Could tactical voting stop Brexit?

With Labour facing meltdown, Tony Blair has urged voters to back alternative parties, including the Tories, in the general election if it means putting more anti-Brexit MPs in the House of Commons, reports the Financial Times. Indeed, he suggested that the issue of Brexit was "bigger than party allegiance". This call has already met with criticism, with Corbyn's office calling it "not helpful" and the moderate MP Chuka Umunna stating that "Tony Blair is wrong to suggest in any way that voters should look elsewhere".

"If you were to try to imagine an intervention that would elicit the most contempt and indignation from the people who are going to decide Labour's next leader, I don't think you could do much better," says Sam Glover in The Guardian. Indeed, Blair is "deluded" if he really thinks that "making sure people know that voting Conservative is always an option will somehow help the centre-left". It also overlooks the fact that "the party is already in crisis among Leave voters polling in February suggested that only 45% of Leave voters who voted Labour in 2015 still back the party".

"Brexit is a hugely complex issue for every political party, and for Labour it is more complicated still," says The Times. So it is no surprise that Blair, who is "normally so fluent", has "tied himself in knots". The problem is that "in southern metropolitan centres, most Labour voters are passionate Remainers", while "in smaller towns, in the north and in Wales, they are mainly ardent Brexiteers". Its task is also made more difficult by the fact that "the government's position on Brexit is deliberately opaque, meaning that a competent opposition would find itself trying to hammer nails into mist".

Start your trial of MoneyWeek today

Get unparalleled financial insight, analysis and expert opinion you can profit from.

Start your trial

Sign up for MoneyWeek’s free twice-daily newsletter.

Join more than 165,000 subscribers and keep yourself informed with latest financial news, insights and expert analysis to help you understand what really matters when it comes to your finances.

Join more than 165,000 subscribers and keep yourself informed with latest financial news, insights and expert analysis to help you understand what really matters when it comes to your finances.

Sign up

Blair's not the only one suggesting tactical voting. Open Britain, a pro-EU campaign group, has produced a list of 20 seats held by supporters of a hard Brexit (19 Conservatives and one Labour MP, Kate Hoey) in areas that either split evenly in the referendum or backed a Remain vote.

However, they are wrong to believe that tactical voting will "save Britain from the hardest of exits from the European Union", argues Rafael Behr in the New Statesman. After all, "if you're a voter in Chipping Barnet who backed a Remain vote because you were worried about your house price, is Jeremy Corbyn really the answer to your problems"? Similarly, many people in seats such as Vauxhall, held by the pro-Brexit Kate Hoey, "believe their own interests are better served by sending a Labour MP to Westminster rather than refighting the referendum".

But this isn't simply about Brexit, says Polly Toynbee in The Guardian. It's a matter of survival. Polls suggest Labour could fall below 100 seats or become "the party of Merseyside and London". An unbridgeable chasm has opened up between Labour's traditional working-class supporters and Labour's leaders. Many people in the north now think Labour "is the party of posh metropolitans who defend only immigrants and people on benefits". In the "blue tsunami" to come, "every Labour seat needs saving in any way possible". Tactical voting and progressive alliances "can save a few".