Book of the week: Heroic Failure

Book review: Brexit and the Politics of Pain Irish writer Fintan O'Toole examines what Brexit reveals about Britain.

930-books-OToole_Heroic-Failure

Brexit and the Politics of Pain

Head of Zeus, £11.99

Buy on Amazon

There has been a flood of books on Brexit, but most have focused on what Brexit means for Britain's future. Heroic Failure takes a different path by focusing on whatBrexit reveals about Britain. The book is also notable in that its author is an Irish journalist, not a domestic politician or pundit. O'Toole argues our Brexit woes are not really much to do with the European Union, but rather a symptom of the desires and neuroses within our national character, as well as a howl of rage at the political establishment.

The Leave campaign's success was a result of its tapping into our long-standing insularity combined with national paranoia about foreign occupation, says O'Toole. That we are so obsessed is shown by the success of books and television series set in a Nazi-run Britain, he argues.

This leads him to wonder whether many Brexiters oppose Europe just so they can live out a long-held fantasy of beingpart of an underground resistance. The perceived loss of national and regional identities within the UK itself also played a part. Polls show those who identified as "English" mostly voted to leave, while those considering themselves "British" voted to stay.

The Remain campaign's emphasis on the economic costs of leaving the EU, on the other hand, overlooked the fact that the British have always secretly preferred heroic failure to success, as shown by our fascination with the Charge of the Light Brigade and Scott of the Antarctic. Sarah Vine's joke to her husband Michael Gove, that "you were only supposed to blow the bloody doors off", was particularly telling. The Italian Job (the source of Vine's quote) deals with a British attempt to raid Europe that ends on a literal cliffhanger that is impossible for the characters to resolve satisfactorily.

O'Toole makes some interesting points, but his argument ends up descending into caricature. Although Britain spurned the opportunity to become a founder member of the European Community, for example, it still spent a huge amount of money keeping western Europe safe from the threat of Russian invasion throughout the Cold War. And while the citizens of the remaining 27 countries don't want to leave the EU, they

are generally opposed to any further integration (which is why Britain's exit is also a tragedy for them).

Still, it's always refreshing to get an outsider's take on political events. The book provides an original perspective on a topic that has dominated British politics for the past couple of years, and looks set to continue do so for some time yet. It is also an entertaining read that will at times have you laughing out loud.

Recommended

The MoneyWeek Podcast: lorry drivers, Brexit, and why now is a good time to buy UK stocks
Investment strategy

The MoneyWeek Podcast: lorry drivers, Brexit, and why now is a good time to buy UK stocks

The UK is facing shortages of everything from chicken to microchips. Is Brexit really to blame? Merryn and John discuss the boom-bust nature of the ha…
27 Aug 2021
Disasters, bunkers and financial collapse: a little not-so-light holiday reading
Books

Disasters, bunkers and financial collapse: a little not-so-light holiday reading

Merryn Somerset Webb picks a selection of books for you to dive into wherever you are holidaying this summer.
3 Aug 2021
LSE Group fights to stem the tide as share trading moves abroad
UK stockmarkets

LSE Group fights to stem the tide as share trading moves abroad

Some of the City’s share-trading business has moved to the EU and the US. But all is not lost for the London Stock Exchange.
18 Feb 2021
Brexit: a bumpy beginning for small businesses exporting to the EU
Small business

Brexit: a bumpy beginning for small businesses exporting to the EU

Small businesses trading with the EU have struggled since the Uk officially left the EU at the turn of the year. David Prosser outlines the key proble…
12 Feb 2021

Most Popular

Should investors be worried about stagflation?
US Economy

Should investors be worried about stagflation?

The latest US employment data has raised the ugly spectre of “stagflation” – weak growth and high inflation. John Stepek looks at what’s going on and …
6 Sep 2021
Two shipping funds to buy for steady income
Investment trusts

Two shipping funds to buy for steady income

Returns from owning ships are volatile, but these two investment trusts are trying to make the sector less risky.
7 Sep 2021
How you can profit from the power of the grey pound
Share tips

How you can profit from the power of the grey pound

Higher life expectancy and surging asset prices have proved a boon for the baby-boomer generation, which has accumulated vast wealth. Younger generati…
10 Sep 2021