Why a good government needs a good opposition

The result of the Scottish election might be a foregone conclusion. But the real fight is for second place, says Merryn Somerset Webb. Governments need effective oppositions.


I went to the pub to interview Scottish Tory leader Ruth Davidson this week. That's just the way we do things in Scotland. The other thing we do in Scotland is not talk much about next week's Scottish election. We are a bit politicked out after the referendum; and, of course, we already know who is going to win. No suspense there.

However, those who are concentrating will know that this is a more exciting election than it looks: the real fight is for second place for the right to be the official opposition. Labour have had the role for nine years and have proven themselves utterly useless in it (despite trying out six different leaders). Davidson is campaigning to get a shot at proving she can do a better job.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Become a smarter, better informed investor with MoneyWeek.

Take the Named Persons Scheme a nonsensical business that will appoint a state employee of some kind as an effective state guardian for every child in Scotland. It's intrusive and administratively nightmarish. A good opposition would have sent it back to the drawing board. Labour did not.

The result is that this is the first policy to make SNP voters think the SNP isn't all that. The next, as voters begin to feel the consequences of it, will be the silliness of making Scotland the highest taxed part of the UK (Scottish taxpayers won't be seeing the raise in the higher rate tax threshold the rest of the UK will be seeing).

Advertisement - Article continues below

Davidson reckons that businesses are already "worried that they are going to have different payrolls for employees in different parts of the UK" and that they will have trouble persuading people worried about tax rates moving north to take up jobs to move north.

This is a perfectly reasonable worry. Both Davidson and I can come up with anecdotes to suggest it is happening already (as can most business people in Scotland). And as for those here already, all too many say that if asked now they wouldn't come.

Good governments (and democracies) need good oppositions.

Back to Davidson and the real point of this election. She's not asking people to vote for her so that she gets to implement Conservative policies. That won't happen. Instead, she wants to make a transactional deal with the electorate: she wants to "do a very specific job to hold the SNP to account". That means "saying no to a second independence referendum" and pushing for the SNP to do what we "actually pay them to do" run the country efficiently and effectively.

Look at it like that and you'd think that if Nicola Sturgeon had any sense she'd be giving Davidson one of her votes (you get two up here) if she could be forced to run the country well she might get to run it for longer. But on the assumption she isn't going to vote Tory (Davidson thinks it unlikely but would, she says, "be delighted" with any and all SNP support), any of our Scottish readers might like to redress the balance by giving Davidson both of theirs. I'm going to.




How long can the good times roll?

Despite all the doom and gloom that has dominated our headlines for most of 2019, Britain and most of the rest of the developing world is currently en…
19 Dec 2019

Beyond the Brexit talk, the British economy isn’t doing too badly

The political Brexit pantomime aside, Britain is in pretty good shape. With near-record employment, strong wage growth and modest inflation, there is …
17 Oct 2019
Investment strategy

The MoneyWeek Podcast - Your questions answered

Merryn and John tackle some of the questions sent in by readers - including what they expect to happen to house prices; how much are dividends likely …
30 Mar 2020
UK Economy

It’s not all doom and gloom

In some ways at least, there’s never been a better time to launch a start-up, says Matthew Lynn. The government should help.
29 Mar 2020

Most Popular


What does the coronavirus crisis mean for UK house prices?

With the whole country in lockdown, the UK property market is closed for business. John Stepek looks at what that means for UK house prices, housebuil…
27 Mar 2020
UK Economy

The UK’s bailout of the self employed comes with a hidden catch

The chancellor’s £6.5bn bailout of the self employed is welcome. But it has hidden benefits for the taxman, says Merryn Somerset Webb.
27 Mar 2020

Coronavirus: what it means for your mortgage or your rent

Ruth Jackson-Kirby looks at all the key questions for owners, renters and landlords affected by the coronavirus crisis.
29 Mar 2020
UK Economy

Debt jubilee: will our debts be written off?

The idea of a "debt jubilee" – general society-wide cancellation of debt – goes back to Biblical times. Could it happen again? And would it really do …
28 Mar 2020