The big share buyback controversy

US politicians have share buybacks in their sights. They may be right to do so, says John Stepek – but not for the reason they think.


Share buybacks have always been controversial, but now they are rapidly turning into US public enemy number one. Last year, a record $1trn was earmarked by companies to buy their own stock, boosted by the $700bn or so that US companies brought back onshore after tax rates on repatriated profits were slashed. Politicians of all stripes have argued that this money should have been spent on boosting wages or investing in expansion. Republican senator Marco Rubio wants to change tax laws to make buybacks less appealing, while various Democrats have argued that buybacks are mainly aimed at boosting executive bonuses. So what's the fuss, and does it matter for investors?

The idea that executives use buybacks as an easy way to boost earnings per share (EPS) is a common objection. As far as 2018 goes, investment bank Goldman Sachs says this is unfair. The pay packets of bosses in around half of the companies in America's S&P 500 stock index are linked to EPS. Yet last year, these firms spent a smaller proportion of cash on buybacks than their peers, notes Goldman, and spent more on dividends. Now, no one will be amazed at Goldman defending executive pay, and other longer-term studies suggest that the complaints about executive pay do have weight.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Become a smarter, better informed investor with MoneyWeek.

However, the real issue for investors, says Richard Teitelbaum in Institutional Investor, is that companies are like most of us for all that they should be best-placed to understand the value of their firm, they are not very good at market timing. As Warren Buffett whose investment vehicle Berkshire Hathaway has strict criteria for buying back its own shares puts it: "Obviously, repurchases should be price sensitive. Blindly buying an overpriced stock is value-destructive, a fact lost on many promotional or ever-optimistic CEOs." Yet, as Teitelbaum points out, buybacks peaked in both 2000 and 2007 (significant market highs), and collapsed in 2009 which, of course, would have been the best time to hoover up as much stock as possible.

While we tend to prefer dividends (see below for why), there's no need to sell or avoid a company just because it engages in share buybacks. Indeed, it can be a positive sign Japanese companies, notoriously loath to return cash to shareholders, are starting to do so via buybacks, which bodes well for the future appeal of Japanese stocks, notes Richard Aston of the CC Japan Income & Growth Trust in What Investment. However, the clarity (or otherwise) of a buyback scheme can give you an idea of whether management is more concerned about getting shareholders value for money or boosting their own pay packets.




The British equity market is shrinking

British startups are abandoning public stockmarkets and turning to deep-pocketed Silicon Valley venture capitalists for their investment needs.
8 Nov 2019

There are lots of reasons to be bearish – but you should stick with the bulls

There are plenty of reasons to be gloomy about the stockmarkets. But the trend remains up, says Dominic Frisby. And you don’t want to bet against the …
17 Jul 2019

Good news on jobs scares US stockmarkets

June brought the best monthly US jobs growth of the year, but stockmarkets were not best pleased.
11 Jul 2019

Trade-war ceasefire boosts stockmarkets

Stockmarkets sighed with relief after the G20 summit in Japan brought a handshake between Donald Trump and Xi Jinping.
4 Jul 2019

Most Popular


Three things matter for the UK housing market now – and “location” isn’t one of them

The UK housing market is frozen. And when it does eventually thaw out, the traditional factors that drive prices will no longer apply. The day of reck…
1 Apr 2020

What does the coronavirus crisis mean for UK house prices?

With the whole country in lockdown, the UK property market is closed for business. John Stepek looks at what that means for UK house prices, housebuil…
27 Mar 2020

Oil shoots higher – have we seen the bottom for the big oil companies?

Just a few days ago everyone was worried about negative oil prices. Now, the market has turned upwards. John Stepek explains what’s behind the rise an…
3 Apr 2020
UK Economy

How the coronavirus pandemic is killing cash

Covid-19 is making a huge difference to the way we live, work and do business. One of its less obvious effects, says Merryn Somerset Webb, is to accel…
31 Mar 2020