Book of the week: the problems with Chinese trade

Book review: The Silk Road Trap Jonathan Holslag argues that Beijing has repeatedly outmanoeuvred Brussels by getting Europe to open its markets in return for vague promises that the Chinese will do the same.

The-Silk-Road-Trap-150

How China's Trade Ambitions Challenge Europe

Polity Press, £14.99

We hear a lot about American complaints that China isn't playing by the rules of global trade, but Europe has much more cause to be bitter. Jonathan Holslag argues that over the last 20 years Beijing has repeatedly outmanoeuvred Brussels by getting Europe to open its markets in return for vague promises that the Chinese will do the same. Needless to say, those promises from the People's Republic have never come close to being fulfilled.

China still imposes a huge number of restrictions on imports from Europe, as well as on investment by European firms into China, which are required to share intellectual property if they want to take part in projects. At the same time, China heavily subsidises its domestic firms, many of which are owned by the state, and are therefore allowed to run up huge debts, which the state-owned banks continually roll over. In some cases, Chinese firms engage in outright dumping, deliberately selling products far below the cost of production, in order to drive foreign rivals out of business.

Some people argue that although China hasn't opened up its market to the same extent as Europe, the European consumer has still benefited from a stream of cheap imports. Holslag has little time for this argument, pointing to Europe's chronic trade deficit with China, which has resulted in Europe accumulating large levels of public and private debts. Indeed, some countries, such as Greece, are now so indebted to China that they are essentially becoming Chinese colonies. He also worries that as China climbs the development ladder, producing ever more sophisticated goods, Europe is reduced to selling raw materials and agricultural products.

It's a stark warning, especially since Holslag provides a lot of data to illustrate the unequal flow of goods and capital between Europe and the Asian superpower. Still, it's hard to avoid the impression that we've heard a lot of this before 30 years ago, for example, when everyone worried about the rise of Japan, only for it to experience a "lost decade". The same could easily happen again. Chinese growth is starting to slow, and cracks are appearing in its financial system.

The Silk Road Trap is a one-sided look at the problems with Chinese trade, which dismisses any benefits. And it's a pity Holslag didn't spend more time on China's "soft power" efforts to lobby European policymakers, and the increasingly sinister co-operation between Chinese state firms and the military. Still, the book provides a powerful counterpoint to the increasingly complacent attitudes of European (and British) policymakers to a country that combines authoritarian politics with a state-directed economic system.

Recommended

Holiday reading: five books to make sense of the 1970s – and the 2020s
Books

Holiday reading: five books to make sense of the 1970s – and the 2020s

With raging inflation, booms, busts and political crises, the 1970s has a reputation as a relentlessly awful decade. But things aren’t that simple, sa…
11 Jul 2022
Six of the most interesting books I read in 2021
Books

Six of the most interesting books I read in 2021

John Stepek picks six of his favourite books covering everything from blockchain to stockpicking, and the perils of doing business in Russia.
28 Dec 2021
Five books to make you think this Christmas
Books

Five books to make you think this Christmas

Merryn Somerset Webb picks five books on the theme of ownership for you to read over the festive period.
10 Dec 2021

Most Popular

Are UK house prices set to fall? It’s not so simple
House prices

Are UK house prices set to fall? It’s not so simple

Figures suggest UK house prices are starting to slide, but we shouldn’t take these numbers at face value, explains Rupert Hargreaves.
11 Aug 2022
Is gold cheap relative to equities?
Gold price

Is gold cheap relative to equities?

Dominic Frisby looks at the Dow-gold ratio and explains why gold is starting to appear inexpensive compared to equities.
12 Aug 2022
The energy price cap keeps rising - here is what you can do about it
Personal finance

The energy price cap keeps rising - here is what you can do about it

The energy price cap could hit £5,000 next year, even higher than expected, predicts energy consultancy Auxilione. Saloni Sardana explains what you ca…
12 Aug 2022