The bear market has unfinished business

Stocks are rising for the moment, explains Andrew Van Sickle. But the longer-term trend is still unmistakably bearish.

Are we still stuck in a long-term bear market? That sounds like a stupid question, says John Authers in the Financial Times. The S&P 500, which sets the tone for the rest of the world, has almost trebled since March 2009. It now stands at a new record high. But the question isn't as straightforward as it seems.

In 2003, a multi-year rally began in Western markets. Many hailed a new long-term bull market. Others, including MoneyWeek, suspected that the rally was probably just a bounce within a long-term, or secular, bear market a huge bear-market rally.

In 2008, we were proved right: the S&P plumbed new depths, proving that the post-2000 bear market had not ended.So could this rally be another massive bear-market rally? Yes. Here's why.

Secular bulls and bears

They then overcompensate by being bearish for years, during which they avoid or sell assets until they become absolute bargains. These long-term valuation upswings and downswings secular bulls and bears last for 15 years on average.

In secular bulls, cyclically adjusted price/earnings (Cape) ratios rise from single digits to above 20. The pattern was evident in the big post-war rally of the mid-1940s to the mid-1960s and during the 1920s.

Between 1982 and 2000, the biggest secular bull on record, the S&P's Cape rose from around seven to over 40, when the tech bubble peaked.

Conversely, the 1966-82 bear market ground valuations down from high double digits back to single digits. There was another secular bear from 1929 to the mid-1940s. 2000 marked the start of the latest one.

Fifteen years on, history suggests we should really be getting going on a new bull cycle. But the last bear may not have hit bottom yet. In 2000, the euphoria peaked and the Cape began to fall. But it was still historically stretched in the 20s when the 2003 rebound began.

Then, in 2009, it only fell to ten, not to six or seven, the sort of single-digit values that have historically heralded a secular bottom. Now it is back to overvalued levels. If the bear market isn't over yet, it doesn't necessarily mean that stocks must plunge.

The other way for valuations to fall to enticing levels is for earnings to rise as stocks grind sideways. Secular bear markets are usually a messy combination of the two.

It's the economy

The 1966-82 bear was a result of inflation getting out of control; the following bull market was all about the defeat of inflation and deregulation. The post-2000 era can be seen as a long economic hangover.

Central banks inflated the credit bubble in order to mitigate the impact of the bursting of the tech bubble. Then they printed unprecedented amounts of money to temper the effect of the burst credit bubble. The sub-par global recovery shows we are still stuck in the hangover.

We certainly aren't in an economic environment that history suggests accompanies a secular bull market.

It seems plausible that central banks' continual liquidity boosts have prevented valuations from hitting the usual floor, making them pricier than the economic backdrop would warrant. Without constant money printing, stocks would be nowhere near this far ahead of the fundamentals.

Can central bankers put off the evil day forever? The shaky, artificial nature of the rally, and the still-lacklustre economic backdrop, makes us suspect that the post-2000 bear may yet have unfinished business.

Recommended

What can the “January barometer” tell us about 2022 stockmarket prospects?
Investment strategy

What can the “January barometer” tell us about 2022 stockmarket prospects?

How the stockmarket performs in the first month of the year can often have a bearing on its performance for the remainder. Max King looks at what it’s…
10 Jan 2022
Which investment trusts performed the best in 2021?
Investment trusts

Which investment trusts performed the best in 2021?

Shivani Khandekar runs through the top ten investment trusts of 2021 – and the worst performing trusts – and looks ahead to 2022.
7 Jan 2022
French stocks are back in fashion
European stockmarkets

French stocks are back in fashion

France’s CAC 40 stockmarket index gained 29% in 2021, making it the world’s best performing major market.
7 Jan 2022
Crunch time for stockmarkets as interest rates rise
Stockmarkets

Crunch time for stockmarkets as interest rates rise

Stockmarkets, having been puffed up by ultra-low interest rates, are in for a rough ride as the world’s central banks start to raise them.
7 Jan 2022

Most Popular

Five unexpected events that could shock the markets in 2022
Stockmarkets

Five unexpected events that could shock the markets in 2022

Forget Covid-19 – it’s the unexpected twists that will rattle markets in 2022, says Matthew Lynn. Here are five possibilities
31 Dec 2021
Which investment trusts performed the best in 2021?
Investment trusts

Which investment trusts performed the best in 2021?

Shivani Khandekar runs through the top ten investment trusts of 2021 – and the worst performing trusts – and looks ahead to 2022.
7 Jan 2022
Interest rates might rise faster than expected – what does that mean for your money?
Global Economy

Interest rates might rise faster than expected – what does that mean for your money?

The idea that the US Federal Reserve could raise interest rates much earlier than anticipated has upset the markets. John Stepek explains why, and wha…
6 Jan 2022