How to invest in anti-bubbles

The good news about bubbles is that they’re easy to spot. The bad news is that they’re hard to profit from.

Chinese tourists in front of  the Agricultural Bank of China © PHILIPPE LOPEZ/AFP/Getty Images
Chinese banks look cheap

Chinese tourists in front of the Agricultural Bank of China © PHILIPPE LOPEZ/AFP/Getty Images

Few investment topics garner as many headlines as market bubbles, and little wonder. They represent an opportunity to make a lot of money or a chance to rail against the irrationality of the herd. But how do you spot a bubble, and how can you profit from it? A new paper from Rob Arnott, Bradford Cornell and Shane Shepherd at US asset manager Research Affiliates, titled "Bubble, Bubble, Toil and Trouble", provides useful answers to both of those questions.

Advertisement - Article continues below

The good news is that a bubble is pretty easy to spot. It has two main characteristics. Firstly, "the asset or asset class offers little chance of a positive risk premium relative to bonds or cash, using a generally accepted valuation model with a plausible projection of expected cash flows". Secondly, investors don't care about this. They buy regardless of how ridiculous the valuation is, because they expect to sell at a profit to a "greater fool" further down the line. In short, bubbles happen when investors pile into clearly overpriced assets in the hope they'll keep rising.

Advertisement - Article continues below

So what looks bubbly today? The team highlights US tech stocks (the FANGs specifically), and US market trackers (top-heavy in such stocks) in general. They're also sceptical about cryptocurrency bitcoin, likening it to the tulip bubble of the 1630s. Of course, it's one thing to identify a bubble, but profiting directly from it is a lot harder. The risk with buying in is that it might be the top. The risk with short-selling (betting on a fall) is that it might go on for a lot longer. Either way, you lose.

Advertisement - Article continues below

So the best option, according to Arnott and his team, is to ignore bubbles altogether and instead invest in "anti-bubbles". These are the assets that are neglected while everyone is paying attention to the superstars, and so become so cheap that it takes "implausibly pessimistic assumptions in order to fail to deliver a solid risk premium". So where are these hated anti-bubble assets today?

Emerging-market value stocks and state-owned enterprises (SOEs) in particular look cheap, they reckon. The majority (two-thirds of the top 50) are in China, with half of those in the financial sector. There's no specific SOE index, but you could get exposure to many of the stocks with a China exchange-traded fund (ETF). One option to explore on this front could be the CSOP Source FTSE China A50 ETF (LSE: CHNA), which tracks the 50 largest companies listed on the Shanghai and Shezhen stock exchanges. More than 50% of the ETF is in financial stocks. As for developed markets well, you might be able to guess their favoured option. "We see turmoil over Brexit potentially creating an anti-bubble opportunity in UK shares." See page 4 for more.

I wish I knew what a yield curve was, but I'm too embarrassed to ask

The yield curve compares the yield on bonds of the same credit quality, but different maturities (so the Treasury yield curve charts the yields on everything from three-month US government debt to the 30-year Treasury). The curve normally slopes up from left to right, because longer-dated bonds typically yield more than shorter-term ones. That's because money today is usually worth more than money in a year's time. For taking the risk of waiting for longer to be repaid, investors want more interest.

Advertisement - Article continues below

If the yield curve starts to flatten in other words, the gap (or "spread") between yields on short-term bonds and long-term ones narrows then it suggests that investors believe inflation will fall (and so don't need as high a yield from longer-term bonds); or that short-term interest rates will rise (driving up the yield on shorter-term bonds); or both.

Eventually, a flat yield curve may give way to an inverted one. This suggests that investors expect interest rates in the future to be lower than today, meaning they are happy to lock in today's yields on longer-term bonds, because they expect them to be even lower tomorrow. That in turn suggests they expect the economy to slow down, forcing the central bank to cut rates in hope of boosting demand and getting growth going again. In recent months, the yield curve between the three-month US government debt and the ten-year has inverted. But the spread between the two-year and the ten-year (often seen as a more definitive recession signal) has remained positive.




Will inflation return – or is “Japanification” the real threat?

SPONSORED CONTENT – Should we actually be concerned about deflation in the wake of Covid-19?
3 Jul 2020
UK stockmarkets

Laura Foll: small companies, income, and the power of equity markets

Merryn talks to fund manager Laura Foll about value, income yields and the UK market's underperformance, plus the benefits of smaller companies and th…
1 Jul 2020

Great frauds in history: Nick Leeson – the man who broke Barings Bank

"Rogue trader" Nick Leeson’s losses cost his employer, Barings Bank, an estimated £860m, plunging it into bankruptcy.
1 Jul 2020

The end of currency a tailwind for UK investors

A weak pound and strong dollar are unlikely to keep bolstering returns for British investors over the next decade.
29 Jun 2020

Most Popular


House price crash: UK property prices are falling – so where next?

With UK property prices falling for the first time in eight years, are we about to see a house price crash? John Stepek looks at what’s behind the sli…
2 Jul 2020

How can markets hit new record highs when the economy is in such a mess?

Despite the world being in the midst of a global pandemic, America's Nasdaq stock index just hit an all-time high. And it's not the only index on a bu…
3 Jul 2020

The end of the bond bull market and the return of inflation

Central bank stimulus, surging post-lockdown demand and the end of the 40-year bond bull market. It all points to inflation, says John Stepek. Here’s …
30 Jun 2020