What a fund star rating tells you

John Stepek explains the ins and outs of fund star ratings, and why investors cannot always rely on them.


Fund ratings are big business. There are thousands of funds out there to a new investor, a star rating from an expert researcher may look like a way to narrow the field; and to an adviser, they provide a nice easy way to justify a recommendation. Unfortunately, one thing they won't do is uncover tomorrow's world-beating managers.

The Wall Street Journal recently looked at fund researcher Morningstar's widely used star ratings. Scouring data going back to 2003, the WSJ found that of the funds that enjoyed the top Morningstar five-star rating (and the influx of investor money that goes with it), only 12% had managed to hang on to their five stars five years later. Another 10% had seen their ranking drop to a single star.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Become a smarter, better informed investor with MoneyWeek.

I suspect that this won't surprise most MoneyWeek readers. We know by now that the number of managers who can consistently beat the market over a long period are vanishingly rare, and that identifying those managers in advance is extremely difficult. We also know as Morningstar itself acknowledges that "reversion to the mean" is a powerful force in investment. That's the argument for passive investing (buying a cheap fund that merely tracks the market rather than trying to beat it) in a nutshell.

However, while you may not get rich from sticking to them religiously, the star ratings do in fact have "some modest predictive value". A five-star fund today will on average have turned into a three-star fund in a decade's time. A one-star fund today will on average still only have 1.9 stars a decade from now. Similarly, funds rated four, three or two stars have all maintained their relative positions ten years down the line, averaging 2.8 stars, 2.5 and 2.2 respectively. What's going on?

Advertisement - Article continues below

As Morningstar's Russel Kinnel notes, the most reliable predictor of future returns is also the one over which you have the most control costs. For example, if you split the fund universe into quintiles'' by expense ratio (see below), then the funds in the cheapest quintile were three times more likely to beat the market than the most expensive funds, over the five years to December 2015. Morningstar's rankings take these costs into account, and as a result, notes Matt Levine on Bloomberg, its fund rankings have at least some predictive value because "it tends to pick the ones with low fees".

So before you buy a fund, go straight to the total expense ratio. Finding a cheap way to invest in your chosen market is probably the best thing you can do to increase your odds of beating the market.




The power of mean reversion

When it comes to investing in funds, don’t chase the top performers – look for the cheapest ones.
1 Apr 2019
Investment strategy

MoneyWeek's financial glossary

All those financial terms you wished you knew but were too embarrassed to ask about.
27 Mar 2020

The MoneyWeek Podcast – Charles Heenan: dominoes are falling; be very careful

Merryn talks to Charles Heenan, investment director of Kennox Asset Management. Assets are cheap, he says, but you need to be very, very careful about…
26 Mar 2020

Great frauds in history: the Hound of Hounslow

"Flash crash" trader Navinder Singh Sarao made around $70m from manipulating the futures market.
25 Mar 2020

Most Popular


What does the coronavirus crisis mean for UK house prices?

With the whole country in lockdown, the UK property market is closed for business. John Stepek looks at what that means for UK house prices, housebuil…
27 Mar 2020
EU Economy

The European Central Bank throws away the rulebook to bail out Italy

The ECB has removed all constraints on asset purchases and will now buy “whatever it takes” to tackle the coronavirus. John Stepek explains what it me…
26 Mar 2020

Gold is hard to find right now – so should you be buying?

With demand through the roof and the physical metal hard to find, it's not the best time to buy gold. But right now, says Dominic Frisby, you want to …
25 Mar 2020
UK Economy

The UK’s bailout of the self employed comes with a hidden catch

The chancellor’s £6.5bn bailout of the self employed is welcome. But it has hidden benefits for the taxman, says Merryn Somerset Webb.
27 Mar 2020