How dear are US stocks?

The Cape ratio is a popular metric for valuing stockmarkets. Cris Sholto Heaton explains how it works, and what it tells us about the American market.


The cyclically adjusted price/earnings (Cape) ratio is a popular metric for valuing stockmarkets, especially among investors who believe that the US market is grossly overvalued by historical standards. Cape, which was devised by Robert Shiller of Yale University and John Campbell of Princeton University, measures the value of the market relative to average earnings over the past ten years, adjusted for inflation.

Advertisement - Article continues below

At present, the Cape for the US is around 26, compared with a long-term average of around 16. On face value, this suggests that unless earnings grow much faster than they have done over the long term, investors are likely to be disappointed.

But could the Cape ratio be overstating how expensive the US market is? Some analysts and investors argue that record-low interest rates and long-term bond yields justify higher stock prices. Financial assets aren't valued in isolation, but relative to each other: if you can only get 1.5% per year from bonds (after inflation), compared with almost 3.5% per year over the last 50 years, you might expect stocks to be priced to give you 4% per year, say, rather than the 6% you might previously have expected.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Make a few assumptions about what investors can reasonably expect in today's market environment and the US Cape ratio no longer looks stretched, says John Higgins of Capital Economics: it's possible that it should be around 23-24, suggesting the market is modestly overvalued at best.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Of course, this assumes that interest rates remain low by long-term standards. That's quite possible central banks are in no rush to hike but not guaranteed.Significantly higher rates would make stocks look expensive. But would they still be as expensive as one would conclude from comparing Cape to its history? Possibly not, says Jeremy Siegel of Wharton Business School in a recent paper in the Financial Analysts Journal.

The Cape ratio today is not exactly the same as it would have been decades ago, because earnings have not been calculated consistently over time. "Changes in accounting practices since 1990 have depressed reported earnings during economic downturns to a much greater degree than in the earlier years."

If instead you calculate the Cape using national statistics on corporate profits compiled by the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA), instead of those reported by companies, it looks more reasonable relative to its long-term average (see chart above).

Allow for the fact that firms increasingly return cash through share buybacks rather than dividends, which pushes up growth rate of earnings per share (because there are fewer shares in issue), and the overvaluation shrinks further. All told, it's still very difficult to make the case that US stocks are cheap today, but they may not be as expensive as the Cape ratio suggests.




The British equity market is shrinking

British startups are abandoning public stockmarkets and turning to deep-pocketed Silicon Valley venture capitalists for their investment needs.
8 Nov 2019

There are lots of reasons to be bearish – but you should stick with the bulls

There are plenty of reasons to be gloomy about the stockmarkets. But the trend remains up, says Dominic Frisby. And you don’t want to bet against the …
17 Jul 2019

Good news on jobs scares US stockmarkets

June brought the best monthly US jobs growth of the year, but stockmarkets were not best pleased.
11 Jul 2019

Will inflation return – or is “Japanification” the real threat?

SPONSORED CONTENT – Should we actually be concerned about deflation in the wake of Covid-19?
3 Jul 2020

Most Popular


House price crash: UK property prices are falling – so where next?

With UK property prices falling for the first time in eight years, are we about to see a house price crash? John Stepek looks at what’s behind the sli…
2 Jul 2020

The end of the bond bull market and the return of inflation

Central bank stimulus, surging post-lockdown demand and the end of the 40-year bond bull market. It all points to inflation, says John Stepek. Here’s …
30 Jun 2020

How can markets hit new record highs when the economy is in such a mess?

Despite the world being in the midst of a global pandemic, America's Nasdaq stock index just hit an all-time high. And it's not the only index on a bu…
3 Jul 2020