Advertisement
Features

Carillion’s collapse should prompt better rules for PFI

Calls are mounting to make changes to the private finance initiative (PFI) following the collapse of Carillion.

879-Clarke-634
Business Secretary Greg Clark: facing criticism over Carillion

Business Secretary Greg Clark is "trying to get on the front foot" after criticism of the government's handling of the Carillion crisis, says Jim Pickard in the Financial Times.

He wants to fast-track an investigation into the conduct of the firm's directors and has asked the Financial Conduct Authority to look into the preparation of Carillion's accounts. But it may be a bit late to step up now. The fact that ministers continued to award the firm contracts after its "financial woes were made public" last July promises to be politically very awkward.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn says the collapse proves that the private sector shouldn't be involved in running Britain's public services, say George Parker and Gemma Tetlow in the same paper. Even David Willetts, a former Treasury official and "key promoter" of the private finance initiative (PFI), concedes that the Carillion collapse shows the risk is not always genuinely transferred to the private sector, since the government has an obligation to maintain public services.

At least Carillion hasn't been bailed out, says Andrew Lilico in The Daily Telegraph. That shows that capitalism is working, by "weeding out inefficient and obsolete companies, management and working practices". We want it to be as easy as possible for PFI contract-holders to fail, so that owners run them with maximum efficiency.

That misses the point of what happened, says Simon Jenkins in The Guardian. Carillion's fate reveals "rampant indiscipline in the contracts". A combination of "favouritism, cost escalation, excessive risk, obscene remuneration and reckless indebtedness" led to the firm's demise. Finding the "ideal mix of public-sector loyalty and private-sector incentive" isn't easy, but there should be clear rules, limiting, for example, "market dominance, debt and remuneration". This debacle should prompt "a review of how privatisation is working".

Advertisement
Advertisement

Recommended

How long can the good times roll?
Economy

How long can the good times roll?

Despite all the doom and gloom that has dominated our headlines for most of 2019, Britain and most of the rest of the developing world is currently en…
19 Dec 2019
Beyond the Brexit talk, the British economy isn’t doing too badly
Economy

Beyond the Brexit talk, the British economy isn’t doing too badly

The political Brexit pantomime aside, Britain is in pretty good shape. With near-record employment, strong wage growth and modest inflation, there is …
17 Oct 2019
UK house prices go into a gentle decline
House prices

UK house prices go into a gentle decline

Halifax’s house price index shows that UK house prices declined for the fourth month in a row in June.
9 Jul 2020
Rishi Sunak: buy a house, do it up and then go for a meal
UK Economy

Rishi Sunak: buy a house, do it up and then go for a meal

The chancellor has been on a spending spree. Will it help?
9 Jul 2020

Most Popular

An economics lesson from my barber
Inflation

An economics lesson from my barber

On reopening his shop after lockdown, Dominic Frisby’s barber doubled his prices. It’s all part of the post-Covid inflation process – and we’re going …
8 Jul 2020
Can Rishi Sunak save the economy with stamp duty cuts and half-price meal deals?
UK Economy

Can Rishi Sunak save the economy with stamp duty cuts and half-price meal deals?

John Stepek runs his eye over the chancellor's £30bn stimulus package and asks if it's enough to get the economy back on its feet after months of lock…
9 Jul 2020
A first-half home run for investment trusts
Sponsored

A first-half home run for investment trusts

The investment trust sector has seen some extraordinary performance in the first half of this year. Max King looks at what's behind it, and asks: is i…
7 Jul 2020