Populist challengers are as bad as the elite
Book review: Rebel: How To Overthrow The Emerging OligarchyHeady but standard libertarian fare from Douglas Carswell, says Matthew Partridge.
Published by Head of Zeus, £18.99
Douglas Carswell has hadan eventful few years. After moving from the Conservatives to Ukip inAugust 2014, he managedto hold his seat at both thesubsequent by-election, andthe 2015 general election. However, his libertarianviews sat uneasily with NigelFarage's populist approach,and the two have clashedover a wide range of issues,culminating in his recentdecision to quit Ukip andbecome an independent MP.
MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Carswell's new book, Rebel,is an attempt to outline hispolitical philosophy. In it, he arguesthat the current establishment, bothpolitical and business, is corrupt anddeliberately constructed so as to avoidpublic scrutiny. This isn't a particularlynew idea: you can hear variations on thistheme from everyone from Beppe Grilloin Italy to Donald Trump in America.However, the big twist is that Carswellthinks that the populist challengers to the status quo, such as Trump, Grilloand Farage, are just as bad as the elitethat they are trying to replace.
Indeed,Carswell is particularly scathing aboutthe Ukip leader. Rather than trying tochange, or at least reform, the system,these politicians are only concernedwith trying to grab more power for themselves, he says, using fear andhysteria to further their own interests.
Instead of trying to replace the peopleat the top, Carswell thinks that we needto make some fundamental changes tothe way that we regulate business andfinance. We need to avoid following theexample of medieval Venice and early modern China, where entrepreneurialactivity and businesses ended up beingenmeshed in a web of regulation designedto maintain the elite's strangleholdon power. This led to stagnation anddecline, while countries that stayed opento innovation, such as 16th-centuryHolland and 19th-century Britain,became economic superpowers.
This is all heady stuff. But look closelyand much of Carswell's programmeis standard libertarian fare, such asdismantling the welfare state, replacingpublic services with personal savingsaccounts, and breaking up the BBC.
Such policies would accentuate inequalitywithout stimulating enterprise, andwould make the oligarchy even morepowerful. His idea of growing UK-UStrade by accepting US standards alsodeliberately overlooks the fact that USstandards are much weaker than ours.Finally, some of the stranger ideas heputs forward include ending limitedliability for bankers and having multiplecurrencies circulate in the UK at thesame time. These proposals are simplyunworkable in a modern economy.
Get the latest financial news, insights and expert analysis from our award-winning MoneyWeek team, to help you understand what really matters when it comes to your finances.

-
Nationwide promises to protect all its branches from closures until at least 2030The building society has extended its pledge to keep all high street Nationwide and Virgin Money branches open, now until at least 2030.
-
Could dividend tax nearly double in the Budget?Self-employed directors and investors, including pensioners, who get an income from company shares would be hit if the rumoured move to hike dividend tax goes ahead.