Telecoms giant BT is in exclusive talks with mobile provider EE. It is set to buy the company for around £12.5bn, which would be a record purchase for the former state monopoly. BT had also considered buying Telefonica's O2, which was previously known as Cellnet.
BT itself was forced to spin off Cellnet in 2001 in order to pay down the telecoms' bubble-induced debt. The deal announced this week would see EE's owners Deutsche Telekom and Orange take small stakes in BT.
What the commentators said
BT is paying around eight times operating earnings. That compares well with similar deals. Verizon paid nine times for the 45% of Verizon Wireless that was still available.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
EE was chosen because it has more customers and has invested heavily in 4G. BT wants to be able to provide the fastest mobile internet to complement its fibre-broadband offering, said Daniel Thomas in the FT.
It is now in a position to offer "quad-play": landline and mobile phone connections, along with TV and broadband, all in one package. These have done well in Europe and the US.
But will they do well here? CEO Gavin Patterson has yet to prove that the British will go for quad-play. Its success elsewhere is a result of "defensive offerings", says Chris Blackhurst in the Evening Standard: price-cutting bundles to prevent customers switching to cheaper alternatives.
"There is no evidence" that we particularly want to group all four services together. Indeed not, said James Moore in The Independent. Quad-play has been available for seven years with Virgin Media. "It doesn't appear to have had a massive impact." And most people have several contracts with varying expiry dates.
The hassle of changing all these "adds to the inertia" BT will need to confront. Quad-play does at least mean there is just one place to complain to when you're unhappy. Still, "given that most providers turn a tin ear to their customers that doesn't necessarily count for much".
