Are pension Isas a good idea?
Pensions and Isas both offer savers tax-efficient ways to save, but in slightly different ways. So, how will a 'pensions Isa' work? Merryn Somerset Webb explains.
Hoping for a break from changes to pensions regulation? Too bad it looks like more are on the way. At his last budget, Chancellor George Osborne said that (more) "radical change" was possible, change that might make a pension more like an individual savings account (Isa). Pensions and Isas both offer savers tax-efficient ways to save. But they do so slightly differently.
With an Isa you put in taxed income. It compounds tax-free (no tax on dividends or capital gains) and you withdraw it tax-free. It is taxed, then exempt. With a pension you put in tax-free income. It compounds tax-free, but you pay tax as and when you withdraw the money. It is exempt, then taxed. So the idea of a "pension Isa" is to switch the system so you put in taxed money and take it out tax-free perhaps with a government top-up along the way.
There are two schools of thought on this. One is convinced that savers must have tax relief upfront, to incentivise them to save. The other points out that people are more than happy to save into Isas with only the promise of future tax exemption, and also notes that upfront exemption isn't cheap: it costs the Treasury £40bn a year with most of the benefit going to higher-rate taxpayers a nastily regressive system. So what's best?
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Osborne has launched a consultation, which we hope will recommend a new Isa-style pension differing only from an ordinary Isa by restricting when the funds can be drawn down (perhaps from 60 or 65). It would be simple (almost no one outside the industry understands pensions, but pretty much everyone understands Isas), which would motivate savers more than upfront tax relief ever has.
Not everyone agrees. The main problem, says David Robbins of Tower Watson in the Financial Times, is that this system could be seriously unstable. Say a new pension Isa were put in place with a 50p per pound top up to savings, up to a limit of, say, £4,000 a year (as suggested by the Centre for Policy Studies). "The top-up would be easy to tweak, an irresistible plaything for future chancellors".
Given endless regulatory change, who could be confident that on retirement they would really be able to access their cash without paying more tax? We have sympathy with this view. But the current system suffers the same problem, and a lot of that is a direct result of its complexity. If voters don't really understand something, it's easy to fiddle with.
If they do understand it, fiddling is harder. That's why the Isa system has been pretty much unchanged since 1999 and why child trust funds have been changed to Isas. It is also why we think that, if we want people to save sustainably for their futures, a pension Isa could be the way to go.
Sign up to Money Morning
Our team, led by award winning editors, is dedicated to delivering you the top news, analysis, and guides to help you manage your money, grow your investments and build wealth.
Merryn Somerset Webb started her career in Tokyo at public broadcaster NHK before becoming a Japanese equity broker at what was then Warburgs. She went on to work at SBC and UBS without moving from her desk in Kamiyacho (it was the age of mergers).
After five years in Japan she returned to work in the UK at Paribas. This soon became BNP Paribas. Again, no desk move was required. On leaving the City, Merryn helped The Week magazine with its City pages before becoming the launch editor of MoneyWeek in 2000 and taking on columns first in the Sunday Times and then in 2009 in the Financial Times
Twenty years on, MoneyWeek is the best-selling financial magazine in the UK. Merryn was its Editor in Chief until 2022. She is now a senior columnist at Bloomberg and host of the Merryn Talks Money podcast - but still writes for Moneyweek monthly.
Merryn is also is a non executive director of two investment trusts – BlackRock Throgmorton, and the Murray Income Investment Trust.
-
What the Employment Rights Bill means for your workplace rights
New workplace reforms are set to give employees new rights to benefits and flexible working
By Marc Shoffman Published
-
GSK share price surges after $2.2bn Zantac drug settlement
GSK has settled lawsuits in the US that alleged the drugmaker’s now-discontinued heartburn drug Zantac triggered cancer
By Chris Newlands Published