The good news about the housing crash

Desperate housebuilders are demanding the government 'do something' about the housing crash. But the credit crunch may mean that house prices settle at a level that genuinely reflects supply and demand.

This feature is just part of our FREE daily email. Sign up for Money Morning here .

Why housebuilders are demanding state hand-outs... More hilarity in the housing industry this weekend.

Builders are now demanding state help. As housing sales have collapsed, the construction industry faces mass redundancies, while house builders themselves have seen their share prices dive. Many look like they'll have to find more capital to shore up their balance sheets, and there was much speculation in the weekend papers about investment banks ganging up behind the scenes to prop the sector up.

Advertisement - Article continues below

With housing sales in freefall, builders aren't building anymore. It now looks as though just 100,000 homes will be built this year compared to a Government target of 240,000. That would be the lowest number built since 1945.

David Sutherland, chairman of housebuilder Tulloch, tells The Telegraph: "The UK housing target does not have a cat in hell's chance of being met this year or next. Somebody at central government needs to do something."

Advertisement - Article continues below

Two questions immediately arise in response to this plea. "What can the Government do?" and "Why should anything be done?"

Housebuilders are calling for government aid now that the housing market has gone into self-destruct mode. The Home Builders Federation is calling for stamp duty to be suspended and interest rates to be cut.

Sales are down 60% on this time last year, says Roger Humber of the House Builders Association. "No business or industry can survive that."

Advertisement - Article continues below

The housebuilders are indeed facing terrible times ahead. They've had their boom a boom never seen before, the likes of which they could never have dreamed of. Now they're having the bust that was always certain to follow that boom. Just as the boom was better than they could have hoped, so the bust will be worse than they'd ever imagined.

This is why housebuilders usually trade on low price to earnings ratios, by the way. It's because they are so brutally cyclical. Once the market turns, it turns badly, and the e' part of the p/e ratio drops off a cliff.

When activity drops off, the builders find they are left with assets plunging in value (their land banks) and they have to rapidly lay off workers to slash costs as sales dry up.

So no surprise that they now want someone to save them.

But this is capitalism, remember? This is the way it works. Throughout the boom, no one in the property industry was particularly keen to have the state intervening in the market any more than it already does. Home Information Packs (HIPs) for example, which started out as a broadly sensible idea, were ripped apart by the property industry until they were introduced in their current, worse than useless, state.

Advertisement - Article continues below
Advertisement - Article continues below

More to the point, there's nothing the Government can do. Stamp duty cuts? House prices are falling by about 2% a month at the moment. That's your stamp duty right there. Interest rate cuts? In case the builders hadn't noticed, rates have already fallen by three quarters of a point, and it hasn't made a bit of difference.

That's because banks still aren't keen to lend. There's been a curious reaction to this in the press recently. One leading property writer seems to be blaming Halifax among others for the seizure in the housing market, complaining that they are causing the house price crash by refusing to lend to creditworthy borrowers. Meanwhile, in The Telegraph, a reader's letter cites amazement at banks greedily ignoring the BoE's interest rate cuts.

It's important to understand that the banks aren't doing this out of spite or greed. This is not a matter of simply persuading them to start dishing out the readies again. The banks for anyone who didn't notice Northern Rock or Bradford & Bingley's travails are undergoing a bit of a crisis themselves. Halifax parent HBoS is right now crossing its fingers for its £4bn rights issue, while Royal Bank of Scotland has just raised £12bn.

Advertisement - Article continues below

To put it bluntly, the banks are skint. They gave too much money to people who couldn't pay it back, and now they're paying for it. They need all the money they can get. They don't care how good a credit risk you are they simply aren't in a position to be as profligate as they were before.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Sure, it's their own fault they got into this mess. But if you want to blame the banks for their reluctance to lend now, you also have to acknowledge that they were wrong to have been so free and easy with the credit in the first place. And that's something I suspect most property pundits would be reluctant to admit.

Anyway back to the point in hand. There's nothing the Government can do short of actually giving the housebuilders money (don't rule it out) to save the construction companies.

The good news is that with the free and easy access to credit that created the boom in the first place now gone, house prices will settle back to a level that genuinely reflects supply and demand. And with builders unable to build more houses (bye-bye to Gordon Brown's eco-towns, thank goodness), and foreign workers heading off back home in their droves, we'll soon see just how much of a housing shortage Britain really has.

Advertisement - Article continues below

I think we'll find it's less of a problem than the bulls have been making out.

Turning to the wider markets

Enjoying this article? Why not sign up to receive Money Morning FREE every weekday? Just click here: FREE daily Money Morning email.

The FTSE 100 recovered on Friday to rise 12 points to 5,802. HBoS was the biggest riser along with other banks as investors closed out short positions.

Meanwhile, in Europe, the German Xetra Dax climbed 50 to 6,765, while in Paris the French CAC 40 rose 10 points to close at 4,682.

Advertisement - Article continues below

In the US on Friday, stocks made strong gains as inflation data was in line with expectations and the dollar continued to rally. The Dow Jones rose 165 points to 12,307. The S&P 500 climbed 20 points to 1,360. And the Nasdaq rose 50 points to end at 2,454.

In the forex markets today, sterling was trading at 1.953 against the dollar and 1.2677 against the euro. The dollar stood at 0.6493 against the euro and 108.31 against the Japanese yen.

Advertisement - Article continues below

In Japan, stocks were higher as the weaker yen boosted earnings at car and electronics manufacturers. The Nikkei 225 climbed 380 points to close at 14,354.

Brent spot was trading this morning at $133.70, while in New York crude was trading at around $134.10. Spot gold was at $867 an ounce. Silver was trading at $16.49, while platinum was at $2,019.

This morning, Barclays' share price has risen after it said that it is actively considering selling shares to prop up its balance sheet. Profit for May was "well ahead" of last year's figure. Reports at the weekend suggest that any money raised would come both from sales to sovereign wealth funds and to existing investors.

Our recommended articles for today:

Why an interest-rate hike would mean a recession

The ECB's Jean-Claude Trichet caused a stir when he saidhe would raise interest rates. Other central banks would likely follow suit, but the effect on the global economy could be damaging.

Can the sickly dollar ever recover?

With the US economy slowing and the prospect of further banking pain, monetary policy makers will be hoping the dollar can get off its sick bed. But the future is looking bleak for the greenback.




Beyond the Brexit talk, the British economy isn’t doing too badly

The political Brexit pantomime aside, Britain is in pretty good shape. With near-record employment, strong wage growth and modest inflation, there is …
17 Oct 2019
UK Economy

Spend, spend, spend – think of it as your patriotic duty

After months of lockdown, many of us will have some money to spare. If you do, says Merryn Somerset Webb, spend it.
2 Jul 2020

House price crash: UK property prices are falling – so where next?

With UK property prices falling for the first time in eight years, are we about to see a house price crash? John Stepek looks at what’s behind the sli…
2 Jul 2020
UK Economy

Why the UK should be gunning for a trade deal Down Under

It might seem a minor matter compared with Brexit, but a trade agreement with Australia is a big deal
28 Jun 2020

Most Popular


The end of the bond bull market and the return of inflation

Central bank stimulus, surging post-lockdown demand and the end of the 40-year bond bull market. It all points to inflation, says John Stepek. Here’s …
30 Jun 2020

This chart pattern could be extraordinarily bullish for gold

The mother of all patterns is developing in the gold charts, says Dominic Frisby. And if everything plays out well, gold could hit a price that invest…
1 Jul 2020
Global Economy

How “pent-up demand” could drive a V-shaped economic recovery

“Pent-up demand” is usually a myth. But not this time. The Covid lockdown has created genuine pent-up demand, says Merryn Somerset Webb. That’s now be…
29 Jun 2020