Collectables: beat the bull to the china shop

Donald Trump wants to slap trade tariffs on Chinese art as well as on other goods from China. Chris Carter reports.


Donald Trump wants to slap tariffs on china as well as on China. Chris Carter reports

Donald Trump's approach to diplomacy has been likened to a bull in a china shop. This has taken on new, more literal, meaning in recent weeks the "china shop" in question now including auction rooms piled high with Ming dynasty porcelain. That's because Trump's latest salvo of threatened tariffs in his trade war with China covers paintings and drawings executed entirely by hand, original sculptures, and antiques more than 100 years old in fact, any artwork that has originated in China. "That means American buyers could be required to pay 25% more for a Ming dynasty bowl sold by a British owner at an auction in New York, as well as for a painting by a young Beijing-based artist at a gallery in Hong Kong," says Scott Reyburn in The New York Times.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Become a smarter, better informed investor with MoneyWeek.

Shot in the foot

American dealers are up in arms. They argue the sanctions will only end up hurting America, where the market in Chinese collectables is relatively small compared with mainland China. Last year $5.1bn of the $7.1bn-worth of sales of Chinese art and antiques came from the mainland, according to a report from art news website Artnet. "China will welcome [the sanctions on art]," James Lally, a New York-based art dealer, tells Artnet. "It's a very harmful levy" that will isolate the United States as "the one place where it is 25% more expensive to bring in anything".

So, while the deluge of Asian-related auction sales in New York over the next couple of weeks from the major auction houses doesn't herald anything particularly out of the ordinary for this time of year, there may well be a renewed sense of urgency in the auction rooms themselves. After all, the sanctions, if they are enacted, "will have a chilling impact", says Lally in The New York Times. "It will quickly reduce the market for Chinese art in America to a backwater."

Advertisement - Article continues below

Auctions this autumn

Bonhams gets things under way with its sale of "Chinese Works of Art and Paintings" on 10 September, where several Chinese snuff bottles will be on display. Asian Art Week begins the following day at Christie's, featuring everything from "fine Chinese paintings" to ceramics and jade ornaments over eight sales. But the star of the show is the Zuo Bao Yi Gui, a bronze "ritual food vessel", dating from the tenth to the 11th centuries BC that, at one time, belonged to the 18th century Qianlong Emperor. It has been valued at up to $6m.

Sotheby's "Junkunc: Chinese Buddhist Sculpture" sale on the 12 September includes a large Tang dynasty (618-907) limestone head of the Buddha, valued at up to $3m. That's followed by its "Important Chinese Art" sale, featuring a rare Famille-Rose "landscape" vase from the Qianlong period, bearing a traditional idealised Chinese landscape scene that blends in European-inspired motifs. It is expected to fetch between $500,000 and $700,000. That's followed the next day by two sales of classical Chinese paintings and calligraphy, and a further sale of Asian art on the Saturday. All of the above would represent quite a windfall if Trump were to get his way.

A good way to begin a collection


Apart from the rarest and earliest examples, "the majority of 19th-century Japanese prints are still undervalued in comparison with Western or Chinese art and have the potential to increase in value", says Yasuko Kido, Japanese art specialist at Chiswick Auctions. That's because "living artists are unable to match the quality and techniques of the past". Woodblock prints from famed artists Hiroshige and Kuniyoshi can be had for as little as £200. "Each print has a story to tell," she says, that reflects aspects of Edo society, such as kabuki theatre, sumo wrestling and courtesans, or the wars against the Russians and Chinese during the Meiji period. Others depict beautiful landscapes in simple lines and bold colours.

Japanese ukiyo-e woodblock prints have fascinated Western artists ever since a number were displayed at the 1867 World's Fair in Paris, says Katherine Whatley on collectables website Artsy. These early admirers would become known as the Impressionists, among them Dutch painterand collector of prints Vincent van Gogh.



During the French Revolutionary Wars and the reign of George III, silver became scarce. The Royal Mint invited bankers to supply silver to be minted into coins, paying 62 shillings per pound (in weight). When in early 1798 the market price of silver fell to 60 shillings per pound, a consortium of bankers led by Magens Dorrien Magens took advantage, presenting the Mint with 9,895 pounds of silver enough to make 600,000 silver shillings. After an estimated 34,000 shillings had been struck, the Mint halted production. At least 20 of the Dorrien Magens coins (pictured below) are known to have survived one is expected to fetch up to £20,000 at a sale held by Sovereign Rarities together with the Royal Mint on 25 September, ahead of the Coinex Show in London.



Advertisement - Article continues below

In 1792 George Washington, as America's first president, was presented with a $10 gold coin by a company that was looking to make the new country's currency. However, the coin bore his profile, and fearing that it made him look too much like a European-style monarch, Washington rejected it as a design but nevertheless hung onto the coin as a memento. A year later the first coins stamped with Lady Liberty entered circulation. In 1942, the Washington coin came into the collection of Eric Newman, who died last year, aged 106. It was sold by his son, Andy, through Texas-based Heritage Auctions for $1,740,000 on 16 August, with the net proceeds going to charity.



Share tips

Alternative investments: three hidden gems beyond stocks and bonds

Alternative investments such as private equity or commodities are one of the oldest forms of investment, says professional investor Alex Barr. Here. h…
16 Sep 2019
Alternative investments

The $68 trillion inheritance

A very valuable torch is being passed to a new generation, says Chris Carter
24 Jan 2020
Alternative investments

The art market endures after a jittery 2019

Wealthy Americans stepped up to help calm the art market's jitters in 2019. Chris Carter reports.
10 Jan 2020
Alternative investments

Today's art markets are a paradise for bargain hunters

Now is an ideal time for collectors to go shopping at the art auctions. 
29 Nov 2019

Most Popular

House prices

The biggest risk facing the UK housing market right now

For house prices to stagnate or even fall would be healthy for the property market, says John Stepek. But there is a distinct danger that isn't going …
17 Feb 2020

The euro’s slide against the US dollar looks set to continue

The euro has been in a bear market against the US dollar for two years now. And on a broader scale since 2008. A decline like that is telling us somet…
19 Feb 2020
Share tips

Three overlooked stocks to buy now

Each week, a professional investor tells us where he’d put his money. This week: Joe Bauernfreund, portfolio manager at the AVI Global Trust, highligh…
17 Feb 2020

The rare earth metal that won't be a secret for long

SPONSORED CONTENT – You can’t keep a good thing hidden forever; now is the time to consider Pensana Rare Earths and the rare earth metals NdPr.
31 Jan 2020