Advertisement
Features

Adam Smith and the crony capitalist conspiracy

The concentration of market power in the hands of a few big companies worried Adam Smith. It should worry us too, says Merryn Somerset Webb. But it is fixable.

180828-google
Google had 120 lobby meetings with EU officials between 2014 and 2016

Former Greek finance minister Yanis Varoufakis and Jeremy Corbyn had a public conversation this week at the Edinburgh Book Festival. Varoufakis was good engaging enough to deserve his growing reputation as the thinking capitalist's favourite socialist. He is clearly rather a fan of Adam Smith.

An audience who had read either of Smith's blockbusters, The Theory of Moral Sentiments (published in 1759) or The Wealth of Nations (1776), would have caught several references. But the most obvious similarities came in Varoufakis's irritation with the rise of corporate power, oligopoly and monopoly something Smith was constantly concerned about.

Advertisement - Article continues below

One of Smith's best known quotes is on this very matter: "People of the same trade seldom meet together, even for merriment and diversion," he wrote, "but the conversation ends in a conspiracy against the public, or in some contrivance to raise prices." The fewer players in an industry, the more powerful those players are and the more they hang around together, the easier it is for the "conspiracy" to kick off and for the ordinary person to be disadvantaged.

Big companies are getting more powerful

The evidence rested on tracking average mark-ups on goods and services provided by listed companies in 74 countries (this is the extent to which a company can bump up its prices relative to its costs, and is an obvious and simple measure of its power in the market).

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

The results, says the IMF, show a few worrying things. First, that mark-ups in advanced economies have significantly increased since the 1980s (by 43% on average); that this trend has accelerated in the past ten years; and that the increase is mostly driven by the "superstar" companies in each sector.

Advertisement - Article continues below

This matters partly because overly concentrated market power is connected with falling investment and innovation, and partly because it is possible that market concentration is one of the things holding down wages in the West. The IMF says that "the labour share of income declines in industries where market power rises".

However, it mostly matters because it appears to represent an obvious failure of capitalism. In a perfect environment with no barriers to entry in the form of regulation, access to capital and industry associations superstar companies would not be around for long: many start-ups would compete their advantage away, wealth would again be spread about a bit and that would be that.

This is not happening perhaps because of regulation or the endless and expensive lobbying habits of big business. According to lobbyfacts.eu, Google, for example, had 120 lobby meetings with a commissioner, cabinet member or director-general of the EU between 2014 and 2016. The networking effect of new technology plays its part.

Advertisement - Article continues below

In the US, the rate of new company formation is well below where it was before the financial crisis. At the same time, the big are getting bigger. The result is a depressing perception that capitalism is doing exactly what Karl Marx said it would: it is pushing wealth towards the few, something that is surely one of the main drivers of the sentiment shift towards socialism in the UK and in the US. Polls show that about half of US millennials think they would prefer to live in a socialist society than a capitalist one.

Politicians are waking up to the threat

Smith would not have wanted corporate merriment tackled in any way not consistent with "liberty or justice". But given that most people at the moment whether they identify as capitalist or socialist appear to agree that they are anti-oligopoly and pro a fair share for labour, it must be time to reimagine industrial policy. The aim should be not to "pick winners" but to root out the wrong kind of winner.

There may be no particular need to worry about dominant technology companies in the immediate future, for example, given that, data concerns and tax arguments aside, their products do great things for consumers. But a dedicated "crony capitalism" tsar might find that there is an argument for legislation to break up accounting firms by banning them from doing both audit and corporate finance work and perhaps one for limiting corporate lobbying.

Either way, the fact that both the friends and the foes of capitalism are looking at the same entirely solvable problems is surely progress.

This article was first published in the Financial Times.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Recommended

How long can the good times roll?
Economy

How long can the good times roll?

Despite all the doom and gloom that has dominated our headlines for most of 2019, Britain and most of the rest of the developing world is currently en…
19 Dec 2019
The British equity market is shrinking
Stockmarkets

The British equity market is shrinking

British startups are abandoning public stockmarkets and turning to deep-pocketed Silicon Valley venture capitalists for their investment needs.
8 Nov 2019
Beyond the Brexit talk, the British economy isn’t doing too badly
Economy

Beyond the Brexit talk, the British economy isn’t doing too badly

The political Brexit pantomime aside, Britain is in pretty good shape. With near-record employment, strong wage growth and modest inflation, there is …
17 Oct 2019
UK house prices hit a new record high – can it last?
House prices

UK house prices hit a new record high – can it last?

Despite the pandemic, UK house prices have hit a new high. John Stepek looks at what’s driving the surge in prices, and what it means for house prices…
7 Aug 2020

Most Popular

Don’t despair on dividends – these companies could be set to bring them back
Income investing

Don’t despair on dividends – these companies could be set to bring them back

The value of dividends paid out by UK stocks has plummeted this year as companies “rebase” their payment policies. But things could soon start to look…
6 Aug 2020
Platinum: the precious metal that looks set to play catch-up with silver and gold
Silver and other precious metals

Platinum: the precious metal that looks set to play catch-up with silver and gold

Gold and silver continue to soar, but there's still time to get in. And there's another precious metal that looks set to go on a bull run too, says Jo…
7 Aug 2020
The MoneyWeek Podcast: how to age well and profit from the “longevity dividend”
Investment strategy

The MoneyWeek Podcast: how to age well and profit from the “longevity dividend”

Merryn talks to economist and author Andrew J Scott and discusses how we can profit from the "longevity dividend" as we live longer; why we need to re…
6 Aug 2020