What’s behind the recent slide in the oil price?

After a year of big rises, the oil price has slipped back recently. Is this just a blip, or are we set for another big tumble? John Stepek explains.

US shale oil producers survived Opec's plan to drive them bankrupt, and kept on pumping.

The oil price has shot up by about 50% in the last 12 months.

At one point, Brent crude oil had hit $80 a barrel.

But in the last week or so, it's hit a stumbling block.

Are prices heading for another tumble? Or is this just a blip on the way to higher ground?

The oil price had rallied too far, too soon

Here's a quick summary of what's happened to the oil price over the past five years or so (regular readers have already seen this a few times, so I'll keep it short).

In 2014, after defying gravity for a ridiculous length of time, the oil price slid as investors realised that US shale oil production was not a flash in the pan, and that America had become a major global energy producer.

The oil price tumbled from $100 a barrel to below $40 at one point. Oil majors slashed production, shut down ambitious plans to drill in far-off areas, and sacrificed all they could in order to service their dividend payments.

Meanwhile, oil cartel Opec kept on pumping. It didn't want to lose market share to the US shale oil producers, and it also wanted to drive as many of them as possible to bankruptcy.

But Opec reckoned without 0% interest rates. The shale oil producers cushioned by a massively forgiving credit backdrop managed to survive the downturn and just kept on pumping.

Opec with national budgets wilting under the pressure of sliding oil revenues gave up first. In late 2016 (by which point, the oil slide had just about exhausted itself anyway), Opec and Russia agreed to cut oil production.

That helped to turn sentiment around again. Oil has rallied sharply since then, and in the last year or so, has gone up by around 50%.

Meanwhile, the fact that oil companies have reined in all their big exploration projects and are still in capital conservation mode rather than "let's splash the cash" mode has only added to the generally bullish mood.

As I said around about this time last week, there has been a sudden sentiment switch in the oil market. Suddenly, everyone has been talking about how we're going back to the days of $100 a barrel or more, and how we're in danger of seeing shortages again.

To me, that had a feeling of "too much, too soon". A correction of that overly bullish sentiment was necessary, and is not especially surprising.

We're not great at looking into the future

The thing is, markets are all about expectations; the market prices in what it expects to happen next. If that doesn't happen, then the market has to reprice the situation.

Sometimes the market gets too optimistic or too pessimistic. Markets have momentum, you see, because the vast majority of human forecasting is based on looking at what happened yesterday and assuming that the same thing will happen tomorrow.

We think of the future as being a straight line, whereas in fact, it's a curve. Sometimes the curve might be a wave that's turning up or down in a repetitive cycle and sometimes it might be part of an exponential growth curve that changes everything.

But it's not a straight line.

As a result of this misperception, the market gets too excited when things are on the way up, and too nervous when they're on the way down.

With oil, there has been too much focus on the bull side, and not enough on the bear side. Hence the recent slap down the price has taken.

How enthusiastic should you be about oil if we're heading into a global trade war? How keen should you be if China slows down? And what about Donald Trump's apparent plans to open the US emergency oil reserve ahead of the November elections?

When everyone is focusing on the bull side of the argument, these stories carry a lot more weight than when everyone is gloomy.

However, these things move in stages. The market had grown too bullish on oil, but at a fundamental level, there are still a lot of strictures on the supply side (which is what really matters).

The big producers are starting to ramp up new projects again. But there's a caution there, driven partly by the downturn and partly by the long-term fear of oil being rendered unusable either by climate change regulations or a mass shift to renewable energy.

When optimism about electric vehicles collapses and were all talking about being dependent on oil forever more, you'll know that the bullishness has gone too far. That's not happening yet though, and I suspect it'll be a while before it does.

In this week's issue of MoneyWeek magazine (out on Friday), my colleague Matthew Partridge looks at why we're unlikely to see a significantly lower oil price any time soon and he also looks at some of the best ways to play that. If you don't already get MoneyWeek, I recommend that you subscribe here now.


Commodities look cheap

Commodities look cheap

Gold may be on a bull run, but industrial commodities, including copper, zinc and aluminium, remain cheap.
17 Jan 2020
What escalating tension between Iran and the US means for oil prices
Global Economy

What escalating tension between Iran and the US means for oil prices

The tension between the US and Iran is unlikely to mean all-out war in the Middle East. But markets may be getting a little too complacent about its e…
6 Jan 2020
Rising output will keep a lid on the oil price

Rising output will keep a lid on the oil price

Oil exporters’ cartel Opec gave further encouragement to the bulls this month after agreeing to new production curbs.
20 Dec 2019
Brace yourself for pricier oil

Brace yourself for pricier oil

Global growth, and hence demand for oil, could surprise on the upside next year, leading to a bounce in the oil price.
29 Nov 2019

Most Popular

The Bank of England should create a "Bitpound" digital currency and take the world by storm

The Bank of England should create a "Bitpound" digital currency and take the world by storm

The Bank of England could win the race to create a respectable digital currency if it moves quickly, says Matthew Lynn.
18 Oct 2020
What would negative interest rates mean for your money?
UK Economy

What would negative interest rates mean for your money?

There has been much talk of the Bank of England introducing negative interest rates. John Stepek explains why they might do that, and what it would me…
15 Oct 2020
Last chance to secure a Bounce Back loan for your small business
Small business

Last chance to secure a Bounce Back loan for your small business

The government’s Bounce Back loan scheme will only run for another six weeks. Act now if you need to take advantage of it.
16 Oct 2020