The arch-architect of the eurozone, former German chancellor Helmut Kohl, once said that he'd been forced to act "like a dictator" to push through European unification. Despite what the public wanted (or thought they wanted), Kohl and other like-minded politicians bulldozed through what they thought was best for millions of people.
And looking at Greece's ultimate showdown with the European Union (EU) machine, things hardly seem to have changed at all. Greek citizens voted to ignore euro-imposed austerity and yet, despite objections, Greek prime minister Alexis Tsipras returned to Athens this week with a deal that was arguably even worse than the one the public emphatically threw out.
Even the International Monetary Fund (IMF) agrees that Greece needs debt relief 30 years of it, at that. But what Tsipras returned with was little relief, and more austerity.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
So what is it that bends strong-headed politicians like Tsipras and makes them yield to the meisters of centralist institutions like the EU?
And this isn't just a Euro-politician' issue. Let's not forget that the only reason that the UK has won a referendum on Europe, was ultimately due to public support for an outsider party, Ukip. There's no way any of the mainstream parties wanted to hear what the public had to say on the issue of ever more centralised power in Brussels.
To put it bluntly, politicians of every hue have an uncanny habit of "going dictator" on us. Why? I don't have the answer, but here are three of the most plausible motivations I can think of let me know your own views in the comments section (keep it civil).
Retirement planning
Of course, not everyone fancies leading Europe. For others there are lucrative positions in banks and investment groups at the heart of a centralised system. Indeed, Blair found his way into many a lucrative hotseat.
As I read company reports, it's hard to ignore the number of board seats taken by former politicians. The fact is, many multinationals, let alone the banks, love the centralised approach to government and they'll promote any politician that feels the same way. For the banks, belonging to a large central power means they're underwritten by a nice big entity. Thank heavens for RBS it was part of the UK. And for any multinational, the reams of regulation offered by centralist institutions like the EU create barriers to entry for any upstart rivals.
Interestingly, over recent years, we've even seen a revolving door develop, whereby former City bigwigs have taken up political positions too. But let's not get too conspiratorial.
A higher purpose (also known as egomania)?
In order to achieve the individual's significant goal', co-operation is required. They call it diplomacy. And they put in place an army of stooges and diplomats to make it happen. If they can achieve a significant goal, they're on the way to a meaningful epitaph and of course, some bragging rights along the way. That's not to mention the book deal, or the odd (and extremely lucrative) after-dinner speech.
So do these moralistic, or even hubristic goals really just come down to money, once again?
Maybe there's more...
You can't handle the truth!
A Few Good Men
I suspect that once in power, many politicians begin to err towards Jessup's way of thinking that the important decisions involved in running a country can't be left to the whim of the public. In fact, I suspect that many a man on the street believes this too; thus deferring important decisions to the political elite. As such, politicians on all sides tend to coalesce. The ideas are no longer as varied and thoughtful as those of the average public.
Tsipras was undoubtedly told some home truths once he'd taken his country to the brink of euro ejection. Remember, he had been an outsider. He was voted in off the back of views that chimed with the public. His (now ex-)finance minister, Varoufakis hadn't ever had any political bent, but came in to save Greece'.
But Tsipras has suddenly yielded to the centre. What on earth did they tell him?
Of course, this type of indoctrination stretches further than economic stratagems. There's a notion that the public doesn't understand, and can't be trusted to back the right' decisions.
This is, of course, the same sort of thinking that leads to any sort of dictatorial state, from either side of the political spectrum. And it also tends to ignore the fact that history shows that centralisation tends to deliver awful outcomes.
Have we thus ended up with a charade of democracy, where the central policy unit plans direction? Sounds conspiratorial, I know. But it's hard to fathom why it is that the public's voice is always subjugated to the point that it's only offered a say in extremis. And even then, any referendum a la grec', can be ignored!
It'll be interesting to see what happens to the youthful and ever charismatic Tsipras as his career progresses. He might have made enemies, but I suspect he's found some powerful allies within the central machine too. He must at the very least get a book out of it!
-
Paying the grandkids’ school fees could generate a shock IHT billPrivate school fees have soared as a result of the government’s VAT policy, meaning more grandparents are helping out – but what are the tax implications?
-
Number of savings deals hits record high – as interest rates slump to two-year lowSavers have more choice than ever when it comes to choosing a savings account or cash ISA. But, the interest rates on offer continue to fall. What’s next for the savings market?
-
Britain’s inflation problemInflation in the UK appears to be remaining higher for longer when compared with similar rich countries. Why? And when can we expect a return to normal? Simon Wilson reports.
-
Will the sanctions aimed at Putin have any effect?Briefings Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has changed the West’s strategic calculus and tougher than expected sanctions have followed. Will they be enough to change the course of events?
-
Why the City should create a single financial market with the SwissOpinion A tie-up between London and Zurich, two global financial centres, could pay huge dividends for both, says Matthew Lynn.
-
EU throws green spanner in the works of global tradeFeatures Europe has big plans for the environment – but making them work without damaging world trade will be a challenge.
-
Which countries sell citizenship and how much it costsFeatures Fancy living in a European capital, or gaining citizenship of a Caribbean island? If you have deep enough pockets, the world is your oyster, says Alex Rankine.
-
How Brexit will save the United KingdomFeatures Leaving the EU should strengthen the United Kingdom – a multinational union Europe can only aspire to. Alex Carew, a London-based fund manager and economic historian, explains how.
-
Farage victory would tip the balanceFeatures A Brexit Party win may concentrate minds in parliament and break the stalemate. Emily Hohler reports.
-
Labour defeats a Remainer rebellionFeatures Jeremy Corbyn has faced down a challenge spearheaded by his deputy, Tom Watson, for Labour to signal its backing for a second Brexit referendum.
