Investors hoping to use stop losses to ride volatility "received a blow" recently as markets tumbled unexpectedly, says Alice Ross in the FT.
The trouble was not that stop losses didn't work, but that many worked too well.
As the market plunged on 6 May the Dow Jones crashed 9% in a matter of minutes - stop losses were triggered, cancelling many open trades. "Fine", you might think. But that left many investors on the sidelines as markets subsequently rallied.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
But stop losses are still a vital tool when it comes to avoiding losses that could cost you your shirt. Don't be put off by one freaky trading day.
The plain vanilla variety also the cheapest will ensure that if you hold, say, stocks at £3 and the price drops below £2.80 (your stop loss price), your position is automatically closed. But it suffers a major drawback called "gapping". That's where lots of orders are triggered together as the market drops and a broker executes them in strict price/time rotation. If yours is at the back of the queue, you may be closed out below your stop loss price.
- Spread betting The easy way to geared, tax-free returns
- Forex trading- How to profit from currency movements
Solutions include choosing an uneven price say £2.81 instead of £2.80 - that bumps you up the list. Or you could choose the guaranteed stop: these are pricier perhaps costing 1% of the value of a trade but they do what they say, and get you out at the price you specify.
Another neat variation on the theme is the trailing stop. This is where you choose a stop loss limit of, say, 25% (meaning it is triggered by a 25% price drop). If you then see your shares rise in value, the stop loss moves up too. That way you protect some of your cumulative gains in a bull market, whereas with a conventional stop loss you would only be closed out at your original price.
And whilst the events of that Thursday in New York may have been traumatic for anyone stopped out prematurely, as John Cotter at Barclays Stockbrokers puts it: "I've been spiked out when I didn't want to be. But am I glad I use them? Yes."
-
What does Reeves’s plan for growth mean for UK investors?Rachel Reeves says she is going “further and faster” to kickstart the UK economy, but investors are unlikely to be persuaded
-
Will China thrive during the Year of the Snake - or will Trump’s tariffs bite?As the Chinese lunar new year begins, investors will be wondering whether allocating to the world’s second-largest economy will “rattle” up some big returns, or whether Trump’s tariffs will take a “venomous bite” out of investment performance
