assets into their name to benefit from the lower CGT rate they will pay.

Another possibility is to stagger large disposals over several years. This lets you use your allowance in multiple years, reducing your cumulative tax bill.

Pocket money... fraudsters target university students

As students return to university, thousands of them will be at risk of getting caught up in bank-transfer frauds, says Sam Meadows in the Daily Telegraph. Last year there were 8,652 cases of people aged 18-24 acting as "money mules", which involves allowing their bank accounts to be used by fraudsters to launder stolen money, according to data from Cifas, the fraud database.

Recruiters for the fraudsters regularly take to social media at the start of university terms to search for potential money mules, and often use fake job advertisements in order to lure people in. Students are often targeted because part of the offer is that they can keep a portion of the funds in return for transferring the cash on. Anyone caught acting as a money mule will face problems getting credit in future. At worst, they could receive a prison sentence.

Parents can earn 3.5% interest on their children's savings due to Nationwide's new Future Saver account. It offers the top rate to parents who have their main current account with the building society, says the Sunday Times, with a rate of 2.5% for others. You can deposit up to £5,000 a year, with little withdrawal allowed every year. The account arrives as Nationwide closes its junior individual savings account, which paid 3.25%, to new customers.

Music fans are being given the chance to invest in the back catalogue of Dire Straits (lead singer and guitarist Mark Knopfler). A new investment scheme allows you to buy a share of the royalties that are paid out every time one of the rock band's songs or albums is bought, downloaded, streamed or played on the radio. The venture from US firm Royalty Exchange proves that "classic songs are not only the soundtrack to people's lives they are also a potentially lucrative asset class' that can be packaged up and sold off to wealthy investors", says Rupert Jones in the Guardian.

Advertisement - Article continues below

The portion of the Dire Straits back catalogue that is up for sale earned $296,000 (£225,000) in the past 12 months, according to Royalty Exchange. However, only those with deep pockets need apply. To be eligible for the scheme, you must have either over $1m of investable assets aside from your main house, or an annual income of at least $200,000.




Dangerous, dear and dying: why the consensus on nuclear power is wrong

Nuclear power is viewed as too dangerous and too costly to form part of our energy future. That’s plain wrong – and it could spell huge opportunity, s…
27 Dec 2019
Stock markets

Investors today are unreasonably bearish on oil companies

As the world looks to a future without fossil fuels, investors have abandoned oil companies. But we still need oil, says John Stepek. And this irratio…
9 Dec 2019
Personal finance

Is it time for you to get a new energy deal?

You may well be paying too much for your gas and electricity. But finding a cheaper energy deal isn’t difficult and could save you a lot of money.
22 Oct 2019

Will solar energy investment funds keep shining?

Investment funds designed to profit from the solar energy have done well, but now look expensive, says Max King.
22 Oct 2019

Most Popular


Want to make money in 2020? Gold and silver are looking like a good bet

If you want to make money from investing, says Dominic Frisby, it’s simple: find a bull market and go long. And in 2020 gold and silver are in a bull …
22 Jan 2020

Money Minute Wednesday 22 January: UK public borrowing

Today's Money Minute looks ahead to the latest on of the UK's public finances, with the Office for Budget Responsibility’s forecasts for borrowing thi…
22 Jan 2020

Money Minute Thursday 23 January: European interest rates

In today's Money Minute we look ahead to Christine Lagarde's second interest-rate-setting meeting at the European Central Bank.
23 Jan 2020
Share tips

India’s small and mid-cap stocks are set for big gains – here are three to buy now

Each week, a professional investor tells us where he’d put his money. This week: David Cornell of the India Capital Growth Fund highlights three favou…
20 Jan 2020