Why do ostensibly intelligent people pay six times their salary for a home they can ill afford? Why did equally smart people rush to buy shares in technology companies that didn't make any money and never would? The answer is mainly because other people were doing the same. Sadly, following others blindly is a certain route to financial ruin as Mobs, Messiahs, and Markets, the new book from MoneyWeek's publisher Bill Bonner and co-author Lila Rajiva, amply demonstrates.
In a sharp-witted jaunt through the mass hysteria that's defined markets and people through the ages, Bonner and Rajiva observe that when large groups of people "are thrown into the company of legions of their fellow men, some chemistry turns humans who are individually of irreproachable integrity and unimpeachable prudence into stark, raving blockheads". That's when they start burning witches', swapping tulip bulbs for houses, or, as we saw not so long ago, putting money into stocks ending in .com'. The message is simple. Man is a herd animal, say the authors. And just like the swallow or the wildebeest, he will move with his pack.
The writers don't restrict themselves to crowds; the follies and delusions of the political leaders and "world improvers" who stir up these hysterias, from Che Guevara to George Bush Jnr, are skewered in the irreverent style familiar to readers of MoneyWeek and Bonner's email newsletter, The Daily Reckoning. And special mention is reserved for Alan Greenspan, the man whose time at the helm of the Federal Reserve is arguably most to blame for the current financial crisis facing the markets.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
So what has all this got to do with investing? Understanding the psychology of crowds is central to understanding the psychology of the markets, says Bonner. It is the mob, and not the free-minded individual, that determines which way the FTSE 100 and every other asset class under the sun moves. But mobs make bad decisions, which means that the assets that are most popular are inevitably the ones set to lose latecomers the most money. If you can understand that, then you'll know what to do with your money when everyone else is scrabbling to get in or out of the next craze. Which is largely to do precisely the opposite.
To buy Mobs, Messiahs, and Markets: Surviving the Public Spectacle in Finance and Politics by William Bonner and Lila Rajiva (priced £16.99), visit www.moneyweek.com/bookshop, or call 01730-233870.
Bill and Lila on the war in Iraq: an extract from Mobs, Messiahs, and Markets
Americans had little doubt that they had liberated the desert tribes of Mesopotamia from "Tyranny", rather than imposed a new tyranny of their own. They managed to support and applaud the biggest growth in government spending, debt, and bureaucracy since Franklin Roosevelt, and applaud it, of all things, in the name of liberty...
Success has transformed a modest people whose greatest virtue was once minding their own business into a vainglorious race, who mind everyone's business but their own. They cannot save a dime themselves, but now they offer to save the entire planet. There was a time when they admired the English for their literature... the Germans for their organisation... the French for their intellect and style... and the Japanese for their industrial discipline. Now they turn their heads to the heavens and see only their own reflection in the clouds. They revere themselves with double the adoration and thrice the fidelity. Old Europe is a museum, they complain. It is rigid, cowardly, and gummed up with social welfare regulation. And Japan? The so-called miracle economy has been stuck in an on-again, off-again recession for more than 16 years, they gibe, because the Japanese lack the guts to restructure their economy along American lines.
This disdain is not based in logic or reason, of course. Few attitudes are. Or, as they say on Wall Street "Markets make opinions". That is to say, when stocks have been rising for a long while, investors have opinions about why the bull market will last forever. If stocks are falling, their feelings lead them to believe prices will continue to fall for all eternity. But, of all attitudes, none is so irrationally conceived and so inveterately held as people's good opinions of themselves. And Americans' opinions of themselves are no exception. Since they have created their success themselves, surely they must be in charge of it too, they think.
Discounted is the hard work of their fathers and grandfathers who went ahead of them. Dismissed are the virtues of thrift, sound money, limited government, and collective modesty. Flipping with boredom through the back pages of their history, Americans pay no attention to the dead. And the future... the unborn? It is as if they think the book has no sequel.... as if it were the last opus ever... the final word, the Omega Civilisation. We can almost hear the gods snickering. One day, historians will look back at our era and marvel at how George Bush and Tony Blair determined to convert the Iraqis to democracy. To our descendants, it will look like a mad caprice; a quaint, religious gesture; an act of remarkable faith or delusion, like missionaries showing the heathen the correct posture for copulation.
-
Parental contributions to kids' university living costs could reach £14,000 a yearParents helping kids with university living costs face contributions of up to £14,000 per year, according to a report from HEPI and TechnologyOne.
-
Rightmove: property asking prices hit record highNews Rising demand for top of the ladder home is boosting asking prices, Rightmove research shows. Is now a good time to sell a property?
