What makes a good active fund and where you can find them

Closet tracker funds are dying as investors plump for passive funds or well-managed active funds. Here, we pick some of the best active funds to buy for today’s markets.


With all the market turmoil over the past few weeks, it is easy to forget why it is that we the we in this case being us ordinary investors actually invest. We aren't in markets to fiddle around with complicated financial instruments in the hope of outsmarting someone else and making a quick buck. We are looking to buy into fundamentally well-run listed companies that will grow both our capital and our incomes at a price that makes sense both in absolute terms and relative to other assets.

With that in mind this week, I don't want to talk about quantitative tightening, wage inflation, interest rates, Jay Powell or Mark Carney. I'm bored with all of it as I suspect you are, too. Instead, I want to offer a little good news from the industry and then look at a couple of funds I've been meaning to mention for a while.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Become a smarter, better informed investor with MoneyWeek.

The good news is that one of the worst parts of the investment industry is slowly dying. I speak, of course, of closet trackers. These are funds that call themselves actively managed and charge as though they have teams of clever people rushing around the world identifying fabulous investment opportunities and crunching endless numbers in a quest to get their hands on those investments on the cheap. But, actually, they do little but buy and hold the firms that make up the index they are supposed to measure their performance against.

There are a variety of reasons to loathe both these funds and the firms that provide them. There is the needless expense; the underperformance (if you track an index and charge a high fee, odds are you will underperform it); the general dishonesty; and finally, the fact that they give the whole business of active management a bad name. Strip out the closet trackers from the numbers and it is harder to make the case that the average active manager always underperforms the market after costs.

Advertisement - Article continues below

The good news is that these irritants are on their way out. Thanks to rising investor awareness and a welcome focus on costs, they are being abandoned in favour of either genuine low-cost trackers or properly active funds.

Simon Evan-Cook of Premier Asset Management has crunched the numbers. In 2014, he says, 28% of UK equity funds were closet trackers (as defined by having an "active share" of 60 or less, where zero is holding exactly the same shares as an index and 100 is having none of the stocks in an index).

By late 2017, this had fallen to 19%. At the same time, the percentage of funds that were genuine index trackers had risen from 19 to 22% and those that are "highly active" (defined by having an active share of more than 80) had risen from a mere 10% to 19%.

Altogether, about 60% of the market can now be considered to be active (as defined by having an active share between 60 and 80) or highly active. That's up from 53%. These numbers refer to funds invested in UK equities only but I think (I hope) we can extrapolate them across all sectors. This is great.

The industry likes to argue (a lot) about whether ordinary investors should be invested in passive funds or in active funds (I'd go for a bit of both). But absolutely nobody is arguing for closet trackers. Good riddance to the ones that have been squeezed out already. Fingers crossed that the rest follow.

What makes a good active fund

So what about the kinds of funds that have driven up the active and highly active fund percentages? What are they, where are they, which ones are good and how can you get your hands on them?

Advertisement - Article continues below

The first thing to say here is that star fund manager Neil Woodford's departure from Invesco Perpetual to set up his own fund management company is (as ever) having an effect on the statistics. His old funds had an active share of just under 80. His new ones have one of more than 80.

The second is that being a highly active stockpicker, while often an indicator that your performance will be good, is in no way a guarantee. Things aren't going particularly well for Woodford at the moment (his flagship fund has slightly underperformed the FTSE All Share index since launch) and there are bound to be some fund managers who have felt forced by their investors to be more active than they feel comfortable with.

We will find out who they are over the next few years. So, on to the interesting active funds of the day. I'm keen on emerging markets at the moment. First, because, as Peter Warburton of Economic Perspectives points out, if the thing to be scared of at the moment is the unwinding of extreme monetary policy, surely one should keep one's money in places where there hasn't been any.

The funds to buy now

And second, because they look like they offer a bit more value than overpriced developed markets. Sadly, one of my new favourites, the

HMG Global Emerging Markets Fund

, which invests only in high-quality, low-priced, dividend-paying listed emerging market subsidiaries of long-established developed market companies (such as Sanepar, the Brazilian subsidiary of Vivendi) isn't open to individual investors. To access the fund, you will have to bully your wealth manager into buying it for you.

Advertisement - Article continues below

There are good alternatives, however. The Cadence Strategic Asia fund is about as active/high conviction as it comes: the managers hold just 20 stocks they see as "undervalued in relation to their future cash-generating ability".

M&G Global Emerging Markets has rather more holdings but also an attractively high active share and a firm value bias (which I like). Outside emerging markets, you'll get pretty clear active management from Gary Channon's Aurora Trust (LSE: ARR), which I hold myself (and so do family members). Aurora holds fewer than 20 positions in stocks purchased at prices that "even with low expectations will deliver excellent returns".

Otherwise look at the Scottish Investment Trust (LSE: SCIN) run by Alasdair McKinnon (I also hold this one myself). It is global, high conviction and contrarian pretty much everything the modern fund investor should look for in an investment.

Finally, if you want to delegate all your decision making and buy a fund of interesting active funds you could do worse than look at the Premier Multi Asset Growth and Income fund. It is invested in the HMG fund I mention above and unusually for a fund of funds is a regular outperformer despite its double layer of costs.

This article was first published in the Financial Times




The power of mean reversion

When it comes to investing in funds, don’t chase the top performers – look for the cheapest ones.
1 Apr 2019

The most important number to look at before you buy any fund

Many investors get distracted by past performance when they buy a fund. But there’s something else to consider that will have a much bigger influence …
22 Mar 2019

How the boom in passive investing could create better-run companies

ESG investing, or "ethical investing" as it used to be called, is mostly about the marketing, says John Stepek. But it's not all bad.
24 Jan 2020

Investment trusts: the Cinderella of investment arrives at the ball

Investors should look beyond the market noise of a single year and examine the bigger picture. Max King explains what we can learn from 25 years of in…
8 Jan 2020

Most Popular


Want to make money in 2020? Gold and silver are looking like a good bet

If you want to make money from investing, says Dominic Frisby, it’s simple: find a bull market and go long. And in 2020 gold and silver are in a bull …
22 Jan 2020

Money Minute Wednesday 22 January: UK public borrowing

Today's Money Minute looks ahead to the latest on of the UK's public finances, with the Office for Budget Responsibility’s forecasts for borrowing thi…
22 Jan 2020

Money Minute Thursday 23 January: European interest rates

In today's Money Minute we look ahead to Christine Lagarde's second interest-rate-setting meeting at the European Central Bank.
23 Jan 2020

Money Minute Friday 24 January: the key to UK interest-rate cuts

Today's Money Minute looks ahead to the release of data that could hold the key to UK interest rates cuts. 
24 Jan 2020