Does China’s credit rating cut matter?

Moody’s decision to downgrade China’s credit rating is no surprise, and many believe it will have no real impact.

"There's nothing so surprising about Moody's decision to downgrade China's sovereign debt one notch to A1," says Andy Mukherjee on Bloomberg Gadfly. Since March 2016, when Moody's and its rival Standard & Poor's (S&P) cut their outlook for China, "an eventual demotion has been the most likely outcome". (S&P continues to rate China one notch higher, while Fitch, the third main ratings agency, already ranks it at its equivalent of A1.) "Still, it mustn't have been an easy decision, considering the tongue-lashing they got from the Chinese finance minister at last year's Group of 20 meeting over the bias' in their assessment."

The downgrade reflects Moody's view that recent reforms will not be enough to slow the pace at which debt is rising in the Chinese economy, the agency's Marie Diron tells Reuters. China's non-financial debt-to-GDP including corporate, government and household debt now stands close to 300% of GDP, with corporate debt accounting for more than half of this. The key force behind this runaway credit growth has been government-led stimulus to boost growth in recent years. Since policymakers remain keen to achieve economic growth targets, any efforts to cut debt levels have been relatively cautious, ahead of a political leadership shuffle set for later this year.

Many critics believe the downgrade will have no real impact. "One of the credit rating agencies no one cares which one lowered China's credit rating from something to something else no one cares what," says Paul Donovan of UBS, quoted on One reason is that foreign investors play a minimal role in Chinese debt markets, says Lisa Jucca on Breakingviews. The share of Chinese debt held by foreigners is below 3%, in contrast with the 20%-30% seen in most emerging markets. Domestic investors "tend to buy and hold, and are not to be rattled by such global appraisals". Hence "there won't be the traditional ripple effect on existing investments" that a downgrade can cause.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE

Get 6 issues free

Sign up to Money Morning

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Sign up

Still, "the needle on the doubtometer" seems to have risen, says Douglas Bulloch in Forbes. China appears unable to explain when debt growth will again be exceeded by GDP growth (something that hasn't happened since 2009). Until that's resolved, the downgrade will act as an "international warning" on China at an awkward time. The authorities are seeking to have mainland-listed shares included in international stockmarket indices and to open up the domestic bond market to more foreign investors. As those investors start to play a bigger role, China's "days of being able to ignore the policy criticism of international ratings agencies look numbered", concludes Jucca.

James McAdam Stacey

James has previously written about financial markets for MoneyWeek. He has a bacherlors degree in management and he has been awarded an investment advice diploma by The Chartered Institute for Securities & Investment (The CISI). James then worked at Moran Stanley as a U.S. Equity Sales Analyst for two years, then moved into hedge fund sales and investor relations at 36 South Capital Advisors, and then became the Global Multi-Asset Sales at Credit Suisse. Now, James is the Associate Director of US Equity Sales at Oppenheimer & Co. Inc, where he is responsible for servicing a range of clients including asset managers, hedge funds and wealth managers.