I've never been to Canada. I'm sure it's a wonderful place. It has vast reserves of mineral wealth, there's plenty of space, and it shares a border with the most powerful nation in the world (handy for all sorts of reasons). But one thing I can say for certain is that none of these considerable advantages has come about as the result of having Mark Carney head up their central bank for the past five years. So why is everyone getting so excited by the fact that he's going to take over from Sir Mervyn King as governor of the Bank of England?
We keep hearing that it's great to have an outsider' with a mandate to shake up' the Bank's stuffy' culture. Frankly, I couldn't care less about the Bank's culture, stuffy or otherwise. I'd much rather look at its record on the economy. On that front, the Bank made two really big mistakes over the past decade. The biggest error was to watch a huge property bubble inflate right before its eyes, and do nothing about it. In fact, it aided and abetted the bubble by keeping interest rates at rock-bottom levels and even cutting them when we had a sniff of a correction in summer 2005.
Its second-biggest mistake was in failing to allow the bubble to then burst properly. Americans got lucky, in that the Federal Reserve was unable to prevent their crash. Now it looks like they will bounce back to health before we do. In Britain, we've been left with a semi-deflated bubble, hordes of mortgage prisoners, and a vestigial mini-bubble in London, all of which are holding back our economy.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
So what interests me about Carney is: does his record suggest he'd have done anything different? Sadly not. That Canada is highly dependent on a now-imploding commodity boom is not Carney's fault. But that it also has one of the most overvalued housing markets in the world is at least partly down to his slashing interest rates after the financial crisis no different to the policies followed by every other central banker. There was even a joke website called Crack Shack or Mansion?' in which the viewer looks at pictures of ugly Vancouver properties and tries to guess which are drug dens, and which C$1m-plus homes. It's not easy I got fewer than half the answers right.
The website was set up in 2010 the problem has only got worse since then. The ratio of debt to disposable income for Canadian households is now more than 160%, higher than America at the peak of its bubble. However, it seems the Canadians might soon get a belated taste of the financial crisis the housing bubble may finally be bursting. The latest data suggest that price increases are slowing sharply, and sales have fallen too. So forget about the idea that Carney is coming over here to save us. Quite the contrary. He's escaping from Canada just in time.
