Advertisement

What’s in your tracker funds?

A striking gap in the returns on Chinese index funds shows why you must be sure to know what you own. John Stepek explains.

937-Strat-634

A striking gap in the returns on Chinese index funds shows why you must be sure to know what you own.

China is set to become an even more significant force in global equity markets. By November, index provider MSCI will have increased the proportion of domestically listed Chinese stocks ("A-shares") in its emerging markets index from 0.71% to 3.3%, notes the Financial Times.

Advertisement - Article continues below

As a result, any funds that track the popular benchmark will have to buy more of the shares. Chinese stocks listed offshore in the US or Hong Kong already account for 31% of the index, so by the end of the year China's total weighting will be 34.3%. This is just one reason for this year's China market rally.

Yet for anyone considering investing in China, the latest Credit Suisse Global Investment Returns Yearbook (by professors Elroy Dimson, Paul Marsh and Dr Mike Staunton of the London Business School) has a useful warning know what you're buying. The researchers reviewed the performance of three key Chinese indices since 1993: FTSE China, MSCI China, and S&P China BMI.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

All three, notes the yearbook, aim to measure the performance of Chinese stocks available for investment by foreign investors. Yet the returns were dramatically different. Over the period, the MSCI China returned just 1.1% a year. Yet the FTSE China index managed 10.3%, and the S&P BMI 7.4%.

Advertisement - Article continues below

That's a staggering gap. There's no great mystery to it there are several differences in calculation and categorisation that can account for the gap. For example, until 2013 the FTSE China index did not include certain Hong Kong-listed shares, while the MSCI China index excluded US-listed Chinese shares until 2015.

However, as an investor, if you'd been looking for a "China tracker" during this period, then you would have probably struggled to forecast (or even understand) the effect that their differing methodologies would have on your returns and choosing the wrong one would have cost you dear. The lesson is clear, and it'sone we've repeated over andover again here you always need to understand what you are investing in.The number of indices out there is now vast.

If you just want to buy UK shares, for example, you can probably rely on a plain vanilla FTSE All-Share tracker. But if you want to invest in specific emerging markets, or a tracker with a more exotic set of valuation criteria, then you have to look under the bonnet. If you can't understand what a tracker fund holds and why, or how those holdings might change over time, consider another route to investing in the sector. And if you're looking at China specifically, you might want to compare any passive funds you are considering with active alternatives.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Recommended

Bullish investors return to emerging markets
Stockmarkets

Bullish investors return to emerging markets

The ink had barely dried on the US-China trade deal before the bulls began pouring into emerging markets.
27 Jan 2020
Beware the hidden risks when investing in emerging markets
Investment strategy

Beware the hidden risks when investing in emerging markets

Emerging markets look cheap compared with developed countries, but earnings may be less trustworthy.
23 Dec 2019
The British equity market is shrinking
Stockmarkets

The British equity market is shrinking

British startups are abandoning public stockmarkets and turning to deep-pocketed Silicon Valley venture capitalists for their investment needs.
8 Nov 2019
Emerging markets: buy when the news is bad
Emerging markets

Emerging markets: buy when the news is bad

Emerging markets are being squeezed by local turmoil and by more general factors. But bad news can spell opportunity for investors.
5 Nov 2019

Most Popular

Eagle Lightweight GT: the reincarnation of the E-type Jag
Toys and gadgets

Eagle Lightweight GT: the reincarnation of the E-type Jag

Jaguar’s classic E-type sports car has been reinvented for the modern age. The result – the Eagle Lightweight GT – is a thing of beauty.
7 Aug 2020
Should you take advantage of the UK’s new breed of domestic holidaymakers?
Buy to let

Should you take advantage of the UK’s new breed of domestic holidaymakers?

With Britons choosing to holiday in the UK this year, the owners of the country’s holiday cottages are cleaning up. Should you buy in, too? Merryn? So…
10 Aug 2020
The pound has been trending higher against the dollar – will it last?
Sponsored

The pound has been trending higher against the dollar – will it last?

Sterling has been rising against the dollar. Dominic Frisby sets his trend lines in the charts to see where the pound is heading next.
10 Aug 2020