Labour stumbles into Osborne’s trap

published 16 October 2015

15-10-15-McDonnell-634 — John McDonnell's U-turn took Labour backbenchers by surprise

Shadow Chancellor John McDonnell "is a fan of straight-talking, honest politics", says Dan Hodges in The Daily Telegraph. "So he'll appreciate the following observation... John McDonnell is a dangerous left-wing ideological clown." A mere few weeks ago, at the Labour party conference and in a Guardian interview, McDonnell unilaterally said that Labour would back Chancellor George Osborne's fiscal charter, which would enshrine in law the requirement for the government to balance the books by 2018/2019, then run a budget surplus in "normal times".

In his speech, he said that Osborne was using the fiscal charter as a "political stunt. A trap for us to fall into" in order to brand Labour "deficit deniers". Why then, this Monday, did he "proceed to hurl himself into the very trap" he had identified by unilaterally reversing his position and announcing that he wouldn't support the fiscal charter?

The U-turn saw Jeremy Corbyn face a "damaging Commons rebellion" on Wednesday, as dozens of furious backbenchers, urged on by Osborne, considered defying his authority by voting in favour of the charter, says Ben Riley-Smith in The Daily Telegraph. A confusing memo sent out to Labour MPsclaimed Labour had changed its stance because the new fiscal charter is different to the one Labour voted for in January, but made no mention of why McDonnell had shifted position.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE

Get 6 issues free

https://cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.net/flexiimages/mw70aro6gl1676370748.jpg

Sign up to Money Morning

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

The ridiculous thing is that Labour should have skirted Osborne's trap "with ease", says the FT. "Governments are elected to change the law" and there is no reason why a future Labour chancellor should feel legally or morally bound to follow his predecessor's path. Osborne himself overturned a Labour attempt at the same trick, calling the Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2010 "vacuous and irrelevant". This "shambles" has lost Labour an opportunity to "set out a credible alternative strategy" and raises the question of whether McDonnell "even grasps the terms of the debate".

He and Corbyn campaigned against austerity all summer "before pledging support for a law that would have delivered more of it". Did they not bother to understand the policy? Labour's disarray in just one month the re-shuffle, the anthem and IRA debacles, the "chaos" over Trident don't go unnoticed by the public, which had long ceased to trust Labour with the economy in any case. "This is a disaster for Labour, but also unhealthy for British politics."

Emily has worked as a journalist for more than thirty years and was formerly Assistant Editor of MoneyWeek, which she helped launch in 2000. Prior to this, she was Deputy Features Editor of The Times and a Commissioning Editor for The Independent on Sunday and The Daily Telegraph. She has written for most of the national newspapers including The Times, the Daily and Sunday Telegraph, The Evening Standard and The Daily Mail, She interviewed celebrities weekly for The Sunday Telegraph and wrote a regular column for The Evening Standard. As Political Editor of MoneyWeek, Emily has covered subjects from Brexit to the Gaza war.

Aside from her writing, Emily trained as Nutritional Therapist following her son's diagnosis with Type 1 diabetes in 2011 and now works as a practitioner for Nature Doc, offering one-to-one consultations and running workshops in Oxfordshire.