Astra bid causes political storm

Politicians have waded into the debate over Pfizer's takeover attempt of AstraZeneca.

This week, AstraZeneca attempted to garner its shareholders' support for remaining independent rather than succumbing to a Pfizer bid by pointing to its promising drug pipeline and future revenues.

The British company has rejected an improved £63bn, £50 a share bid from the US pharmaceuticals giant, saying the valuation was still too low. Concern also grew over the future of scientific research in Britain amid fears of cost-saving closures of Astra facilities by a victorious Pfizer.

Business Secretary Vince Cable said he was worried about the bid on "public interest grounds". Labour leader Ed Miliband accused Prime Minister David Cameron of acting as a "cheerleader" for Pfizer.

What the commentators said

To stop a deal, the government would have to argue that an independent Astra is crucial to the future of Britain plc, as Dominic O'Connell pointed out in The Sunday Times.That's "a tricky argument when Astra itself has been the biggest culler of pharma scientists' jobs in recent years".

Shareholders are the other key constituency. Many will have been impressed by Astra's presentation this week, said Nils Pratley in The Guardian. CEO Pascal Soriot "has succeeded in creating a sense that things could go very well for Astra after 2017", given the improvement in the pipeline under his aegis in the past 18 months. The upshot is that the price Astra can demand from Pfizer has probably risen to £60 a share.

Should the government interfere in future takeovers if the scientific research base appears at risk? No, said Allister Heath in The Daily Telegraph. The key to encouraging firms to grow their scientific base in the UK is to get the framework right: put tax incentives in place, maintain high levels of science teaching in schools and universities, and have plenty of venture capital available for entrepreneurial scientists.

That will work much better than trying to pick winners or seek guarantees from companies that they will stay for a few years.

The hands-off formula "has worked well in other areas", said Heath. Foreign ownership revived the car industry after "years of home-grown idiocy". Had there been a "public interest" test on foreign ownership of cars, we would probably "have given up on that key sector altogether".

The bottom line is that shareholders are "less likely to take bad decisions" than politicians and countries open to market forces are more likely to flourish than those that politicise business.

Recommended

When will interest rates go up?
UK Economy

When will interest rates go up?

The Bank of England raised rates to 4.25%, its 11th consecutive increase. Does the base rate have further to go?
30 Mar 2023
Best junior stocks and shares ISA platforms
Isas

Best junior stocks and shares ISA platforms

A junior stocks and shares ISA is a great way to save for your child tax-efficiently. But it can be confusing deciding which investment platform to ch…
28 Mar 2023
What is inflation and how will it affect you?
Inflation

What is inflation and how will it affect you?

There has been much talk of inflation recently. But what exactly is it and what does it mean for our money?
24 Mar 2023
Bank of England hikes key interest rate to 4.25%
UK Economy

Bank of England hikes key interest rate to 4.25%

The Bank of England raised rates by 0.25% following a surprise jump in inflation.
23 Mar 2023

Most Popular

11 investment trusts for inflationary times
Investments

11 investment trusts for inflationary times

Inflation eats away at the value of your money, but these investment trusts can help you grow your wealth.
28 Mar 2023
Will energy prices go down in 2023?
Personal finance

Will energy prices go down in 2023?

Ofgem’s price cap is now predicted to fall below £2,000, based on average typical use, from July, for the first time since 2022. We have all the detai…
21 Mar 2023
This contrarian indicator suggests we’re at the bottom of the mining cycle
Commodities

This contrarian indicator suggests we’re at the bottom of the mining cycle

Mining might be a boring industry, but investors shouldn’t ignore it, says Dominic Frisby.
29 Mar 2023