By David A Stockman
"Most 742-page jeremiads aren't much fun to read," writes Daniel Gross on The Daily Beast. But David Stockman's The Great Deformation is an exception. The ex-congressman and Ronald Reagan-era budget official's "revisionist history of the past 100 years of capitalism American-style, is a spirited, occasionally gleeful skewering of many of our most widely held assumptions and most lionised figures", by a man who "knows the world of which he writes from the inside out".
MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
The broad argument of the book, notes Marcus Brauchli in The Washington Post, is that since America abandoned all vestiges of the gold standard in the 1970s, loose monetary policy, chronic deficits, and a tax system that encourages speculation have resulted in recurring financial bubbles.
These include "the bubble in global oil and commodity prices in the 1970s, then the bubble in US stocks in the 1980s, the Tokyo bubble of the late 1980s, the Asian bubbles of the 1990s, the tech bubble at the millennium and finally the housing finance bubble that imploded so catastrophically in 2007".
The fact that on each occasion the world's central banks have just "doused the smouldering ruins with a flood of yet more cheap cash" has "softened the earth for the emergence of the next asset bubble".
Despite his background as a Republican, Stockman isn't out to score partisan political points, says Gross: "Few escape his opprobrium current and past policymakers, Roosevelt and Reagan, Democrats and Republicans, leveraged buyout titans, and corporate CEOs". And it's a powerful argument, which has won the book many admirers.
Stockman's scholarship is "top-notch", says Russell Winter in The Wall Street Examiner. The book packs in a "tremendous amount of highly informative historical context". Stockman "brilliantly connects the dots as to why the economy is functioning poorly and paints a picture of a future that will only become worse". It's good to see that "someone of influence finally had the fortitude to say what needs to be said".
Of course, not everyone agrees. "Some [of Stockman's] assertions will be found to be contentious," writes Kirkus Reviews. The book is certainly not without its flaws, says Brauchli. Stockman "has a curious predilection to believe conspiracies and assume the worst motivations in many people he writes about".
And surely, contrary to what he argues, "massive job losses, a non-functioning financial system and a shell-shocked nation aren't constructive', even if they might finally stir policymakers to consider another path". However, in all, this is an argument "worth hearing and heeding".
The Great Deformation by David A. Stockman. Published by PublicAffairs (£19.99).
-
The new 4% rule – how much should retirees really draw from their pension in 2026?Brits retiring in 2026 could be withdrawing too much from their pension pots if they stick to an old rule about ‘safe’ limits – with the risk of running out of money in retirement
-
Leaving it too late to gift inheritances costs some of Britain’s wealthiest families £3m eachEven average Brits are being landed with huge and unexpected inheritance tax bills because of a little understood rule around gifting, new figures show
