Steer clear of structured products

Complex financial products may sound like great buys. But as Tim Bennett explains, if it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.

We have never been fans of structured products' as investments, and it seems we are not alone. As The Daily Telegraph's Andrew Oxlade notes, "the European Union is often derided, but on the odd occasion its policy wonks are bang on the money". Brussels is increasingly unhappy with these products too.

The reason the grand-sounding European Securities and Markets Authority has taken a keen interest is that the Germans have been buying these products by the busload. One million were sold there last year, up from just 160,000 five years ago. The one piece of good news is that here they are far less popular, probably because "banks have largely given up selling them quivering under the fear of being caught for mis-selling. Again."

So, what are structured products, and why do we dislike them? The terms vary from product to product, but the basic deal doesn't. You hand over your money to buy a fund that promises a seemingly no-lose deal. Typically you get a percentage of the return in the stock market over a chosen period (say 50% of the return over five years), or, if the market drops, a percentage (usually up to 100%) of your money back, depending on how far below a reference level' (ie, where it is now) it ends up. This sort of offer sounds like a great way to hedge your bets, get some upside in uncertain markets and cap your downside.

But the terms are often complex (especially as regards the conditions that need to be met to get all your money back), your money is tied up for long periods, and the charges are high. So you end up paying a heavy price for little upside. The latest study, for example, reckons the median return from 2,750 of these products has been just 2.5% a year since 2008. Over the same period the S&P Europe 350 index has done slightly better and paid dividend income on top. So our advice remains the same: avoid expensive, complex products.

Something else to avoid wasting your time on is offers that sound too good to be true. As Tony Hetherington notes on Thisismoney.co.uk, a firm called Global Green Alternatives is claiming to offer a 60%-70% investment return within 12 months by investing in an organic fertiliser product called Geo Minerals. But as Hetherington says, "if investors could make a 60% profit, then why would farmers not simply buy the stuff right now"?

With interest rates at near zero and decent returns hard to find, these offers can be tempting. But the chances of getting your money back, let alone making any, are usually slim.

Recommended

Interest rates are rising, here are the best savings accounts on the market
Savings

Interest rates are rising, here are the best savings accounts on the market

With inflation at more than 9%, your savings are not going to keep pace with the rising cost of living. But you can at least slow the rate at which yo…
24 Jun 2022
Don’t be tempted by cashback mortgage deals
Mortgages

Don’t be tempted by cashback mortgage deals

Many lenders are now offering “cashback mortgages” that can return up to £1,000 to you on completion. But beware, says Ruth Jackson-Kirby. Cashback of…
21 Jun 2022
Should you overpay your mortgage?
Mortgages

Should you overpay your mortgage?

Overpaying your mortgage could knock years off your repayment period and save you thousands of pounds in interest. Ruth Jackson explains the pros and …
16 Jun 2022
Why you shouldn’t rush to fix your energy tariff
Personal finance

Why you shouldn’t rush to fix your energy tariff

Fixed-tariff energy deals are becoming more tempting, but not all households can benefit, says Ruth Jackson-Kirby.
16 Jun 2022

Most Popular

The ten investment trusts with the highest dividend yields
Investment trusts

The ten investment trusts with the highest dividend yields

Investment trusts are one of the best ways to participate in the stockmarket, and the way they are structured means they can maintain their dividends …
23 Jun 2022
Governments will sink in a world drowning in debt
Global Economy

Governments will sink in a world drowning in debt

Rising interest rates and soaring inflation will leave many governments with unsustainable debts. Get set for a wave of sovereign defaults, says Jonat…
23 Jun 2022
Why a recession will do us good
UK Economy

Why a recession will do us good

A period of slimming down is always painful, but it leaves us healthier for the long run, says Matthew Lynn.
26 Jun 2022