Why open banking could be a boon for fraudsters

Open banking has arrived and with it a slew of apps aiming to help you to use these new rules to improve your budgeting habits. Just watch out for crooks.


Banks might duck the blame if you're hacked
(Image credit: This content is subject to copyright.)

Last weekend, new regulations came into force that could dramatically change the way you bank. "Open banking" has arrived and, with it, a slew of apps aiming to help you to use these new rules to improve your budgeting habits.

From now on, banks have to share financial data such as your transaction history and spending patterns with third parties, if you ask them to. "That might sound like baffling small print, but it could genuinely shake up the way in which you manage your money," as Felicity Hannah says in The Independent.

How much can you save?

In practice, this means you could give a third party access to your current-account data, and they could either analyse your spending habits and work out exactly how much you can afford to save each month and move that amount into a savings account automatically or assess how often you go into the red and then recommend a current account that better suits your needs, perhaps one with lower overdraft charges.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE

Get 6 issues free

Sign up to Money Morning

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Sign up

The benefit to the companies involved is that they will use this access to try to sell you their products. Open banking could also allow you to keep track of all your money, across different accounts, via one website. But open banking isn't just about sharing your financial data with start-ups. It should also encourage more of us to switch bank accounts, suggests The Daily Telegraph, as you can now share your financial data with your new bank "in minutes".

Someone will have to pay

But it isn't all good news. There are concerns that the new rules could lead to more of us being scammed, with criminals setting up dodgy apps and websites asking for your banking details under the umbrella of open banking.

"I might sound like a Luddite, but I'm worried that letting an app access my data might leave me vulnerable to fraud," says Patrick Collinson in The Guardian. "It's not absolutely clear who is going to cough up when something goes wrong, which, inevitably, it will at some point."

Before open banking, if criminals hacked into your bank account the blame fell on your bank, unless you had been handing out your account details willy-nilly (highly unlikely). As a result, your bank would have to compensate you. But now you could be giving out all your account details to a fintech firm that happens to have developed an app.

"Given that tech companies with vast IT departments, such as Experian, have been successfully hacked, we can assume one of these fintechs will be hacked too," says Collinson. But as you gave that fintech access to your accounts, your bank will "quite reasonably blame the third party". And it's fair to question whether a small start-up tech firm would be able to cover these potential losses.

A tech firm has to be regulated to use open banking, and many are taking out insurance policies to cover themselves in case of a data breach. But most of us remain concerned, according to a survey by Accenture, with two-thirds of those questioned saying they would not share their financial data with a third party.

However, even if you are keen to embrace this new era of banking and budget automation, you may have to wait a while. HSBC, Nationwide, Barclays, RBS, Santander and Bank of Ireland have all requested, and received, an extension to the deadline to comply with open banking. Their customers will now have to wait for weeks or even months before they can start sharing their financial data.

Pocket money how to escape the January blues

Employees are missing out on a "valuable tax perk", according to Ruth Emery in The Sunday Times. Pension advice vouchers are a government initiative similar to childcare vouchers, "but they have gone largely unnoticed", with few companies offering the benefit to workers.

Under the salary-sacrifice scheme, staff can swap up to £500 of their pay each tax year for a pension advice voucher. The voucher can then be used to get financial advice about any sort of pension scheme they have. Depending on the employee's wages, the voucher can cost them as little as £190, thanks to the tax and national insurance saved.

Last Monday was dubbed "Blue Monday" the most depressing day of the year, thanks to the arrival of festive credit-card bills, the failure of New Year's resolutions and the long drag until payday. To cheer us all up, the Financial Times ran a series of money-saving travel tips.

The number-one tip is to "regularly clear the cookies' from your web browser, as this will prevent the site from remembering the holidays, flights and hotel bookings you have previously browsed and often automatically raising the price of those you've looked at before", says Claer Barrett. If you need car hire, book it as far in advance as possible. Also, "make sure the car is big enough it will only cost a few quid more to get a bigger car when booking, but it can be hundreds if you have to upgrade at the check-in desk", suggests the FT.

Watch out for dodgy "trust" schemes that say they can help you to avoid care-home fees, warns Sam Brodbeck in The Daily Telegraph. Average nursing-care fees exceeded £1,000 a week for the first time last year. Combine that with more and more families hoping to avoid inheritance tax (IHT) and you have fertile ground for a dodgy investment scheme.

If you put your house into a trust to try and avoid care-home fees you could be committing fraud, leaving you still having to pay the fees but potentially also facing criminal charges. The new IHT allowance for family homes also means that many people who are contemplating trying to shield their house in some way actually have little chance of ever having to pay IHT.

Ruth Jackson-Kirby

Ruth Jackson-Kirby is a freelance personal finance journalist with 17 years’ experience, writing about everything from savings and credit cards to pensions, property and pet insurance. 

Ruth started her career at MoneyWeek after graduating with an MA from the University of St Andrews, and she continues to contribute regular articles to our personal finance section. After leaving MoneyWeek she went on to become deputy editor of Moneywise before becoming a freelance journalist.

Ruth writes regularly for national publications including The Sunday Times, The Times, The Mail on Sunday and Good Housekeeping among many other titles both online and offline.