I’m not wildly excited about gold in 2017 – but I just can’t be bearish

So today we turn our attention to the alluring, the lustrous, the irresistible metal that is gold.

What next?

Up? Down? Sideways?

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE

Get 6 issues free

Sign up to Money Morning

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Sign up

What really matters for gold and everything else this year

I'll explain first why I'm not wildly bullish using just one word: sterling.

2016 was the year to own gold. It began the year around £720 an ounce, and ended it around £940 a 30% gain. Gold had an OK year anyway up around 8% in US dollars but it was a bonanza year for UK investors for the simple reason that sterling was so weak.

I'm of the view that sterling has some upside now and sterling strength if we see it limits gold's potential upside. Of course, if you're a sterling bear, then back up the truck and load it up with gold (and don't tell anyone where you're taking it).

However, the really big question and this is not just the elephant in the investment room, but the dinosaur is where does the US dollar go from here?

It's easy to find both bullish and bearish arguments.

Dollar bears can argue: "President Trump wants the dollar to go lower. He needs it to go lower to allow for his plans to spend more and tax less. So he and his team will engineer it lower."

Dollar bulls can reply: "Everyone is trying to engineer their currency lower. America is great. America is strong. The US dollar goes higher."

The trend since May 2016 has been up. But the trend this year has been down. Take your pick.

Whatever your view, the dollar is key. From the US dollar, we learn whether next we see inflation raising its head again a real possibility or whether the deflationary forces at play continue to win out.

Dollar strength will impact global trade and capital flows. There's a relationship between a strong dollar and interest rates.

All of the above will affectthe price of gold.

For now I'm inclined to favour the current, short-term trend in gold which is up. $1,240 is possible, maybe even $1,310. But it wouldn't surprise me if 2017 turned out to be year of range trading, rather than a full-blown bull or bear market.

Below is a one-year chart for your reference.

But if the pound strengthens too, gold's gains in sterling won't be so pronounced.

Why I find it hard to be bearish on gold

There were the loose monetary policies and easy credit of the Brown-Blair years and the house-price boom. There was the gap between the actions of elected leaders and what ordinary people actually wanted; between the riches of the super-rich versus normal people.

Frustration grew with perceived inequality income inequality, wealth inequality, inequality of opportunity. The credit bust of 2008 and the subsequent policy reaction only made matters worse. A very real belief has emerged that the playing field is not level.

That nobody can agree on the answer is exacerbating the division. For some, capitalism is the problem; for others, it is the solution. For some, the state is the problem; for others, it is the solution.

In 2016 the feeling was that the saucepan is boiling over. First there was Brexit; then there was Trump. While joyous for some, the reaction of the losing side has not been to stoically accept the result. It has been to fight by every means possible whether to march, to debate, to protest, to undermine via legal barrier or bureaucratic process, in some cases even to resort to violence.

My questions to you are: was Brexit the end of it, or is this civil division and unrest going to grow? Will the American left resignedly accept Trump now, or will they continue to try and bring him down? If they do bring him down let's say they find a way of impeaching him then how will his supporters react? If Brexit is somehow blocked (it doesn't look likely, but you never know), then what will be the reaction of the 52%?

In short, across the developed world, is civil tension, unrest and division going to bubble over, or is it going to simmer down in the coming years?

I can envisage both scenarios. I can see a resigned acceptance to both Brexit and Trump. But I can also see a growing anger. Perhaps, say, Brexit is not managed properly. Or Trump is found out by some monster gaffe. Perhaps there is some fall-out from the French and German votes later this year.

The biggest bone of economic contention in the UK

Yet there is a shortage of affordable housing in areas where people want to live. Others meanwhile have been handed a fortune on a plate without having done anything to earn it.

One solution is much lower prices. But homeowners won't want that, and the deflationary consequences of a housing bust, whether needed or not, would be a problem, to say the least.

The second solution is dramatically higher earnings AKA inflation, which also has problematic consequences. The third solution (and it's not really worthy of the name) is the current stand-off, which just means more frustration and unrest.

There is every chance that this narrative of civil discontent, division and unrest continues to fester and worsen in the coming years, even if there are no big, catalytic votes coming up in the US and UK. That's why I'm not particularly bearish about gold.