Features

EU says “non” to Brexit deal

The EU’s chief negotiator has rejected May’s plans. A fudge is on the cards. Emily Hohler reports.

907-Barnier-634

Dominic Raab and Michel Barnier: still a long way apart

Michel Barnier has "effectively killed off" Theresa May's latest customs plan, warning that the European Union wouldn't accept Britain collecting duties on its behalf after Brexit, says James Crisp in The Daily Telegraph. The EU's chief negotiator refused to accept that Britain had "evolved its position" following "crunch Cabinet talks" at Chequers, which led to the resignations of David Davis and Boris Johnson. May's White Paper, which "squeaked through Parliament by a handful of votes", envisages Britain signing up to a common rulebook and shared customs arrangements with Brussels.

This would mean that British customs officials would collect duties on goods coming into the UK that are bound for the EU. Barnier's response was that the EU could not and would not "delegate the application of its customs policy, of its rules, VAT and excise duty collections to a non-member who would not be subject to the EU's governance structures". This rejection of a "cornerstone" of the customs plan has refocused attention on the "vexed question" of the Irish border. The issue remains unresolved and the "most likely to sabotage Brexit negotiations as an October deadline to finalise the deal looms".

A clever wheeze, but no cigar

Barnier's "non" is "unfortunate", albeit unsurprising, says Daniel Capurro, also in The Daily Telegraph. The Chequers proposals were never going to remain intact, but the customs arrangement "was the clever wheeze" balancing hard and soft demands and "holding the whole edifice up". But it's not all bad news, says The Wall Street Journal.

Despite major sticking points, Barnier noted that 80% of the agreement was already in place. He softened his opposition to May's post-Brexit plans for financial services, after British negotiators explained that the UK wasn't attempting to remove the bloc's "decision-making autonomy", merely seeking to be treated like New York, Singapore or other non-EU financial centres, says Joe Barnes in the Daily Express. Barnier also said he was "pleased" with the progress on foreign policy and security, add Daniel Boffey and Jennifer Rankin in The Guardian.

Kicking the can yet again

Barnier's remarks "underline" that the Chequers agreement "already causing ructions among Conservative activists" is going to require some changes "if it is to become a workable arrangement", says Stephen Bush in the New Statesman. It's hard to see how any final agreement will secure enough support from Tory MPs, particularly since they will be "getting an earful from party members" this month and doubts are likely to have "hardened" when parliament returns in September.

The "disarray in British politics", as May contends with eurosceptic and pro-EU MPs, has convinced senior EU leaders that a "change of tack might be needed", says Alex Barker in the FT. Although Barnier warned London not to "bother circumventing him by approaching European capitals" Jeremy Hunt, who warned this week of a "no-deal" Brexit if Brussels doesn't change its approach, is visiting European capitals to persuade leaders of the merits of the Chequers plan the EU has since said it is "willing to fudge' crucial Brexit negotiations and offer Britain a vague blueprint for "future ties with the bloc" if it helps May "avoid a no-deal' outcome and win parliamentary backing for a withdrawal treaty". But not all EU negotiators approve, believing that a "vague statement on future relations" simply "stores up trouble" and kicks the can down the road.

Labour fails to lance its anti-Semitic boil

The "boil of anti-Semitism within the Labour movement remains unlanced", says Alex Massie in The Times. Hardly a week passes without Labour councillors and members "promulgating by accident, of course" some form of anti-Semitic material and the party has now failed fully to endorse the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA)'s definition of anti-Semitism. Last week Britain's three leading Jewish newspapers published a joint editorial saying that they were concerned about "the existential threat posed to Jewish life in this country that would be posed by a Jeremy Corbyn-led government". Labour rejected the claims, saying that they had adopted the IHRA definition but had concerns about some of the guidelines.

Choosing to "embark on a fresh dispute about anti-Semitism" at a time when our government is "imploding" over Brexit is bizarre, says Robert Shrimsley in the Financial Times. The cynical but expedient way to handle this would have been to "adopt the IHRA definition and guidelines in full and then fail to implement them (essentially what it has been doing for months)". Instead, the Corbynite approach was to "redefine it and punish those who complained". Two Labour MPs, Ian Austin and Margaret Hodge, who both lost family members in the Holocaust, now face disciplinary action for confronting the leadership. The party's approach is creating conditions for a split that threatens a Labour electoral victory. This says much about Corbyn: that his views should be taken literally, and that he is prepared to risk everything for the "purity of his ideals".

It also reveals Corbyn's "darker", illiberal side, says Rachel Sylvester in The Times: his "self-righteousness" and "intolerance of disagreement". It is why moderate Labour MPs no longer belong in the party, and why Corbyn would be "so dangerous" in No. 10.

Recommended

How to prepare your business for Brexit
Small business

How to prepare your business for Brexit

Whether we have a Brexit deal or not, new procedures for importers and exporters will apply from 1 January. Get your business ready now.
27 Nov 2020
Furlough extension, corporation tax and green investment – the main points of the Budget
Budget

Furlough extension, corporation tax and green investment – the main points of the Budget

Rishi Sunak delivered his 2021 Budget, with measures to extend coronavirus support, get the economy back on its feet, and some first steps in paying f…
3 Mar 2021
What to watch out for in Budget 2021
Budget

What to watch out for in Budget 2021

In his 2021 Budget, Rishi Sunak will lay out his vision for post-Covid Britain – how to fix the public finances and repay all the pandemic stimulus wi…
2 Mar 2021
Where to get help taking your business online
Small business

Where to get help taking your business online

The pandemic has brought forward the transition to e-commerce, so businesses need to go digital. David Prosser explains the tools available to help ta…
2 Mar 2021

Most Popular

A beginner’s guide to bitcoin: how to buy bitcoin
Bitcoin

A beginner’s guide to bitcoin: how to buy bitcoin

For the novice, buying bitcoin can be a daunting prospect. Here, Dominic Frisby outlines the process from start to finish.
2 Mar 2021
A beginner’s guide to bitcoin: what is bitcoin?
Bitcoin

A beginner’s guide to bitcoin: what is bitcoin?

As a completely novel concept for many people, bitcoin can take a little effort to get to grips with. In the first of a short series on the cryptocurr…
1 Mar 2021
What is “yield curve control” and why is it coming to a central bank near you?
Government bonds

What is “yield curve control” and why is it coming to a central bank near you?

Central banks around the world are determined not to let interest rates go up too quickly or by too much – a practice known as “yield curve control”. …
1 Mar 2021