Low volatility – or low rates?

Tracker funds investing in “boring” stocks have done well in the past 25 years – but is that set to change?

921_MW_P16_strategy

Utility companies feature prominently in low-vol portfolios

One big winner from the post-financial crisis environment has been "low volatility" ("low-vol") exchange-traded funds (ETFs). The idea behind these ETFs (part of a range of "smart beta" ETFs that invest in indices with specific themes or theories backing them) is that they are full of equities that are less volatile (ie they suffer fewer ups and downs) than the wider stock market. As a result, they should give investors a smoother ride overall the highs might not be as high, but nor will the lows be as severe and as frightening. And so far it seems they have largely done their job.

But can this continue? There's an interesting piece on the CFA Institute's Enterprising Investor blog by Nicolas Rabener of FactorResearch on the topic. Rabener notes that low-vol ETFs have done very well in recent decades. In fact, rather than deliver a smooth but unexciting path through the market, they have in fact beaten it on many occasions. If you had bought the least-volatile 10% of US stocks in 1991 (and carried on rebalancing into the least volatile tenth on a monthly basis), then you'd have thrashed the market. Rabener also found that, looking at Japanese and European markets, your maximum drawdown (in other words, the biggest hit your portfolio would have had) was significantly smaller than the equivalent for the wider markets. So not only did the low-vol portfolios beat the market, they also saved investors a lot of nailbiting in the process.

There's just one problem. The sectors that dominate in low-vol portfolios accounting for more than half of the value of the stocks in these indices during the period under examination are property and utility companies. Why is that important? Utility and property companies appeal to investors for one main reason they tend to offer higher yields than most other sectors. A world of ultra-low and falling interest rates (which is the environment we'd seen right up until at least mid-2016), made these investments extra attractive to yield-hungry investors.

However, it also means that these stocks are unusually sensitive to movements in interest rates and in both directions. If rates start to rise again as we're seeing now then these sectors are likely to suffer (just as bond prices fall when yields rise, so the price of "bond proxies", such as these stocks, tend to fall as interest rates rise). After all, why invest in commercial property if a Treasury bond yields just as much? So if, as Rabener puts it, "declining interest rates likely explain most of the low-volatility strategy's attractive risk-adjusted returns" then the end of the long bond bull market could spell the end of that. Indeed, "if interest rates rise, then low volatility ETFs could become toxic."

Recommended

Why ESG investing is becoming the norm
ESG investing

Why ESG investing is becoming the norm

A lot of investors say they want to put their money into “ESG” funds. But unless you actively opt for a “sin” fund jammed full of companies behaving b…
10 May 2021
Troy's Gabrielle Boyle: for global companies, sustainability is just good business
Investment strategy

Troy's Gabrielle Boyle: for global companies, sustainability is just good business

Merryn talks to to Gabrielle Boyle of Troy Asset Management about the top quality global companies in her portfolio, and why those firms that invest i…
7 May 2021
Things are looking up for income investors as dividend payouts start to rise
Income investing

Things are looking up for income investors as dividend payouts start to rise

UK dividend payouts are ready to grow again, but this crisis has shown why income investors must diversify overseas.
3 May 2021
Micro-cap stocks: how to get huge returns from tiny firms
Small cap stocks

Micro-cap stocks: how to get huge returns from tiny firms

Micro-cap stocks are often overlooked, but the British market has plenty of them and their potential is massive. Max King picks the best two investmen…
3 May 2021

Most Popular

Could you end up paying inheritance tax on your family home?
Inheritance tax

Could you end up paying inheritance tax on your family home?

The value of the average UK home has risen by 53% since April 2009, but the inheritance tax threshold has remained static. And that means more people …
7 May 2021
Big Tech on steroids: why the 2020s will be the “decade of the DAO”
Bitcoin & crypto

Big Tech on steroids: why the 2020s will be the “decade of the DAO”

Big tech companies have transformed the way we live our lives. But if you thought they were disruptive, you haven’t seen anything yet. As Dominic Fris…
6 May 2021
Why woeful US jobs data might spell higher inflation in the near future
US Economy

Why woeful US jobs data might spell higher inflation in the near future

The latest US employment figures were much worse than expected. And that matters not just for the US economy, but for global markets too – and for inf…
10 May 2021