Features

George Osborne is right – the national debt is a moral issue

George Osborne's decree that the nation's budget should balance makes perfect sense, says Bengt Saelensminde. Here's why it matters.

150611-george-osborne

Osborne's idea on the national debt is just common sense

Margaret Thatcher once likened a nation's accounts to a housewife's budget. That is, don't spend what you haven't got.

Andlast night, the chancellor, George Osborne, made a similar decree. At his Mansion House address to the great and the good of the City, Osborne suggested a pact that British governments will no longer spend more than they take in tax.

Rather than allowing the government of the day latitude to spend whatever it likes, the new regime will demand a balanced budget. If not balanced, then future governments will have to say why.

Now, chancellors of yore have made similar pledges, be it "spend within our means", or "prudent, balanced budgets, within the business cycle". So what's new?

Well, this might look like a finely tuned bit of political theatre, putting the Labour party in a tricky position whether they vote yea or nay. But in reality, this is just common sense and harks back to the way things always used to be. And there's a good reason for that...

Watch out for the skinny cows

As such, the plan now is to consolidate the government's economic success and further embarrass the Labour party either by a) voting with government to enshrine the new doctrine (upsetting the far left); or b) by voting against the move, thereby highlighting once again that the opposition really isn't very good with numbers.

But the fact is, a balanced budget has historically been the norm anyway. Those who talk about Keynesian' economics (spending to stimulate the economy) often forget that what Keynes actually said was that the government should run budget surpluses during the good times, thereby holding back some firepower to spur growth during recession.

And Keynes' idea certainly wasn't without historic precedent. Think of the Bible story of Pharaoh's dream of seven fat calves and then seven skinny ones, and you'll see that the idea of a managing an economy based on saving be it grain, or money is as old as the hills. This is not rocket science.

Historically, governments really only pumped up the debt during times of war. To ward off nasty invaders, national debt was seen as the lesser of two evils.

Exactly who owns the debt, and does it matter?

But in today's climate, you could be forgiven for thinking that debt doesn't matter. Many political/economic commentators say that if we are lending to ourselves, in a manner whereby gilts (government debt) are bought by pensioners, for instance, then it really doesn't matter. We owe the money to ourselves!

To take it one step further, if the Bank of England buys said debt through QE wizardry, then the debt can be magicked away anyway.

Oh, if only it were that simple. Let me outline why debt matters, and why Osborne is right to get things back on track.

Laziness never helped anybody

But let's not go there just now. The real issue is that debt is a way of offsetting tax for a later date. That's why it's so dangerous, and that's why politicians love it so much. Bribe the electorate today, and let tomorrow's taxpayers foot the bill (with interest, of course).

That is why Osborne is right to say that it's morally wrong. Not only is it morally wrong, but cheap money (or free money, for that matter), also has a nasty habit of getting mis-spent. There are few checks and balances on a budget backed by blank cheques.

How do you ensure the NHS doesn't get ripped off by cunning medical staff recruitment firms? You make sure that budgets are tight. You don't offer a blank cheque as with anyone's finances, sobriety and prudence must be instilled.

Governments aren't like individuals: it may be good for us to borrow against a house, especially when we're young; we may equally save into a pension, and draw the benefits in later years. But the national accounts have an infinite lifespan only when that life is threatened (think war) should public borrowing be seen as a good thing.

Nations that borrow endlessly become worse off, not better off. It leads to lazy decision-making, and bad macro-economic policy. Well done George!

Recommended

The UK jobs market is still red hot – but will it last?
UK Economy

The UK jobs market is still red hot – but will it last?

For the first time ever, there are more job vacancies than people to fill them, and wages are rising at a decent clip. But that might just be a tempor…
17 May 2022
Get set for another debt binge as real interest rates fall
UK Economy

Get set for another debt binge as real interest rates fall

Despite the fuss about rising interest rates, they’re falling in real terms. That will blow up a wild bubble, says Matthew Lynn.
15 May 2022
Interest-rate rises mean more pain for stocks
Stockmarkets

Interest-rate rises mean more pain for stocks

Interest rates are rising around the world as central banks try to get inflation under control. That’s hitting stockmarkets – and there is more pain t…
13 May 2022
High inflation will fade – here’s why
Inflation

High inflation will fade – here’s why

Many people expect high inflation to persist for a long time. But that might not be true, says Max King. Inflation may fall faster than expected – and…
13 May 2022

Most Popular

Get set for another debt binge as real interest rates fall
UK Economy

Get set for another debt binge as real interest rates fall

Despite the fuss about rising interest rates, they’re falling in real terms. That will blow up a wild bubble, says Matthew Lynn.
15 May 2022
High inflation will fade – here’s why
Inflation

High inflation will fade – here’s why

Many people expect high inflation to persist for a long time. But that might not be true, says Max King. Inflation may fall faster than expected – and…
13 May 2022
Is the oil market heading for a supply glut?
Oil

Is the oil market heading for a supply glut?

Many people assume that the high oil price is here to stay – and could well go higher. But we’ve been here before, says Max King. History suggests tha…
16 May 2022