Tax wrangles will go to the wire

The government is divided over how to reform Britain's tax system. Are we unfairly taxing work and endeavour when we ought to be raising more money on property? Emily Hohler reports.

Budget negotiations are "entering their final phase", and the main disagreements are not between the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats, but within the Tory party itself, says Rachel Sylvester in The Times.

Discussion centres around whether extra taxes should be levied on income or wealth, dividing the party into two camps: The Economist magazine Tories, who see property as an asset (George Osborne), and the Country Life Conservatives who feel "an Englishman's home is his castle" (David Cameron).

At present, 44% of taxes come from income, 20% from business, 33% from consumption and 5% from land and property. Since taxes on labour are a "levy on endeavour and merit, whereas some part of accumulated wealth, in the words of John Stuart Mill, falls into our mouths while we sleep'", a mansion tax makes sense, says The Times.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE

Get 6 issues free

Sign up to Money Morning

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Sign up

Some people have lived in properties for decades and earn little, but they could pay the bill out of their estate. The top 1% of taxpayers already contribute 28% of income tax and the 50p rate makes Britain a less attractive place to do business.

The 50p rate "repels entrepreneurs and raises no money", which is why Gordon Brown waited until the final six weeks of his 13 years in Downing Street to implement it, says Fraser Nelson in The Daily Telegraph. He set a "bomb" under the public finances and bet the Tories hadn't "the nerve to defuse it". Britain's top rate of tax is the fourth highest on the planet.

Haven't we learned our lesson? When Nigel Lawson cut the rate from 60% to 40% in 1989, Britain became a "magnet for the world's entrepreneurs" and the "tax share collected from the top 1% soared". A Treasury report into the 50p rate's effects is underway, but figures suggest it's a flop, says the Daily Mail. The Centre for Economic and Business Research says it could end up "losing money" for the Treasury.

Scrap the "unloved" 50p rate, but property should be properly taxed too, says Simon Jenkins in The Guardian. "Housing is the most inefficient, mal-distributed, under-taxed and... over-priced asset in the land." Britons live more "lavishly" than any other big European nation, council tax is unfair, and some 100,000 properties are avoiding stamp duty in offshore tax havens. What's more, the "biggest unexploited housing resource in Britain is empty and under-occupied property".

Nick Clegg says the Liberal Democrats would scrap the 50p rate in return for a 1% levy on properties worth more than £2m, but he and David Cameron have "called a truce" on the mansion tax, says Roland Watson in The Times. The government is examining new curbs on the tax relief on pension contributions given to higher earners, particularly those earning more than £150,000, and other ideas for a crackdown on the wealthy are being discussed. "Wrangling" before 21 March will "go to the wire".

Emily Hohler

Emily has worked as a journalist for more than thirty years and was formerly Assistant Editor of MoneyWeek, which she helped launch in 2000. Prior to this, she was Deputy Features Editor of The Times and a Commissioning Editor for The Independent on Sunday and The Daily Telegraph. She has written for most of the national newspapers including The Times, the Daily and Sunday Telegraph, The Evening Standard and The Daily Mail, She interviewed celebrities weekly for The Sunday Telegraph and wrote a regular column for The Evening Standard. As Political Editor of MoneyWeek, Emily has covered subjects from Brexit to the Gaza war.

Aside from her writing, Emily trained as Nutritional Therapist following her son's diagnosis with Type 1 diabetes in 2011 and now works as a practitioner for Nature Doc, offering one-to-one consultations and running workshops in Oxfordshire.