Features

How we can create more jobs and cut the deficit at the same time

Spending cuts alone won't solve Britain's debt problems. We need more jobs. That means encouraging the entrepreneurs who create them. Here, Simon Caufield proposes four measures to get Britain back to work.

Only once in 800 years has a government avoided default once its debt reached 90% of GDP. That's according to Carmen Reinhart and Kenneth Rogoff in their study of financial crises in their book, This Time is Different. That was Britain after the Napoleonic wars, when some of the repayments were made with the spoils of war.

Why does this matter to you? Because, if you include public sector pension liabilities, current UK debt is well past 90% of GDP. There's still much complacency about our debt problem. We have been lulled into a false sense of security by ultra-low interest rates. And many other countries have the same problem.

History suggests that sovereign defaults happen several years after recessions. During the downturn, the private sector stops borrowing, and lenders prefer the security of debt backed by government; so there are plenty of buyers and gilt yields are low. But a few years into the recovery, the lenders get indigestion. Renewed borrowing by companies and individuals provides competition for government debt. That's when yields rise and governments default.

The UK coalition government appears to understand the severity of the problem. But it remains to be seen how determined and effective they will be in implementing spending cuts over the next few years. And reducing debt is only half the problem.

Unemployment is already very high. On 5 November, the Financial Times reported startling figures from the Office for National Statistics: one third of homes in major cities including Liverpool, Nottingham and Glasgow have no-one who is employed. And government cuts threaten to send unemployment soaring higher. If it goes too far, we'll be in a vicious circle: further cuts reduce tax revenues; more spending raises interest costs - Ireland seems to be getting to that point right now. In Japan, interest payments and social security spending alone are already higher than tax receipts. There is no way out from there; both will default.

We need to encourage job creators more

I reckon I know something about job creation; I've been an owner of several small businesses. I founded a software company in 2002. Most people especially politicians who have not been entrepreneurs cannot possibly know how hard it can be to create jobs. We could prove that our software boosted company profits by up to 40%; we did a pretty good job of managing the company. And yet twice we came within a few months of failing.

Nine months after launch, we had no customers. We were still developing the software at that stage. So it was tough to persuade companies to buy something that did not yet exist. We nearly ran out of cash. Sales also came to a grinding halt in 2009. Our existing customers paid an annual licence fee, so we still had revenue from them - that's how we survived at all. But three of our 12 customers went bankrupt and stopped paying. We had to make half our 100 employees redundant. We were again just a few months from running out of cash.

Special FREE report from MoneyWeek magazine: Don't be fooled - house prices will fall again!

  • Why UK property prices are set to collapse by 30%
  • When it will be time to get back in and buy up dirt cheap property

Our society undervalues job creators. Our tax system carries incentives for corporate investment including capital allowances and interest on debt. We have tax breaks on individual savings accounts (Isas) and pension contributions. Over the years, there have been incentives for home buying. The coalition would like to bring back a married persons allowance.

Economists from the right-wing argue for low marginal tax rates which benefit higher income groups. Left-wingers argue for higher benefits and government spending which favours lower income groups. Trade unions fight for the low-paid. But who lobbies for the no-paid?

The economic recovery is clearly too feeble to reduce unemployment. And yet the tax treatment of job creation is appalling. Companies have to pay 12.8% of wages in employers' National Insurance contributions. Many also make pension contributions for staff and provide other benefits. Employment laws make it expensive to shed labour. So when the economic outlook is so uncertain, is it any surprise that companies are reluctant to hire?

We've got the economic, political and social debate all wrong in this country. It should not be about capital versus labour, or rich versus poor. It should be about job creators and job takers. I don't care how rich or poor you are, if you create jobs, you are a hero. You are a hero if you are self-employed, creating a job just for yourself. You are a hero if you're an entrepreneur. And you are a hero if you run a company trying to grow.

In short, we need to support job creators far more than we do. That means radically changing the tax code. Here are just four moves that would help:

Abolishing employers' National Insurance surcharge Sweeping away regulations which make hiring harder or less attractive Granting entrepreneurs the right to charge their investment against personal income for tax Lower personal tax rates for the self-employed and entrepreneurs

Of course, this would all have to be paid for given the debt situation. But I would rather raise any other tax to release the surge of job creation that these changes would bring about. There are two types of tax I'd target specifically.

In the interest of balance, tax breaks on capital could be eliminated. Companies would be getting a reduction in employment costs so an offsetting rise in capital costs would be fair. After all, not all investment promotes jobs. Labour-saving machinery actually destroys jobs. I'm not saying for a moment that companies should never invest in productivity-boosting technology, but why actively favour capital investment at the expense of job creation? That way lies the path of Japan. The world's best manufacturers have so automated their factories that they employ virtually no-one. So capital allowances can go.

An increase in corporation tax would be justified. And a reduction in the deductibility of interest payments might also be needed, just so that the net effect of all the changes is small. And capital gains tax could be allowed to rise - it's still below personal income tax rates. This wouldn't discourage entrepreneurs. When you start a company, you're not worried about whether you'll pay 28% or 40% on your eventual millions, you're far more worried about paying the bills in the next year. So give the tax breaks up-front by allowing investment in start-up companies to be charged against personal tax.

Britain looks likely to be short of jobs for the foreseeable future. We need to recast the tax code to encourage job creation. Let's also start celebrating job creators: the self-employed, entrepreneurs and companies of all shapes and sizes that are growing jobs. They're all heroes. We need so many more of them.

What do you think of Simon's views on job creation? Have your say in the comments below.

Simon Caufield edits the True Value newsletter, which is currently open to new subscribers. Find out more here

True Value is a regulated product issued by MoneyWeek Ltd.

Recommended

Greensill, Cameron and the return of Tory sleaze
UK Economy

Greensill, Cameron and the return of Tory sleaze

The collapse of Greensill Capital threw a spotlight on political lobbying when it emerged that former PM David Cameron had been fighting its corner. J…
17 Apr 2021
Recovery Loan Scheme: the latest government aid package for small businesses
Small business

Recovery Loan Scheme: the latest government aid package for small businesses

The Recovery Loan Scheme will help companies weather the pandemic
16 Apr 2021
UK mid-cap stocks look forward to life after lockdown
UK stockmarkets

UK mid-cap stocks look forward to life after lockdown

The FTSE 250 hit an all-time high at the end of last week, as investors look to a post-lockdown recovery.
16 Apr 2021
House prices: from boom to even bigger boom
House prices

House prices: from boom to even bigger boom

UK house prices have risen to new to record highs, says Nicole Garcia Merida. Demand continues to outpace supply, but continued low interest rates, th…
9 Apr 2021

Most Popular

Lab-grown meat: how “moo’s law” will drive innovation
Soft commodities

Lab-grown meat: how “moo’s law” will drive innovation

Jim Mellon and Anthony Chow, co-founders of Aim-listed Agronomics, explain why they believe that “cellular agriculture” will benefit from massive long…
16 Apr 2021
The bitcoin bubble will burst: here’s how to play it
Bitcoin

The bitcoin bubble will burst: here’s how to play it

The cryptocurrency’s price has soared far beyond its fundamentals, says Matthew Partridge. Here, he looks at how to short bitcoin.
12 Apr 2021
Lab-grown meat: the new agricultural revolution
Soft commodities

Lab-grown meat: the new agricultural revolution

Vegan alternatives are taking off, but the future of food technology lies in lab-grown meat – cultivating steaks and burgers from animal cells, says A…
16 Apr 2021